Since AOKP's latest build they've incorporated a system for us to choose our own Navigation Bar keys and the images. The keys that I'm going to post are from Gnexus Forum.
Most of these are by atticus182 and some are by other users. All the credit goes to him and I'm not here to steal anyone's credit. This thread is for i9100 guys to create or share softkey/nav. bar images.
My(atticus182) Softkeys 2.0 - Includes Back-Search-Home-Menu-Recent
My(atticus182) Softkeys - Includes Back-Search-Home-Recent
Please thank the respective users if you download any of these. They deserve it, especially atticus182
Also, share your keys and I'll add them to the first post whenever I can.
Most of these are by atticus182 and some are by other users. All the credit goes to him and I'm not here to steal anyone's credit. This thread is for i9100 guys to create or share softkey/nav. bar images.
My(atticus182) Softkeys 2.0 - Includes Back-Search-Home-Menu-Recent
Download from here(PNG)
Stock Style
Stock Reflective Style
Stock Small Style
Stock Small Reflective Style
HTC Style
HTC Reflective Style
HTC One Style
Win7 Style
Windroid Style
Windroid Hollow Style
dPhone Style
iPhoney Style
iPhoney White Style
PlayStation Style
PlayStation White Style
PlayDroid Style
PlayStation Buttons Style
PlayStation Buttons White Style
PlayDroid Buttons Style
Stock Style

Stock Reflective Style

Stock Small Style

Stock Small Reflective Style

HTC Style

HTC Reflective Style

HTC One Style

Win7 Style

Windroid Style

Windroid Hollow Style

dPhone Style

iPhoney Style

iPhoney White Style

PlayStation Style

PlayStation White Style

PlayDroid Style

PlayStation Buttons Style

PlayStation Buttons White Style

PlayDroid Buttons Style

My(atticus182) Softkeys - Includes Back-Search-Home-Recent
Download from here(IMAGES ONLY)
Stock Style
Stock Reflective Style
Stock Shadow Style
Stock Small Style
Stock Small Reflective Style
Stock Small Shadow Style
Stock ICS Blue Style
Stock ICS Blue Reflective Style
HTC Style
HTC Reflective Style
HTC Blue Style
HTC Blue Reflective Style
Airbrush Style
Airbrush ICS Blue Style
Balloon Style
Metro White Style
Metro Blue Style
Web2.0 Text Style
Pixelated Text Style
Pixelated ICS Blue Text Style
Roboto V2 Style
Roboto ICS Blue Text Style
Old Honeycomb Style
Metal Square Style
Blossom Style
Simplistica Style
Droidfont Style
Imonaboat Style
Perspective Style
Floral Style
Honeycomb Style
Softkeys made by other xda-members
Download ICS Blue Stock Style Images created by sr-ha, you can thank him HERE
Download ICS Blue Reflection Style Images or ZipThemer created by hxdrummerxc, you can thank him HERE
Download Grunge Reflection Style Images or ZipThemer created by hxdrummerxc, you can thank him HERE
Download Blue Circles Style Images or ZipThemer created by s60mike, you can thank him HERE
Download Blue Honeycomb Style Images created by s60mike, you can thank him HERE
Download Blue OSCI Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE
Download Grey Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE
Download Grey Reflected Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE
Download Paperish Reflected Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE
Download Sticky Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE
Download Purple Stock Style Images created by SteroidalFish2, you can thank him HERE
Download Purple Reflective Style Images created by SteroidalFish2, you can thank him HERE
Download Yellow Stock Style Images created by SteroidalFish2, you can thank him HERE
Stock Style

Stock Reflective Style

Stock Shadow Style

Stock Small Style

Stock Small Reflective Style

Stock Small Shadow Style

Stock ICS Blue Style

Stock ICS Blue Reflective Style

HTC Style

HTC Reflective Style

HTC Blue Style

HTC Blue Reflective Style

Airbrush Style

Airbrush ICS Blue Style

Balloon Style

Metro White Style

Metro Blue Style

Web2.0 Text Style

Pixelated Text Style

Pixelated ICS Blue Text Style

Roboto V2 Style

Roboto ICS Blue Text Style

Old Honeycomb Style

Metal Square Style

Blossom Style

Simplistica Style

Droidfont Style

Imonaboat Style

Perspective Style

Floral Style

Honeycomb Style

Softkeys made by other xda-members
Download ICS Blue Stock Style Images created by sr-ha, you can thank him HERE

Download ICS Blue Reflection Style Images or ZipThemer created by hxdrummerxc, you can thank him HERE

Download Grunge Reflection Style Images or ZipThemer created by hxdrummerxc, you can thank him HERE

Download Blue Circles Style Images or ZipThemer created by s60mike, you can thank him HERE

Download Blue Honeycomb Style Images created by s60mike, you can thank him HERE

Download Blue OSCI Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE

Download Grey Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE

Download Grey Reflected Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE

Download Paperish Reflected Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE

Download Sticky Style Images created by nikosrs4, you can thank him HERE

Download Purple Stock Style Images created by SteroidalFish2, you can thank him HERE
Download Purple Reflective Style Images created by SteroidalFish2, you can thank him HERE
Download Yellow Stock Style Images created by SteroidalFish2, you can thank him HERE
Please thank the respective users if you download any of these. They deserve it, especially atticus182
Also, share your keys and I'll add them to the first post whenever I can.