I have been using the LG Style-i. Yes, it is another device to keep charged up, but the battery time is several days with modest use. The sound and volume quality are very good. I had an interferrence problem while using the Style-i near an active 2.4 GHz cordless phone, it totally garbled the call. The LED screen is difficult to read in bright outdoor light. Overall it is much more desriable than using the Athena as a speakerphone. I would not ever consider holding the phone up to the side of my head. I also have a Jawbone but wearing the earpiece full time isn't acceptable in business and fumbling with it when a call comes in problematic. Picking up the LG is simple and quick by comparison.