Budget Wireless Charger Showdown: 5 Qi Chargers all $11 - $15

Friko

Senior Member
Mar 28, 2011
54
4
0
Is the battery supposed to drain faster with the wireless receiver attached?
My S3's battery is draining at twice the normal speed when the receiver is plugged to the pogo pins.
 

fedor12

Senior Member
Mar 24, 2013
199
19
0
I got the rectangle with LEDs today and i just have to say it is fantastic absolutely superior to the puck charger and like you noted the area of recognition is excellent, the temps seem to be cooler than the puck aswell but haven't tested this properly yet but from 40% to 70% battery temp reached 38.8c with the puck this would have been 40c+. What surprised me was that the cable it came with is not the typical 500mA data cables that always come with cheap charges it gives the exact same output as the stock lg cable so this was a nice surprise. At £6.82 i consider it a bargain

Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
 

cnewlol

Member
Apr 28, 2014
11
2
0
Durham
I got the rectangle with LEDs today and i just have to say it is fantastic absolutely superior to the puck charger and like you noted the area of recognition is excellent, the temps seem to be cooler than the puck aswell but haven't tested this properly yet but from 40% to 70% battery temp reached 38.8c with the puck this would have been 40c+. What surprised me was that the cable it came with is not the typical 500mA data cables that always come with cheap charges it gives the exact same output as the stock lg cable so this was a nice surprise. At £6.82 i consider it a bargain

Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Noticed you used £. Any chance you'd be able to tell me where you got yours from?

After reading the OP made me wanna buy a wireless since I always dangle the phone when I'm picking it up whilst in bed, so would make my life so much easier!
thanks
 

fedor12

Senior Member
Mar 24, 2013
199
19
0
Noticed you used £. Any chance you'd be able to tell me where you got yours from?

After reading the OP made me wanna buy a wireless since I always dangle the phone when I'm picking it up whilst in bed, so would make my life so much easier!
thanks
Here you go http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/251485173...eName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1497.l2649 delivered from the uk so shipping wont take too long, at the price im thinking of ordering another one lol

Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
 

mmmmBACON

Senior Member
Mar 3, 2011
807
1,052
0
Winnipeg
I got the rectangle with LEDs today and i just have to say it is fantastic absolutely superior to the puck charger and like you noted the area of recognition is excellent, the temps seem to be cooler than the puck aswell but haven't tested this properly yet but from 40% to 70% battery temp reached 38.8c with the puck this would have been 40c+. What surprised me was that the cable it came with is not the typical 500mA data cables that always come with cheap charges it gives the exact same output as the stock lg cable so this was a nice surprise. At £6.82 i consider it a bargain

Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
You lucked out with the cable! That doesn't happen often.

Yeah I still quite like the Rectangle w/LEDs charger. That is the charger I've had the longest (and started my Qi charger addiction) and it's been rock solid stable since day one! I also like that it's not terribly small, it fits the phone just perfectly and keeps everything nice and stable.

I went through a bit of a phase looking for the smallest QI chargers around. That's kind of why I got the Q5 Puck (I've since sold both). I found though, that I wasn't the biggest fan of having to balance my phone right on the centre, or finding that sweet spot.

The Rectangle w/LEDs being larger is the perfect size for a bigger phone. And like I mentioned in the OP, area of recognition is just so much more forgiving. It's definitely the lazy man's Qi charger! :laugh: No balancing, no need to be 100% precise. Just put it down generally in the middle, and you're good to go!

I might do a 2 month update to the OP in a week or so, with my current opinions of all of the Qi chargers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: communeist

fedor12

Senior Member
Mar 24, 2013
199
19
0
Bacon i know you said you have opened up the rectangle without LEDs but have you opened the one with LEDs yet? I ask as if opening/closing is easy i would like to stick some magnets with some double sided tape for easy removal if need be under the base to see how it works (i dont want to go breaking it as i only just got it yesterday lol) as my phone slips off pretty easily with my ringke fusion case so want a way to make it stay on, another way is finding a thin non slip material to stick on top but want to try the magnet route 1st if i can open it up without breaking the charger

Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
 

mmmmBACON

Senior Member
Mar 3, 2011
807
1,052
0
Winnipeg
Bacon i know you said you have opened up the rectangle without LEDs but have you opened the one with LEDs yet? I ask as if opening/closing is easy i would like to stick some magnets with some double sided tape for easy removal if need be under the base to see how it works (i dont want to go breaking it as i only just got it yesterday lol) as my phone slips off pretty easily with my ringke fusion case so want a way to make it stay on, another way is finding a thin non slip material to stick on top but want to try the magnet route 1st if i can open it up without breaking the charger

Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Yeah, I've opened up one of them as well. It has a slightly larger and different designed circuit board than the other (w/o LEDs) charger. The coil is also located directly above the grill, sitting on top of a rubbery/squishy pad.

Popping the top cover off won't damage the Qi charger itself as it isn't attached to the top. What may end up happening (which I did :eek: because I couldn't find my pry tool so used a flat mini screw driver...) is it's possible that you might snap some of the hook tabs that hold the cover in place (it's the same type of thing as the hook tabs that hold the back cover on to the Nexus 5). It's not a terribly big deal because there are so damn many of them!! Just don't snap them ALL and you'll still be able to close it with no problems.

There are 12 around the outside that you pop out of place, and 2 more slightly inside (these seem totally unnecessary).
 

fedor12

Senior Member
Mar 24, 2013
199
19
0
I just tried opening it and it didn't go too well i used a flat end small screwdriver and while i was carefully trying to open it without the damaging the hooks i noticed as i was sliding the screwdriver across there was this white residue coming off which i think may have been glue? Anyway i got halfway but noticed the parts that i managed to take apart a little wont stick back on so im probably going to have to use super glue

Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
 

haris013

Senior Member
Dec 27, 2011
87
2
0
hi guys!
i own a N5 and i started to look for a wireless charges because i found it very cool and useful!
my question is ,what's the difference between an expensive charger and these bargains from the OP?
Are the expensive chargers safer to use for our phone?
Will any of these cheap charges harm my phone or the battery?
is it true that wireless charging harms the battery because of the high temps ?
does it worth to buy an expensive charger?
sorry for the many questions :D
 

Andypandiiee

Senior Member
Nov 7, 2013
323
44
0
To the owners of the Rectangle w/ LEDs, are you experiencing the problem where when it reaches 100%, it stops charging, 2-30 seconds after it charges again then stops charging 2-30 seconds after and just keeps repeating? Is this bad for the battery? Thank you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: earendilSK

zjhehe

Member
Nov 17, 2013
42
7
0
20140502_194121.jpg

Received my CHOETECH T511 QI Inductive Wireless Charging Pad today from Amazon

So far so good, haven't been able to test the auto-shut off feature yet. If you can see in the image, the black cord is included. However, I had to supply my own 2A wall adapter. Small blue light flashes twice when you plug USB in to it then a constant blue light when wirelessly charging. There are four rubber paddings on the bottom that grasp on really tight. The charging pad itself is made out of a rubberized material. So far, it is good. Capable of charging my Galaxy S4 with a wireless receiver inside protected by an Otterbox Defender case.
 

goofball2k

Senior Member
Oct 5, 2010
1,569
457
103
Ottawa
To the owners of the Rectangle w/ LEDs, are you experiencing the problem where when it reaches 100%, it stops charging, 2-30 seconds after it charges again then stops charging 2-30 seconds after and just keeps repeating? Is this bad for the battery? Thank you.
Yes, but mine usually doesn't reach 100%, it can happen randomly to me, it just will disconnect/reconnect, even though I haven't moved it from where it was and has been set charging for the previous hour or so.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Andypandiiee

haris013

Senior Member
Dec 27, 2011
87
2
0
hi guys!
i own a N5 and i started to look for a wireless charges because i found it very cool and useful!
my question is ,what's the difference between an expensive charger and these bargains from the OP?
Are the expensive chargers safer to use for our phone?
Will any of these cheap charges harm my phone or the battery?
is it true that wireless charging harms the battery because of the high temps ?
does it worth to buy an expensive charger?
sorry for the many questions :D
Anyone? I am confused help plz :)

Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
 

muyoso

Senior Member
Oct 23, 2007
2,492
492
0
hi guys!
i own a N5 and i started to look for a wireless charges because i found it very cool and useful!
my question is ,what's the difference between an expensive charger and these bargains from the OP?
Are the expensive chargers safer to use for our phone?
Will any of these cheap charges harm my phone or the battery?
is it true that wireless charging harms the battery because of the high temps ?
does it worth to buy an expensive charger?
sorry for the many questions :D
The expensive chargers like the nexus wireless charger are much more forgiving, in that you can throw your phone on it and it will charge without having to adjust the phone to be in the perfect position. The cheap qi charger I bought is MUCH less forgiving. Also, I feel the nexus charger is a bit faster to charge.

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
 

mmmmBACON

Senior Member
Mar 3, 2011
807
1,052
0
Winnipeg
hi guys!
i own a N5 and i started to look for a wireless charges because i found it very cool and useful!
my question is ,what's the difference between an expensive charger and these bargains from the OP?
Are the expensive chargers safer to use for our phone?
Will any of these cheap charges harm my phone or the battery?
is it true that wireless charging harms the battery because of the high temps ?
does it worth to buy an expensive charger?
sorry for the many questions :D
It really comes down to build quality for the most part and branding. If you look at the OP, I give a general rating of the build quality for each of the Qi chargers I tested. Some use a cheaper plastic for a casing, others are built nicer. The "Rectangle w/LEDs" and the "Q8" are the best built of the bunch. But don't think you are limited to those 5 I reviewed, there are TONs of Qi chargers out there, just look for whatever one you like. The only important thing is to make sure it outputs 1A.

The other difference is generally branding. For example, this Lugulake $19 Qi charger is exactly the same Qi charger as the "Rectangle w/LEDs" that is $12. The only difference, is that there is a Lugulake stamp on it...

There is no difference between the "expensive" and the "budget" ones in terms of performance. If the Qi charger has a rated output of 1A and is properly powered, they will all perform pretty much the same. It is a Qi standard. As long as it is followed, performance does as well. That is why, despite having 5 different Qi chargers, they all performed almost identically when powered correctly.

The cheap chargers and the expensive chargers use the exact same coil tech inside. There is nothing special about how a Qi charger works. Any of the risks you have with a cheap one, will be exactly the same on an expensive one.

The temperatures created from Qi charging are nothing compared to playing a graphically taxing game on your phone. People who tell you that the temperatures get too high, or it will destroy the battery are exaggerating. Qi charging is a standard, and it is built directly into the phone. Google uses it, Nokia uses it, Samsung provides adapters for it. It's fine. If you have ever played a game on your Nexus 5 where your frame rate drops heavily, you have been thermally throttled. That's an overheated GPU (and possibly CPU) that has been slowed to prevent damage and that is a battery temp that has probably jumped much higher than a Qi charger ever will cause.

Is an expensive Qi charger worth it? Not in my opinion. The performance is the same. If it has 1A output, and you power it properly, you will get the same performance whether it's $10 or $50. What you are really paying for is brand name, and build quality generally in terms of the outer casing. The internal coil etc. is all the same, as it follows the Qi standard.
 
Last edited:

haris013

Senior Member
Dec 27, 2011
87
2
0
It really comes down to build quality for the most part and branding. If you look at the OP, I give a general rating of the build quality for each of the Qi chargers I tested. Some use a cheaper plastic for a casing, others are built nicer. The "Rectangle w/LEDs" and the "Q8" are the best built of the bunch. But don't think you are limited to those 5 I reviewed, there are TONs of Qi chargers out there, just look for whatever one you like. The only important thing is to make sure it outputs 1A.

The other difference is generally branding. For example, this Lugulake $19 Qi charger is exactly the same Qi charger as the "Rectangle w/LEDs" that is $12. The only difference, is that there is a Lugulake stamp on it...

There is no difference between the "expensive" and the "budget" ones in terms of performance. If the Qi charger has a rated output of 1A and is properly powered, they will all perform pretty much the same. It is a Qi standard. As long as it is followed, performance does as well. That is why, despite having 5 different Qi chargers, they all performed almost identically when powered correctly.

The cheap chargers and the expensive chargers use the exact same coil tech inside. There is nothing special about how a Qi charger works. Any of the risks you have with a cheap one, will be exactly the same on an expensive one.

The temperatures created from Qi charging are nothing compared to playing a graphically taxing game on your phone. People who tell you that the temperatures get too high, or it will destroy the battery are exaggerating. Qi charging is a standard, and it is built directly into the phone. Google uses it, Nokia uses it, Samsung provides adapters for it. It's fine. If you have ever played a game on your Nexus 5 where your frame rate drops heavily, you have been thermally throttled. That's an overheated GPU (and possibly CPU) that has been slowed to prevent damage and that is a battery temp that has probably jumped much higher than a Qi charger ever will cause.

Is an expensive Qi charger worth it? Not in my opinion. The performance is the same. If it has 1A output, and you power it properly, you will get the same performance whether it's $10 or $50. What you are really paying for is brand name, and build quality generally in terms of the outer casing. The internal coil etc. is all the same, as it follows the Qi standard.
Thank you for the info!!
That was exactly the answer I was looking for!
:D


Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app