Dirty Unicorns ROM discussion

Giocarro

Senior Member
Dec 11, 2012
2,061
970
193
Just clean installed the latest RC build during lunch time: it runs really well and I can confirm that the kernel looks fresh.
I repeated my quick scrolling test with graph bars and immediately switched (again) to conservative governor which gives less dropped frames.
It is beyond me how other more famous governors still don't guarantee the same performance of conservative, but I'm really happy with this setup.
 

Hecke92

Senior Member
Dec 27, 2011
313
100
63
The RC is DU_oneplus3_7.1.1_20170311-0919.v11.2-RC.zip
The official is DU_oneplus3_7.1.1_20170311-0241.v11.2-OFFICIAL.zip

So the RC seems to be newer, right?

Thanks :)
 

shriansh1706

Senior Member
Feb 27, 2014
104
28
0
Faridabad
Just clean installed the latest RC build during lunch time: it runs really well and I can confirm that the kernel looks fresh.
I repeated my quick scrolling test with graph bars and immediately switched (again) to conservative governor which gives less dropped frames.
It is beyond me how other more famous governors still don't guarantee the same performance of conservative, but I'm really happy with this setup.
I don't think if I'll be able to actually feel a difference in performance in this ROM cuz it's just too damn fast:laugh::D
The only thing that bugs me in this rom is that it doesn't have hand wave gestures for the ambient display (basically just a very basic implementation of ambient display) which is present in every other ROM. Otherwise it's the best ROM out there as far as I know. BTW do tell me if you find an alternative to this rom. I was thinking of maybe trying the new Candy 7 ROM
 

cba1986

Senior Member
Aug 8, 2010
2,409
621
0
Somewhere in Buenos Aires
I don't think if I'll be able to actually feel a difference in performance in this ROM cuz it's just too damn fast:laugh::D
The only thing that bugs me in this rom is that it doesn't have hand wave gestures for the ambient display (basically just a very basic implementation of ambient display) which is present in every other ROM. Otherwise it's the best ROM out there as far as I know. BTW do tell me if you find an alternative to this rom. I was thinking of maybe trying the new Candy 7 ROM
citrus-CAF is very good too. i had to leave DU because an issue with skype enterprise(doesnt open) and BT headset (soft reboot after a minute or two i stop listening to music :eek:)
 

mido25

Senior Member
Nov 29, 2012
717
655
0
citrus-CAF is very good too. i had to leave DU because an issue with skype enterprise(doesnt open) and BT headset (soft reboot after a minute or two i stop listening to music :eek:)
Try to flash the hal1 enabler in oos cam thread (use the one for lineage kernel not Omni)
 
  • Like
Reactions: ahepas

AGelu

Senior Member
Sep 22, 2014
179
40
48
i had to leave DU because an issue with skype enterprise(doesnt open) and BT headset (soft reboot after a minute or two i stop listening to music :eek:)
Same problem with BT : soft reboot after stopping music or parking my car ( disconnect car hands free) . Sometimes screen become black & phone unresponsive for several minutes. DU stable , F2FS , Viper4A , SU SR3 .
 

ungeeked

Senior Member
Jun 12, 2012
1,568
3,033
0
Delhi-NCR
Just clean installed the latest RC build during lunch time: it runs really well and I can confirm that the kernel looks fresh.
I repeated my quick scrolling test with graph bars and immediately switched (again) to conservative governor which gives less dropped frames.
It is beyond me how other more famous governors still don't guarantee the same performance of conservative, but I'm really happy with this setup.
There is no mystery in this. Conservative governors scale slowly. While the "famous" ones scale quickly.

Whenever there is a load, the cpu should scale up quickly, finish the task and then go back to sleep asap. Conservative governors scale up and down slowly.

Now how this affects the "scrolling test". We perform the test by rapidly scrolling up and down. The "famous governors" will try scale up and then quickly come down too. As the frequencies drop you may see a few frames go above the green 60fps line.

Conservative govs due to their slow nature main relatively stable frequencies during scrolling which gives them an advantage in fps.

But in real world, I don't see a scenario where we need to scroll up and down like we do in scrolling test. Thus the benefit of using conservative appears to be very limited. Secondly as long as you are below the green line (60fps) it doesn't matter. Our eyes cannot differentiate between 70 and 80 fps. But conservative governors here are at a loss because during heavy loads such as gaming, sometimes the scaling is too slow resulting in framedrops and freezes.

I have been experimenting with interactive + zzmoove (another conservative governor) since even before XDA wrote about it. Yes it feels smooth but games sometimes lag.

-----
This is just a crude explaination which I found out from my experience. If anybody has a better explanation, they are welcome to share it
 

kscjx

Senior Member
Aug 26, 2014
104
17
38
I don't think if I'll be able to actually feel a difference in performance in this ROM cuz it's just too damn fast:laugh::D
The only thing that bugs me in this rom is that it doesn't have hand wave gestures for the ambient display (basically just a very basic implementation of ambient display) which is present in every other ROM. Otherwise it's the best ROM out there as far as I know. BTW do tell me if you find an alternative to this rom. I was thinking of maybe trying the new Candy 7 ROM
The most important things to me in a ROM are - smoothness, stability, and overall speed. Every ROM I flash is geared towards these. I've tried my fair share of nougat ROMs out there. I've tried du, citrus, aosip, tuga power, slim, validus, Tesla, resurrection remix...etc. My point is caf and aosp ROMs are always smoother and more stable. I can't speak to camera quality. I'm currently on vertex os by joshuos and I must say am really impressed. I think I prefer it to due and even aosip. I really think you should try it. Cheers
 
  • Like
Reactions: Giocarro

ABotelho23

Senior Member
Jun 1, 2013
184
65
0
Ottawa
This ROM would be perfect with pocket mode/hand wave ambient display. But maintainer has decided against it for "battery drain" reasons.

I'm pretty much jumping ship. OmniROM dev has also shrugged it off as well. Anybody know of stable Nougat ROMs with those features? As much as I hate to abandon :[
 

mido25

Senior Member
Nov 29, 2012
717
655
0
This ROM would be perfect with pocket mode/hand wave ambient display. But maintainer has decided against it for "battery drain" reasons.

I'm pretty much jumping ship. OmniROM dev has also shrugged it off as well. Anybody know of stable Nougat ROMs with those features? As much as I hate to abandon :[
Vertex ROM has these features
 
  • Like
Reactions: ABotelho23

shriansh1706

Senior Member
Feb 27, 2014
104
28
0
Faridabad
This ROM would be perfect with pocket mode/hand wave ambient display. But maintainer has decided against it for "battery drain" reasons.

I'm pretty much jumping ship. OmniROM dev has also shrugged it off as well. Anybody know of stable Nougat ROMs with those features? As much as I hate to abandon :[
That's exactly the same case with me too mate. I even posted a feature request on Jira for this feature to be implemented but there was too much of a battery drain bcoz of it:p

---------- Post added at 06:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:47 PM ----------

The most important things to me in a ROM are - smoothness, stability, and overall speed. Every ROM I flash is geared towards these. I've tried my fair share of nougat ROMs out there. I've tried du, citrus, aosip, tuga power, slim, validus, Tesla, resurrection remix...etc. My point is caf and aosp ROMs are always smoother and more stable. I can't speak to camera quality. I'm currently on vertex os by joshuos and I must say am really impressed. I think I prefer it to due and even aosip. I really think you should try it. Cheers
But it does not have many features and it's stock kernel is eas based which is still quite new and not that optimised. I have tried Zenity RR and render's kernel but even the eas there was not much of a performer and battery life was also not that great
 

shriansh1706

Senior Member
Feb 27, 2014
104
28
0
Faridabad
Was that you? I commented on that. His logic makes no sense. It uses a low power sensor and would be a toggle ...
Yes exactly !! I mean op3 has an amoled display and the required low power sensors. Power consumption should be very low after some optimisations. Even then you could still give it as an option to us. I mean freaking n5 has it and it doesn't have an amoled display and maybe isn't all that optimised considering its way past its time:silly: