Comdirect photoTAN app detecting root

[Conan179]

What about safetynet / unlocked bootloader?

open for me and the safetynet check is passed.

 

[planck0815]

open for me and the safetynet check is passed.

So you changed device fingerprint? What device do you use?

Me, I had to change the device fingerprint to force basic attestation.

 

[Conan179]

GitHub - kdrag0n/safetynet-fix: Google SafetyNet attestation workarounds for Magisk

Google SafetyNet attestation workarounds for Magisk - kdrag0n/safetynet-fix

github.com

Note 9

 

[swour]

What about safetynet / unlocked bootloader? (Stock ROM / SM-G991B)

Since my device is running a custom rom, the bootloader is unlocked and the known methods via Magisk to pass the check by Google have been applied. SafetyNet doesn't seem to play a role here. However it is generally a good idea to make sure it will pass to avoid running into trouble if not already a requirement for another app like Google Pay.

It could also be the phone is simply too old for some of the root detection methods to yield results.

 

[tko]

I flashed magisk Canary
...
After reboot, i can open phototan app one time witout root detetion, second (or more) time its cam the root decetion screen.

okay thats wierd.
btw i was only talking about the carnary manager app. i have 23.0 flashed .... no idea if that makes a difference...

manager app name is changed?

(just for info... my bootloader is unlocked, safetynet full pass)

 

[Conan179]

oh embarrassing embarrassing, after I switched to canary earlier, I forgot to hide the magisk app, just checked in and will now watch it.

 

[hueuebi]

I got it working as well.

Safety net is intact.

I only installed riru and riru unshared, I didn't bother renaming magisk.
Also I used magisk hide to hide all 3 photo tan processes.

 

[Conan179]

I have found my problem,
I created a module with the smali-patcher to always take a screenshot, even for apps protected by drm.
If this is running, the phototan app does not start, without a module it always starts.

 

[Knotte]

Hey folks, I'm glad to have found a fix here but I can't install this:
I download the code from https://github.com/vvb2060/riru-unshare as a Zip file, right? But when I try to install it in magisk it says "unzip error". Any suggestions what I'm doing wrong? Thanks a lot!

 

[Conan179]

Hey folks, I'm glad to have found a fix here but I can't install this:
I download the code from https://github.com/vvb2060/riru-unshare as a Zip file, right? But when I try to install it in magisk it says "unzip error". Any suggestions what I'm doing wrong? Thanks a lot!

code or release?

 

[Knotte]

code or release?

Ah, that's it! I opend the page on my phone and didn't find a download option, so I opened it on my PC but there I only downloaded the code, but I need to go to the latest release on the right. Thanks!

 

[Knotte]

Just went through this process. For me it was sufficiant to update to magisk v23, rename magisk, install riru and riru unshare, hide all processes of phototan app in magisk hide and *clear cache* only for phototan app. This way I did not have to re-activate the phototan app (nor to wait 2 days) again.

Thank you as well. I did not even have to rename Magisk, just install the modules, hide all 3 PhotoTAN processes, clear its cache, done!

 

[TheFerhatKing]

For me Commerzbank photoTan and Comdirect don't work. Note10+ Exynos (N975F) Android 11 One UI 3.1 May Patch DrKetan ROM.
Installed both modules, hidden in magisk and renamed magisk. Last time it worked was on February Security Patch. I still ask me why I tried it again after tried so much things out.

I still think that the SafetyNet Fix included in ROM does interrupt the Banking App, but ROM Developer doesn't care. Maybe I will change the ROM if I have time.

 

[Seppel007]

Hi, I got it working too with Magisk 23.0 then Hiding Magisk and

- installed the 2 Riru Modules (Riru v25.4.4 and Riru Unshare 2.0)
- applied magiskhide on all 3 processes of the phototan-app

Instantly works again (didnt use it since it updated to 8.3.0 and wasnt working anymore.

Machine: OnePlus 5 Android 9.0.11 unlocked/rooted

 

[Marty4]

Hi,

Is there anyone on rooted Android 11 who actually found a way to make the latest photoTAN app work?
I'm running out of ideas...

My current config:

• Magisk Canary with the following modules:
  • Riru 25.4.4
  • Riru - EdXposed
  • Riru - Enhanced mode for Magisk Hide
  • Systemless Hosts
  • Universal SafetyNet Fix

(disabling these modules doesn't make a difference)

• Magisk Hide: all three photoTAN processes enabled
• EdXposed Hide: photoTAN blacklisted
• SafetyNet passed with BASIC
• XPrivacyLua: "Get applications" restricted for photoTAN

Even Google Pay works like a charm! Any ideas what could be the problem for photoTAN?

 

[Conan179]

Is there anyone on rooted Android 11 who actually found a way to make the latest photoTAN app work?

Post 1

https://xdaforums.com/t/comdirect-phototan-app-detecting-root-fix-found.4274825/#post-84987761

 

[WK 85]

THX Comdirect is working on my Xiaomi Mi 9 lite with Android 10,

 

[hey_malik]

The riru fix works for me too. Many thanks for that.

Are there any experiences with doing os updates (OnePlus 6t/oxygenos) with the riru modules installed? Is there a need to uninstall them prior to an update?

 

[RfBob]

I'm on Oxygen OS 11.0.0.2 GM21BA on a OnePlus 7 Pro / Android 11
Finally managed to get it running with the following setup:

Magisk Canary f822ca5b (23001)
Magisk Manager Canary f822ca5b (23001) (21)
comdirect Phototan 8.3.0 (latest version atm)

1. Hid the three processes of phototan in Magisk Manager
2. renamed Magisk Manager to sth else (This did the trick in the end, I think. I had not known of the possibility to do so via magisks settings)
(3. Hid the Adaway process in Magisk Manager - propably not necessary) Propably not necessary. Will trigger new problems once adaway or the ROM itself need updating.
4. started phototan.

 

[ralphabt]

I managed to get it working (Magisk 23.0).

Using only riru unshare was not sufficient for me. A few root apps are installed on my phone, Magisk has been renamed. Still phototan crashed on startup. After trying many things, XPrivacyLua did the trick (-> disable XPosed Hide for phototan & restrict "Get applications" for phototan).

@RfBob AdAway is installed on my phone, I did not need to hide the process