3rd Party Battery

Avelnan

Senior Member
Dec 5, 2010
850
45
0
Chicago
I don't think third party batteries would work because of the battery script. I could possibly work if you are on punk.kaos's or jt1134's rom (CM7)

Sent from my SCH-I500 using XDA Premium App
 

imnuts

Inactive Recognized Developer
Jul 27, 2007
3,808
3,174
113
West Chester
www.imnuts.org
I don't think third party batteries would work because of the battery script. I could possibly work if you are on punk.kaos's or jt1134's rom (CM7)

Sent from my SCH-I500 using XDA Premium App
3rd Party batteries should work with any custom kernel. However, I have never read 3rd party batteries consistently outperforming the OEM battery. If you're looking for a cheap alternative for a "just in case" time, then they are good, but that is it.
 

AlexDeGruven

Senior Member
Mar 24, 2008
685
213
0
Ann Arbor
www.structuredthought.org
I don't know about necessarily outperforming the OEM battery. 1500mAh is 1500mAh. The only way it would really be different is if it was defective.

I have had great luck, myself, with this kit: http://cgi.ebay.com/3x-1500mAh-Batt...603758?pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item35b20f256e

Using a custom kernel (which I've been doing since pretty much day 1), it works perfectly (no warning popup).

I only use the included charger with the 3rd party batteries, though. I'm not up for taking chances on that part.
 

OhioYJ

Senior Member
Feb 25, 2011
1,354
655
133
So Am I understand this right? Aftermarket/oem batteries do not work with stock kernal?-AT
They work "fine" with a stock phone, they just can't be charged in the phone. Which is why a lot of ebay auctions include an external charger. I have 5 batteries, all Samsung, last batch I got out of China $2 each. I use the OTB kernel which allows me to charge non-fascinate batteries in the phone, however, I rarely do. The external chargers are very nice I just swap to a fresh batery and throw the dead one in the charger.
 

nunyazz

Senior Member
Oct 7, 2010
577
149
0
BTR
The Seidio batteries work fine for both stock and with custom roms/kernals. They charge fine in the phone and run fine. No issues.
 

vapermonkey

Senior Member
Sep 27, 2010
114
18
0
St Cloud MN
3500 mAH battery

Update us on this. Let us know how it works and how the life is. Im looking into one as well.

OK for starters i am running the latest miui ROM and loving it. for the battery it wont work on my wife's phone with a older ROM cant remember what she has on it.
for the battery i was getting about no more then 8 hours running Pandora all day at work now i can get about 2.5 days on one charge with going to work and listing to pandora for 2 days at work. so i think if you pick a good rom that supports it go for it :)
 

duganator1

New member
Aug 13, 2010
1
0
0
OK for starters i am running the latest miui ROM and loving it. for the battery it wont work on my wife's phone with a older ROM cant remember what she has on it.
for the battery i was getting about no more then 8 hours running Pandora all day at work now i can get about 2.5 days on one charge with going to work and listing to pandora for 2 days at work. so i think if you pick a good rom that supports it go for it :)
That sounds great vapermonkey. About how deep is the phone after adding the new battery?
 
Last edited:

pbiddy19

Member
Apr 2, 2011
11
0
0
I saw a study a while back about 3rd party batteries. The majority of the 3rd party batteries tested, were garbage, weren't what they were actually rated as, and were far inferior to the stock batteries. However, there are some 3rd party batteries that are made by reputable companies; that being said, I wouldn't trust the China made crap batteries sold on Ebay. :D
 

vapermonkey

Senior Member
Sep 27, 2010
114
18
0
St Cloud MN
I saw a study a while back about 3rd party batteries. The majority of the 3rd party batteries tested, were garbage, weren't what they were actually rated as, and were far inferior to the stock batteries. However, there are some 3rd party batteries that are made by reputable companies; that being said, I wouldn't trust the China made crap batteries sold on Ebay. :D
On that note, I have had no problems with my battery phone is running great with my Hong Kong battery life 3500 mAH I think i got it from gadgets and gizmos


Sent from my I500 using XDA App
 

monkeypuncher

New member
Jan 9, 2008
1
0
0
I just got a seidio battery for my telus samsung galaxy s fascinate... And it's not charging at all. Had it in the phone and plugged into the charger all night last night. The charge went down to zero % and then when I unplugged the phone, it shut itself off due to the lack of charge. My phone is stock with no roms added, just the firmware upgrades. I'm at a loss.
 

dogg94

Senior Member
Jan 6, 2011
245
39
58
Wisconsin
I have a 2300 mah I got from Amazon for 15$ I believe, however it was listed as 3000 mah. makes a big difference

Sent from my SCH-I500 using XDA App
 

davwman

Senior Member
Nov 11, 2010
4,700
863
253
Centereach
samsung epic 4g touch fits perfectly at 1800mah. Only downfall is a custom kernel with 3rd party battery monitoring removed is needed

Sent from my SCH-I500 using XDA App