[APP][Q][XPOSED] GravityBox v10.1.2 for Android 10 [07/03/2021]

[HippoMan]

I don't see a reason why that would be related to magisk in any way. But anyway I am using stable version of magisk in combination with EdXposed build 4661 and riru 23.1 on my op7pro and everything is fine. Maybe check if you didn't forget to enable master switch for navbar tweaks. This is necessary for full navigation key actions compatibility.

Thank you and the rest of you for your responses.

Yes, I did enable the master switch.

And the only thing different between the two cases is the version of Magisk. Everything else is exactly the same. The navbar buttons are remappable for me under Magisk 20.4 but not under Magisk 21.2. Magisk version 20.4 is the stable version, and it also works for me. As I mentioned, the only time the problem occurs is when I am using the beta version of Magisk, i.e., 21.2.

I don't have time at the moment to reinstall 21.2 and collect logs, etc., and I just asked here about this now, in case anyone might have seen this before and might have a quick suggestion for a fix. Later when I have more time (possibly as late as this coming weekend), I'll try again and do more extensive debugging involving log files.

 

[AlDollaz]

After installing Magisk 21.2, navigation keys actions no longer work.

 

[C3C076]

Thank you and the rest of you for your responses.

Yes, I did enable the master switch.

And the only thing different between the two cases is the version of Magisk. Everything else is exactly the same. The navbar buttons are remappable for me under Magisk 20.4 but not under Magisk 21.2. Magisk version 20.4 is the stable version, and it also works for me. As I mentioned, the only time the problem occurs is when I am using the beta version of Magisk, i.e., 21.2.

I don't have time at the moment to reinstall 21.2 and collect logs, etc., and I just asked here about this now, in case anyone might have seen this before and might have a quick suggestion for a fix. Later when I have more time (possibly as late as this coming weekend), I'll try again and do more extensive debugging involving log files.

After installing Magisk 21.2, navigation keys actions no longer work.

Strange. Not sure what's causing this as module has nothing to do with Magisk. There is relation to EdXposed only. Might be that EdXposed has some issues with that Magisk version. Note that I am running Magisk 21.2 on Android 11 and navigation keys work as expected.

 

[Lord Sithek]

Strange. Not sure what's causing this as module has nothing to do with Magisk. There is relation to EdXposed only. Might be that EdXposed has some issues with that Magisk version. Note that I am running Magisk 21.2 on Android 11 and navigation keys work as expected.

I can confirm that some kind of an issue exist. In my case, after updating to Magisk 21.2 (released as stable recently) GravityBox can't be loaded at all. My device is Samsung Galaxy Tab S5e Wi-Fi. Sorry I'm not providing logs, I'm in a similiar position as @HippoMan.

Probably like you say, it's an issue with EdXposed itself, since Xposed Edge Pro doesn't work as well. (Strangely it works well on my Xiaomi Mi Note 10, so maybe it's device dependent too).

 

[Pandemic]

Same issue here on my xperia 1 with android 10..
when i update to stable magisk 21.2.. Its not a edxposed issue for sure because i use this and the xposed module call recorder by @serajr and when i update to magisk 21.2 the call recorder works fine and Gravitybox not.

 

[HippoMan]

Strange. Not sure what's causing this as module has nothing to do with Magisk. There is relation to EdXposed only. Might be that EdXposed has some issues with that Magisk version. Note that I am running Magisk 21.2 on Android 11 and navigation keys work as expected.

Thank you very much. In my case, I'm running TaiChi and not EdXposed, so it isn't related to EdXposed itself. When I have time over the next several days or week, I'll try EdXposed again and see if that might make a difference. I stopped using EdXposed because it was causing me to fail SafetyNet, while SafetyNet passes under TaiChi.

Maybe under 21.2, EdXposed will no longer trigger SafetyNet failure, in which case I will go back to it ... as long as I can get the nav key remapping to work in GravityBox, of course.

But again, I don't have time to test this for at least the next few days.

 

[HippoMan]

I ended up having some unexpected spare time today, so I tried some things, and my problem with the nav key remapping has been solved!

First of all, I had accidentally installed 10.0.1 of GravityBox instead of 10.1.0, so I installed that latest GravityBox version and went back to Magisk 21.2 to test it. Unfortunately, that didn't make a difference with the nav key remap problem.

But then, I decided to try EdXposed again instead of TaiChi. I installed 23.1 of Riru, v4.5.7 of EdXposed Manager, and 93-v0.5.1.4_4655-master (YAHFA). Now, the GravityBox nav key remapping started working under Magisk 21.2.

And also, with the "Pass SafetyNet" setting selected in EdXposed Manager, I am indeed passing SafetyNet now.

So, it seems like it was a problem with TaiChi interacting with Magisk 21.2.

This is on my OnePlus 7 Pro (GM-1917) running Android 10 (OOS 10.3.7) and TWRP 3.5.0_9-0

Thanks again to all for your suggestions as I was trying to solve this.

 

[AlDollaz]

Updated to the latest Canary of EdXposed 0.5.1.4_4667 and that fixed the navigation key actions using Magisk 21.2.

 

[archz2]

Today I updated my magisk to 21.2 on my OnePlus 5T running stock Oxygen OS 10. After that, I'm continuously getting the error.

"Gravitybox framework system not responding. Exiting."

I uninstalled and re-installed latest gravity box but still facing the same issue even after reboots.

My edxposed version is v0.4.6.4 (4563) (SandHook). I have attached error log generated from edxposed.

Please help.

 

[archz2]

Updated to the latest Canary of EdXposed 0.5.1.4_4667 and that fixed the navigation key actions using Magisk 21.2.

What is your riru version?

 

[Lord Sithek]

Today I updated my magisk to 21.2 on my OnePlus 5T running stock Oxygen OS 10. After that, I'm continuously getting the error.

"Gravitybox framework system not responding. Exiting."

I uninstalled and re-installed latest gravity box but still facing the same issue even after reboots.

My edxposed version is v0.4.6.4 (4563) (SandHook). I have attached error log generated from edxposed.

Please help.

Seems like latest Magisk has issues with stable edxposed. I suppose the solution at the moment is update to Riru 23 and EdXposed canary or revert to Magisk 20.4

 

[archz2]

Seems like latest Magisk has issues with stable edxposed. I suppose the solution at the moment is update to Riru 23 and EdXposed canary or revert to Magisk 20.4

I updated to Riru 23 aand edxposed to 5.1.4_4655 -master. I used the alpha version.

Now Gravity box is running fine. Thanks!
I was scared about canary as they are known to be quite unstable.

 

[Lord Sithek]

I updated to Riru 23 aand edxposed to 5.1.4_4655 -master. I used the alpha version.

Now Gravity box is running fine. Thanks!
I was scared about canary as they are known to be quite unstable.

Because of the change in Riru since 23, it's taking some time to get EdXposed working good again. Recent builds seem to work ok though. Hope next stable release is on its way

 

[Pandemic]

Updating to magisk 21.2 stable and reinstall the xposed framework (sandhook) + rirucore 21.3 solved the problem

 

[AlDollaz]

What is your riru version?

23.3

 

[iElvis]

Magisk 21.2, Riru 23.3, and EdXposed 5.1.4_4655-master are working fine for me on 10.1.0.

 

[MaXAiRO]

I'm back to using my good old OnePlus 5 on OOS 10.0.1 + GravityBox after 4 months of using a Poco F2 Pro which I eventually sold.

I have some issues I would like to discuss:

1. Whenever I set any action to any navigation key in GB settings, there's a double vibration everytime I tap on all 3 buttons (back, home, recents) instead of one. Even when I set home double tap to trigger screen off either through stock OOS settings or GB settings, after the screen turns off, there's an extra short vibration after the double tap. I saw some people mentioning it here a while ago (I remember @sjamie for sure) but I couldn't find any workaround/solution.

2. Date format for status bar clock customization gets deactivated after the first time the clock refreshes (when a minute passes). The only workaround is to enable clock seconds. I also saw people mentioning it here a while ago and someone solved it by uninstalling Edge Sense Plus which I don't use. I tried deactivating Xposed Edge which I use in case there's any conflict but the clock date still disappears. I also tried with GB 10 beta 7 and 10.0.1 but it was the same.

3. Is it possible to add an option in Media tweaks to include more audio streams in the expand button on the regular "small" volume panel? Now it's possible to use more audio streams only with the "Expanded volume panel" but it's really intrusive because only the expanded volume panel shows up and not the smaller one first.

 

[C3C076]

I'm back to using my good old OnePlus 5 on OOS 10.0.1 + GravityBox after 4 months of using a Poco F2 Pro which I eventually sold.
I have some issues I would like to discuss:

1) yeah. This one is always tricky. When I achieve it correctly behaves on one system the it behaves differently on another system. Can't manage to cover them all. No such issue on my Oneplus 7pro which is even the same Brand

2) module <-> system incompatibility. Similar to 1). And again no problem on Oneplus 7pro.

3) I'll have to check current design if there's a possibility to choose streams while expanded volume feature is disabled.

 

[Machine318]

I'm back to using my good old OnePlus 5 on OOS 10.0.1 + GravityBox.

Double check thru the past few pages, make sure you are running the right combo of riru, edexposed & GB.

Doesn't hurt to double check. I have a 5T that's it's working fine on.

 

[MaXAiRO]

1) yeah. This one is always tricky. When I achieve it correctly behaves on one system the it behaves differently on another system. Can't manage to cover them all. No such issue on my Oneplus 7pro which is even the same Brand

2) module <-> system incompatibility. Similar to 1). And again no problem on Oneplus 7pro.

3) I'll have to check current design if there's a possibility to choose streams while expanded volume feature is disabled.

1. Sorry for mentioning another module here but I eventually assigned the actions that I wanted using Xposed Edge which doesn't trigger a second vibration. Only the first short vibration takes place when I tap the button for the first time.

2. About 1 hour after I made the post, the clock date appeared and never disappeared again till I rebooted today morning just to check if it's gonna stay or not. I don't know what triggered the date to appear yesterday, maybe the refresh in the hour digits (?)

3. Also, would it be possible to add the option to choose on which side of the screen the volume panel appears?

Double check thru the past few pages, make sure you are running the right combo of riru, edexposed & GB.

Doesn't hurt to double check. I have a 5T that's it's working fine on.

I don't know if it really matters what version of Riru + EdXposed I use. What matters is that the module is activated I guess. I still use Riru 21.3 + EdXposed 0.4.6.4 and all GB features I use work fine except for the ones I mentioned above. If Ceco advises me to upgrade to 23 + 0.5.x I'll do it just to test.

Also, 5T doesn't have capacitive keys like the 5. You can only use navigation bar keys and the vibration may be different on them.