This thread has been very helpful. I have a Sprint GS4 and used the command-line method to enable encryption and a different PIN on 4.2.2. Now, I've had to use Kies to update my phone to 4.3 and the entire device had to be wiped. So I don't have encryption yet. But I've got root access, so at least that's working. My problem is that I can't get either command line encryption nor the built-in encryption to work. The phone reboots but when it comes back on a couple of minutes later, it isn't encrypted. I attempted to use adb logcat, but the file I redirected the output to was empty after the phone restarted. Honestly, I sure I'm not using it correctly. My beliefe is that /data is not being unmounted, but I don't know how to figure out what's preventing it. If anyone has any tips on how to get the logging working, or insight into what else be wrong, I would appreciate it.
There is nothing else I've done to the phone that I think is odd.
Thanks all.