[Discussion] Magisk Delta - Another unofficial third-party Magisk fork

[supermansaga]

Using Magisk Delta fixed 2 out of 3 apps for me that used to crash.

But the other one, my banking app, still detects something. When you open it, it basically opens the browser and online website instead because it detected tampering. Previously, with original Magisk, it used to append rasp=root to the URL. Now it appends rasp=android_hook. So that's progress I guess.

Delta won't be able to fix Marriott V10.13.1

 

[Elsrougy]

Hi there

I am having difficulty with these applications: SNB, Absher, and Nafad. All other apps seem to be working for me. Would you like to try them to see if they work for you?

I am using Magisk Delta, zygisk . with hidemyapplist white-listing and magiskhide

I have the same problem and have been searching everywhere for a while now but no luck.

I even made w thread on reddit for this:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Magisk/comments/11tzstn
It has some good suggestions. None of them worked for me, but you can try and check yourself maybe something will work with you. if it happens please let me know.

 

[mobile_sensei]

.

Hey, thanks for sharing your fork of Magisk. I'm not up to date on all the a/b partition stuff that we have nowadays, can you tell me how to appropriately switch from Magisk? Thank you

 

[penguin_grapefruit]

Hi, everyone. I have a query.
I'm still relatively new to the world of custom ROMs, unlocked bootloaders and rooted phones so please forgive my naivety.

MemoryDetector v2.0.0 detects "Device status or bootloader has been tampered".

I see several screenshots of other people's MemoryDetector app showing "Looks Fine! Nothing is found." so I'm wondering if there's something I can do to resolve this.

Here are details of my setup:
Xiaomi Mi 8 (dipper)
LineageOS 20
Magisk Delta fdac22ba-delta (25210)
Zygisk enabled
MagiskHide enabled (with MemoryDetector in the MagiskHide list)
Universal SafetyNet Fix v2.4.0-MOD_1.2 (Displax) installed

Everything seems to be working OK (SafetyNet passes Basic Integrity and CTS Profile Match and Play Integrity API Checker confirms "MEETS_DEVICE_INTEGRITY and MEETS_BASIC_INTEGRITY).

I'm just curious how I might go about resolving the "Device status or bootloader has been tampered" message in MemoryDetector v2.0.0.
Others seems to have achieved this but I don't know how.

I'd be very grateful for any pointers anyone can give.
Thank you.

 

[DartGerion]

Hello!
I had some question about the TJW Magisk and Delta. I've installed Delta with direct install (tried first with .zip, but it didn't activate) and as the result i had TJW Magisk (with spoofed name) and Delta (that updated to 25210). In TJW Magisk shows installed delta and promts to install v26 version. So as i understand now the delta has taken place of the old tjw magisk. So is it safe to uninstall the tjw magisk app, if the framework is now run by Delta?

 

[zgfg]

Hello!
I had some question about the TJW Magisk and Delta. I've installed Delta with direct install (tried first with .zip, but it didn't activate) and as the result i had TJW Magisk (with spoofed name) and Delta (that updated to 25210). In TJW Magisk shows installed delta and promts to install v26 version. So as i understand now the delta has taken place of the old tjw magisk. So is it safe to uninstall the tjw magisk app, if the framework is now run by Delta?

Of course (it was also guided earlier), uninstall that old (renamed/repackaged or not) TJW Magisk app/manager and reboot. Check if Delta app then correctly shows the Magisk Delta version installed (you could reinstall Delta app then if really needed)

If Delta app asks that it needs to finish the installation and to reboot again, do that

 

[DartGerion]

Of course (it was also guided earlier), uninstall that old (renamed/repackaged or not) TJW Magisk app/manager and reboot. Check if Delta app then correctly shows the Magisk Delta version installed (you could reinstall Delta app then if really needed)

If Delta app asks that it needs to finish the installation and to reboot again, do that

Thank you for clearing this up and apologies for missing the info before. Could you also explain the SuList function in the settings?

 

[zgfg]

Thank you for clearing this up and apologies for missing the info before. Could you also explain the SuList function in the settings?

MagiskHide works in blacklist mode - you have to add all 'banking' apps to the list, you want to hide root from

SuList works in the opposite whitelist mode - you only enlist the root apps, ie those that require access to the 'root'

The advantage: you don't need to add every newly installed banking app to MagiskHide list and to reboot

Scroll back and find additional posts/instructions like from a month ago

Install also SuList Auto Whitelist module - it will find all modules apps (like V4A, JamesDSP, etc) and will automatically add them to the SuList (without, they will not work properly in the SuList mode).
However, you still have to manually add eg AdAway to the SuLlst

 

[supermansaga]

MagiskHide works in blacklist mode - you have to add all 'banking' apps to the list, you want to hide root from

SuList works in the opposite whitelist mode - you only enlist the root apps, ie those that require access to the 'root'

The advantage: you don't need to add every newly installed banking app to MagiskHide list and to reboot

Scroll back and find additional posts/instructions like from a month ago

Install also SuList Auto Whitelist module - it will find all modules apps (like V4A, JamesDSP, etc) and will automatically add them to the SuList (without, they will not work properly in the SuList mode).
However, you still have to manually add eg AdAway to the SuLlst

Can SuList Auto Whitelist module handle Marriott v10.13.1 when the phone also has s ome LSposed modules installed?

 

[zgfg]

Can SuList Auto Whitelist module handle Marriott v10.13.1 when the phone also has s ome LSposed modules installed?

No idea, don't know about that app. Maybe if you provide a link to install, to test

Btw, I'm not sure, wasn't recently in one of these threads a discussion about hiding the root from that or similar appk...

 

[avisekarmani]

This is not an officially supported topjohnwu project.
If you are looking for official Magisk source, please go to this page


Introduction

Custom Magisk fork by HuskyDG. Sync with official Magisk adding back MagiskHide.
http://huskydg.github.io/magisk-files

REPORT BUG IS STILL ACCEPTED ON XDA THREAD BUT PLEASE INCLUDE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION SUCH AS LOGCAT AND MAGISK LOG

Hi @huskydg , the new updated magisk delta have some issues. The MagiskHide Props module is not working in new update.
I am attaching the log. Please review it and solve this issue. For this kind I always be thankful to you.

 

[zgfg]

Hi @huskydg , the new updated magisk delta have some issues. The MagiskHide Props module is not working in new update.
I am attaching the log. Please review it and solve this issue. For this kind I always be thankful to you

Btw, are you sure it was really a problem on the MHCP side - the original MHCP module is no more maintained for a year or more (and I really don't know how is about the fork from the new developer - at least, there are not much news on his XDA thread)

Also, do you really need MHCP. Husky made like Sensitive Props module - ok, that's not for general purposes but for hiding the root

 

[avisekarmani]

Btw, are you sure it was really a problem on the MHCP side - the original MHCP module is no more maintained for a year or more (and I really don't know how is about the fork from the new developer - at least, there are not much news on his XDA thread)

Also, do you really need MHCP. Husky made like Sensitive Props module - ok, that's not for general purposes but for hiding the root

Hello @zgfg , first of all thanks for your reply. Magiskhide Props Config module is working smoothly. I was using it in magisk delta some days ago. But when I updated my magisk delta into the latest version, it started showing error. Also, it is working smoothly in official magisk latest version. And I uses it for changing my device fingerprint and there is no any alternative of this module available. So I need this module.
I am attaching the image of error showing by the module in terminal and log of this module.

 

[zgfg]

Hello @zgfg , first of all thanks for your reply. Magiskhide Props Config module is working smoothly. I was using it in magisk delta some days ago. But when I updated my magisk delta into the latest version, it started showing error. Also, it is working smoothly in official magisk latest version. And I uses it for changing my device fingerprint and there is no any alternative of this module available. So I need this module.
I am attaching the image of error showing by the module in terminal and log of this module.

Screenshot says "Please reboot your device .." - did you try (and is the module enabled)?

 

[avisekarmani]

Screenshot says "Please reboot your device .." - did you try (and is the module enabled)?

I tried all the things but nothing happened.

 

[zgfg]

I tried all the things but nothing happened.

Strange. I just installed MHPC v6.1.2 and it runs for me

However, I'm on the last but one v25210 Delta, 80d8cbf0 (I did not want to upgrade to fdac22ba "Temp fix 1/?" ?!)

Screenshots attached

 

[goldwoods]

The latest bank app from vietinbank detect root

VietinBank iPay - Apps on Google Play

VietinBank x Den Vau

play.google.com

 

[martyfender]

Strange. I just installed MHPC v6.1.2 and it runs for me

However, I'm on the last but one v25210 Delta, 80d8cbf0 (I did not want to upgrade to fdac22ba "Temp fix 1/?" ?!)

Screenshots attached

I reverted to an older version my self. I had major problems with fdac22ba. No matter what I did, it would not pass the playstore integrity checker, Playstore certification and CTS Profile in Safety Net. I even went as far as reinstalling the Rom. That was on the older of my 2 Onn 8 1st gen, Android 9 tablets.

 

[m0han]

... had major problems with fdac22ba..... would not pass the playstore integrity checker, Playstore certification and CTS Profile....

Just an FYI: All fine here on fdac22ba. Delta+Riru, do note.

 

[zgfg]

Just an FYI: All fine here on fdac22ba. Delta+Riru, do note.

You managed to solve your AdAway/Systemless hosts/hosts file problems (I think, blocking ads did not work for you)?