[AUDIO][EXYNOS][OREO][V-1.7.0] Samsung SoundAlive Dolby Atmos - EOL

Androiddsm

Member
Dec 10, 2011
9
1
0
Sry dude but wichout custom recovery you cant install this.
And remember after installing custom recovery your knox is tripped.
I thought I saw something in the thread for non-root? Wish Samsung would just put it in an update. I don't see the issue. Oh well. I still enjoy it with one speaker. ?
 

ImbaWind

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2011
1,774
3,895
143
?
I thought I saw something in the thread for non-root? Wish Samsung would just put it in an update. I don't see the issue. Oh well. I still enjoy it with one speaker. ?
Yeah I thought there was a method mentioned somewhere that worked with non rooted devices?
If you are sure that there's a method somewhere here, pretty sure that you can use the search button eh?
Not sure why you guys keep saying about root, we don't normally use root to flash thing here, unless you want to move the file manually using a file explorer. For the Exynos version, you only need TWRP recovery to flash zip.
 

Androiddsm

Member
Dec 10, 2011
9
1
0
If you are sure that there's a method somewhere here, pretty sure that you can use the search button eh?
Not sure why you guys keep saying about root, we don't normally use root to flash thing here, unless you want to move the file manually using a file explorer. For the Exynos version, you only need TWRP recovery to flash zip.
That's the thing. I'm not really sure. I was reading it from a Google search where the results lead to here. It may not work for me anyways, I'm on the Snapdragon variant. I can't root because I use Samsung Pay. But if there is a version for non-rooted Snapdragon I'll be all over it. Thanks for the work that you do. ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ImbaWind

k2065183s

Senior Member
Oct 8, 2016
73
19
0
Chiayi
That's the thing. I'm not really sure. I was reading it from a Google search where the results lead to here. It may not work for me anyways, I'm on the Snapdragon variant. I can't root because I use Samsung Pay. But if there is a version for non-rooted Snapdragon I'll be all over it. Thanks for the work that you do. ?
Well,using TWRP doesn't means rooting your phone,but yeah,if ur using spay,then you can't use TWRP,it'll trigger KNOX 0x1 and can't be restore.
 

ImbaWind

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2011
1,774
3,895
143
?
That's the thing. I'm not really sure. I was reading it from a Google search where the results lead to here. It may not work for me anyways, I'm on the Snapdragon variant. I can't root because I use Samsung Pay. But if there is a version for non-rooted Snapdragon I'll be all over it. Thanks for the work that you do. ?
Have you read the first post?

EDIT: Theres a Snapdragon version done by another dev, but Im not sure if it works for you since Im using a Exynos version and unfortunately have no idea how Snapdragon version installs mod.
 
Last edited:

EJIS

Member
Sep 23, 2017
13
0
0
The sound alive with 2 points in bass+ Dolby Atmos on in automatic+ viper4 Android with a headphones specific profile+ Bose q25= best audio I have heard in a phone. The clarity and the bass are incredible. A really good job, thx from an audiophile!!!!!
 
Last edited:

popmpopm

Senior Member
Apr 26, 2012
618
127
63
CHLEF
ask if dolby atmos work with Bluetooth speakers in S9 !! no effect with me with s8 !! but its working with me before with dolbyatmos hacked app !!
sorry but no effect with headphone too !!! ( s8 stock rom rooted + soundlive reinstalled 8.0.35 )
after flaching soundlive 8.0.66 soundlive return to work but dolby still no effect !!
 
Last edited:

TheDevelopper

Senior Member
Apr 6, 2018
355
42
28
The zips will not flash because your updater-script is mounting the system specific to the by name of the exynos model s8 so if trying to flash on a snapdragon variant the system mount is different so you may want to just use busybox to mount system in updater-script instead of by-name block specific

@jrkruse, will this work if I pushed the files manually into system? with my rooted Snapdragon Galaxy S7 edge or it will not work at the end? so, flashing this with Flashfire or Safestrap will not be done at all because of the updated scripts
 

jrkruse

Recognized Contributor
Aug 9, 2009
8,048
12,255
263
@jrkruse, will this work if I pushed the files manually into system? with my rooted Snapdragon Galaxy S7 edge or it will not work at the end? so, flashing this with Flashfire or Safestrap will not be done at all because of the updated scripts
It dont work on Qualcomm S7. Says it does but it changes the sound in no way. You can't tell any difference
 
  • Like
Reactions: slimcyril

ImbaWind

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2011
1,774
3,895
143
?
You reused my work (Although you didn't specify in your thread, I can still recognize my work, structure, etc) but there's something in the updater-script that you don't actually need:
In updater-script:
Code:
delete_recursive("/system/etc/permission");
My installer has this because in previous build I make a typo, you don't need this since you 'made' a new Dolby installer

Bloated files
In /system/etc:
sapa_feature.xml
This has something to do with Samsung Android Professional Audio, which I believe is related to Soundcamp, but I don't think it has anything to do with the sound you hear.
TL;DR: It has nothing to do with Dolby Atmos and won't 'fix' your audio volume

In /system/lib(64) & /system/vendor/lib(64)
You have quite a few of conflicting audio library files, in /system/lib/soundfx & /system/vendor/lib/soundfx for example, since the system will only pick one to use, I'm not sure which one the system picks and this might/might not cause problem.

Inclusion of libs of different version
You do not need both
lib_SoundBooster_ver810.so
&
lib_SoundBooster_ver900.so
since libsamsungSoundbooster_plus.so will only pick one of them to use depends on it's version.

Probably non-related libs
I see that you included secure_storage libs, does secure storage has anything to do with Dolby and audio volume? Since secure_storage has something to do with wifi password & bluetooth and is ROM/kernel dependent (I might be wrong here), I don't think that it's a good idea to include them into a general mod.

My probably useful suggestions
Also I don't think that those libs from my BRG6 libs package (or other Android version) have anything to do with audio volume / Dolby. I reckon the only thing that made the volume louder in your mod is the inclusion of:
1. mixer_gains.xml - which made the volume louder
2. mixer_paths.xml - which enabled the dual speaker

So to be honest, essentially you can remove other not as useful, or useless stuff, put these two files in and voila, a Dolby mod with audio volume 'fixed'. And this is better in many ways since you will have lesser files so smaller package, lesser conflicts and thus lesser problems.

Since I also use a self-edited mixer_gains and mixer_paths, I don't actually have the volume problem and thus quite lazy to test it at the moment.
If there's anything in my mod that made the audio volume not as loud as before, I'd probably suspect the SoundBooster component, try to install my Dolby mod with those files removed and see if it improves. (You will have to restore your rom files if you installed my Dolby mod before, as those files are overwritten by my installer)
There are also quite a few of stuffs that you might be able to improve, for example:
1. Edit floating_feature.etc intelligently during installation, add only needed lines & leave other lines untouched to ensure best compatibility
2. Edit carrier feature files or add a init.d file to have the UHQ and Dolby tiles enabled

:cool:


*TO EVERYONE:
If you can prove that you are better than me in this and has the ability to take this mod to another level (understand the linkage between different libs, understand how these stuff work together, the ability to create a more intelligent installer, Linux scripting and probably a unified installer for both Exynos and Snapdragon), honestly I'm more than happy that you can take over the update of this mod. I will close this thread so that you can create your own thread and continue your development there (and earn all the thanks button if you are into that, I was but I'm not anymore) since this will avoid confusion of having two threads. I have the intention to work on aforementioned updates when I have time but I'm a busy engineering student and would love to flash other people's work too without maintaining the thread.
TL;DR: I welcome all challengers to take over this thread if you can prove that you are well-knowledged & better, I'm happy to just slack and flash! :angel:


Let's make xda-developers great again!
 
Last edited: