[DEV][MODDING] CRT, Airview, 4-way reboot, ink effect, phone, sms..etc [9/Dec/2013]

[majdinj]

Well thanks but dont think eybee has something to do with it
Still I think its utterly without respect to take someones work and just compare it to a stock rom.
Then writing it down here as if it was made by you or you made a effort to make it work....
I think this even goes against the xda GPL.
This post is stopping me from makin a new rom.....
Will report this.

In the guide (the link I posted), it was mentioned that "Actual mod was done by RobbieHood and eybee1970" and the last edit to that post was 2 June 2013. so if you still think that I crossed the line by writing the guide for helping others, then I am sorry mate (although I didn't even post the mod, only the guide, thought by doing this I still respect you..) Also I did write the guide only after pressuring from others..
I don't say that you shouldn't report to moderator though,,, but please consider this issue, I didn't even mention that was my work..
Even if I got some action from moderators by your report, I will never hate a good brother like you, so please don't hate me..

Regards

 

[ezaechiel]

I stupidly thought that android community was a sharing community, fool of me. That's not stealing but explanation of your work giving you credits, what's the real problem? You did a great work and people wanted to know how you did it that's not in open source mind?

 

[Robbie Hood]

I stupidly thought that android community was a sharing community, fool of me. That's not stealing but explanation of your work giving you credits, what's the real problem? You did a great work and people wanted to know how you did it that's not in open source mind?

Lol
First try and understand the amounts of work we put in.
Its not simply comparing like its done here.
Alliance roms have always been unique and we do our best to not follow the mainstream and develop things for ourzelves instead of blindly copying.

People can enjoy the work as it is in the roms and mods.
If someone wouldve asked me there was no problem at all.
But this was simply compared to stock and spoonfed here without asking.
I am not ok with this and xda isnt either.

And lets clear up the open source crap argument that someone wildly throws around once in a while.
If a dev chooses to publish his work with source then its open source but since we work in tw rom(which is closed source to start off with) 5his argument holds no ground at all !!

---------- Post added at 12:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:46 PM ----------

In the guide (the link I posted), it was mentioned that "Actual mod was done by RobbieHood and eybee1970" and the last edit to that post was 2 June 2013. so if you still think that I crossed the line by writing the guide for helping others, then I am sorry mate (although I didn't even post the mod, only the guide, thought by doing this I still respect you..) Also I did write the guide only after pressuring from others..
I don't say that you shouldn't report to moderator though,,, but please consider this issue, I didn't even mention that was my work..
Even if I got some action from moderators by your report, I will never hate a good brother like you, so please don't hate me..

Regards

I hold no grudge but its simply tiring when we try our best so hard to not be like the 13 in a dozen roms.

 

[majdinj]

Gi hold no grudge but its simply tiring wwhenwe try our best so hard to not be like the 13 in a dozen roms.

don't be upset,,, If my guides will be the cause of stopping you releasing ROMs, then I will stop posting android mod guides,,
so we could live in peace.. and sorry for being bastard with you brother (if you think so)..

Yours;
majdinj

 

[ezaechiel]

Lol
First try and understand the amounts of work we put in.
Its not simply comparing like its done here.
Alliance roms have always been unique and we do our best to not follow the mainstream and develop things for ourzelves instead of blindly copying.

People can enjoy the work as it is in the roms and mods.
If someone wouldve asked me there was no problem at all.
But this was simply compared to stock and spoonfed here without asking.
I am not ok with this and xda isnt either.

And lets clear up the open source crap argument that someone wildly throws around once in a while.
If a dev chooses to publish his work with source then its open source but since we work in tw rom(which is closed source to start off with) 5his argument holds no ground at all !!

---------- Post added at 12:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:46 PM ----------


Gi hold no grudge but its simply tiring wwhenwe try our best so hard to not be like the 13 in a dozen roms.

I clearly understand your point of view and know you did a great work in alliance rom but I just want to mention that it's because the work is great that people want to know how you did it .

 

[Robbie Hood]

I clearly understand your point of view and know you did a great work in alliance rom but I just want to mention that it's because the work is great that people want to know how you did it .

And thats my point exactly.
if it was asked, I wouldve said yes and helped without a doubt as many of you know here.

But it wasnt...

 

[ezaechiel]

And thats my point exactly.
if it was asked, I wouldve said yes and helped without a doubt as many of you know here.

vut it wasnt

Ok I understand but I don't think majdinj would offense you, I hope that the problem will be solve with fair

 

[Robbie Hood]

Ok I understand but I don't think majdinj would offense you, I hope that the problem will be solve with fair

Yes it will be resolved accordingly and i dont have bad feelings towards majdinj, I was simply surprised by the way this was handled.

 

[ezaechiel]

Yes it will be resolved accordingly and i dont have bad feelings towards majdinj, I was simply surprised by the way this was handled.

As it was asked by a lot of people I think that's why it was handled this way ^_^

 

[not-i]

And thats my point exactly.
if it was asked, I wouldve said yes and helped without a doubt as many of you know here.

But it wasnt...

Robbie I just wanted to say thanks for all the great work you have done for the Note (& beyond) community. Much respect. I understand where you are coming from & have also read all the posts from others requesting how to do this or that so I can understand why some guides have been made. I can also understand why you would be a little pissed at not being asked.

You have definitely broken new ground with your roms & mods so we all thank you for the effort you have put in to it. Personally I can say you inspired me to start cooking roms so I thank you sincerely for that. All the best mate

 

[Robbie Hood]

Robbie I just wanted to say thanks for all the great work you have done for the Note (& beyond) community. Much respect. I understand where you are coming from & have also read all the posts from others requesting how to do this or that so I can understand why some guides have been made. I can also understand why you would be a little pissed at not being asked.

You have definitely broken new ground with your roms & mods so we all thank you for the effort you have put in to it. Personally I can say you inspired me to start cooking roms so I thank you sincerely for that. All the best mate

 

[DAGr8]

And thats my point exactly.
if it was asked, I wouldve said yes and helped without a doubt as many of you know here.

But it wasnt...

1_ you went public with this instead of pming the op as xda rules states.
2_ I respect the alliance and your work but guys like you have to be the better person here.
3_ didnt we all use someone else s work without permission at one point ?
Your initial post brought 2 points up credits and permission.
Credits were there so that is a non issue.
As for permission ... technically he didnt use .. he posted a "how to" .. basically a diff that many could do themselves but this helps new users to make mods for them self.
Dont get me wrong I get your point and I did innovate a few times my self just to see my work rehashed with 0 credits.
Android is so fragmented amongst developpers right now some of us have to be the better person here and do it right. Android is all about sharing.. nobody is thanking jesusfreke for baksmali nor untermech for extented power menu tools and mods we all use everyday...the list goes on .. me, you are just numbers in that list. And yes it is frustrating.

Sent from my SGH-I317M using xda premium

 

[Robbie Hood]

1_ you went public with this instead of pming the op as xda rules states.
2_ I respect the alliance and your work but guys like you have to be the better person here.
3_ didnt we all use someone else s work without permission at one point ?
Your initial post brought 2 points up credits and permission.
Credits were there so that is a non issue.
As for permission ... technically he didnt use .. he posted a "how to" .. basically a diff that many could do themselves but this helps new users to make mods for them self.
Dont get me wrong I get your point and I did innovate a few times my self just to see my work rehashed with 0 credits.
Android is so fragmented amongst developpers right now some of us have to be the better person here and do it right. Android is all about sharing.. nobody is thanking jesusfreke for baksmali nor untermech for extented power menu tools and mods we all use everyday...the list goes on .. me, you are just numbers in that list. And yes it is frustrating.

Sent from my SGH-I317M using xda premium

Yeah like said its not the issue he wrote a howto but it couldve been asked.
Some good devs allready left here on xda simply because a lot of chefs just copy and copy.
Anyway i'm over it and will start working on my new release.

 

[majdinj]

Yes it will be resolved accordingly and i dont have bad feelings towards majdinj, I was simply surprised by the way this was handled.
..
..
Anyway i'm over it and will start working on my new release.

Between brothers there should be some conflicts, just to make their bonds stronger..
Me too Robbie, I don't have bad feelings toward you (and never I will)..!! and I am really glad you could come over the issue..

Another point, please others, don't ask (how to) again.. I don't want for the same issue to re-occur again ^-^

Robbie please check PM

 

[ezaechiel]

Between brothers there should be some conflicts, just to make their bonds stronger..
Me too Robbie, I don't have bad feelings toward you (and never I will)..!! and I am really glad you could come over the issue..

Another point, please others, don't ask (how to) again.. I don't want for the same issue to re-occur again ^-^

Robbie please check PM

It's sad thanks to your how to i learned a lot

 

[Robbie Hood]

Between brothers there should be some conflicts, just to make their bonds stronger..
Me too Robbie, I don't have bad feelings toward you (and never I will)..!! and I am really glad you could come over the issue..

Another point, please others, don't ask (how to) again.. I don't want for the same issue to re-occur again ^-^

Robbie please check PM

Keep this post up mate.
The issue can be overcome in the future bynjust askin the dev you sourced it from.
You might even get help and dont have to decompile and compare.
Its what I wouldve done IF IT WAS ASKED

checkin my pm now.
Keep up the work mate

 

[majdinj]

Keep this post up mate.
The issue can be overcome in the future bynjust askin the dev you sourced it from.
You might even get help and dont have to decompile and compare.
Its what I wouldve done IF IT WAS ASKED

checkin my pm now.
Keep up the work mate

I appreciate your reaction man..
and yeah before posting (how to) next time, I would ask for permission first..

Have a good life with your new job brother. You deserve it.

 

[Robbie Hood]

I appreciate your reaction man..
and yeah before posting (how to) next time, I would ask for permission first..

Have a good life with your new job brother. You deserve it.

Im so excited for this job I cant wait....:silly:

 

[ezaechiel]

Im so excited for this job I cant wait....:silly:

Congrats for your new job

 

[DAGr8]

Keep this post up mate.
The issue can be overcome in the future bynjust askin the dev you sourced it from.
You might even get help and dont have to decompile and compare.
Its what I wouldve done IF IT WAS ASKED

checkin my pm now.
Keep up the work mate

Just gotta say hell yea..

I had this topic favorite that's why I jumped in.. Sorry wasnT my business at all ..

Keep it up op be sure I'll contribute whenever u need me to

Sent from my SGH-I317 using xda premium