[Discussion] Magisk - The Age of Zygisk.

[73sydney]

Fwiw

Delta is not entirely without its own issues, chiefly for me occaisonally losing root in the background, leaving me with having to reset my damn Watch 4 twice a day (if i was lucky) during the 3 days i tested it - once the link to watch is severed by root detection, theres NO way to recover it without reset....i soon went back to 25 debug and zero issues...luckily my bank app doesnt detect using zygisk/shamiko.

i.e. nothing is perfect and its still (relatively speaking) early days for zygisk/shamiko and im sure other zygisk alternatives

 

[meric57]

Hello, hidden doctolib is hidden magisk docotolib detects rooting.

 

[vietmobi]

It detects Zygisk.
You need Magisk Hide, ie.Magisk Alpha/Delta

Thank, i try magisk delta, turn off zygisk and use magiskhide. It finally works.

 

[proza]

I have a moto G7 plus.
I installed the Pixel OS 12 Plus. I installed Magisk 25.1. I enabled both Zygisk and Enforce DenyList. In the DenyList, I only selected the Google Play Services, enabled all the items except com.google.android.gms.
I rebooted and installed module MagiskHidePropsConf-v6.1.2.zip. Rebooted and installed module safetynet-fix-Zygisk-v2.2.1.zip. Rebooted and use the terminal to change the props to Google Nexus 6P.
Rebooted, run Root Checker. It shows SafetyNet request Failed. CTS profile match N/A. Basic integrity N/A.
What else can I do to pass the safetynet?

 

[huskydg]

Rebooted, run Root Checker. It shows SafetyNet request Failed. CTS profile match N/A. Basic integrity N/A.
What else can I do to pass the safetynet?

Please use another checker such as YASNAC

 

[proza]

Please use another checker such as YASNAC

It says "Something went wrong, Attestation response timeout"

 

[zgfg]

It says "Something went wrong, Attestation response timeout"

Do you have GApos in your ROM?
SafetyNet goes through Google Play Services - if missing, it cannot work

AFAIK, there was a MicroG version (an open source alternative to GMS) but it must be provided with the ROM, proper version, etc

I don't know the details and frankly Im not interested (I use stock or custom ROMs with GApps), but I recall it was discussed here and/or in the USNF or MHPC threads, You could search

If you do have GApps, turn off all possible firewalls, blockers, etc - SN is not checked locally, GMS must connect to the Google servers

 

[proza]

Do you have GApos in your ROM?
SafetyNet goes through Google Play Services - if missing, it cannot work

AFAIK, there was a MicroG version (an open source alternative to GMS) but it must be provided with the ROM, proper version, etc

I don't know the details and frankly Im not interested (I use stock or custom ROMs with GApps), but I recall it was discussed here and/or in the USNF or MHPC threads, You could search

If you do have GApps, turn off all possible firewalls, blockers, etc - SN is not checked locally, GMS must connect to the Google servers

From the website, it says "PixelExperience is an AOSP based ROM, with Google apps included"
I have disabled the firewall and paused the adaway.

 

[zgfg]

From the website, it says "PixelExperience is an AOSP based ROM, with Google apps included"
I have disabled the firewall and paused the adaway.

Here you have the official SafetyNet API specifcation:

SafetyNet Attestation API | Android Developers

The SafetyNet Attestation API provides services for determining whether a device running your app satisfies Android compatibility tests.

developer.android.com

You can see that no response or timeout means that somewhere in the request/response channel (call to GMS, call to Google servers, responses back) is broken.
It does not mean that CTS or Basic integrity fail (hence you cannot fix with USNF or MHPC), but there is no response (and therefore no verdict about - they might be perfectly passing if attestation channel was not broken)

If one SN checker fails to answer, it can be that that something is wrong with that checker (or they went over quota with the number of requests to Google today or so).
But if it happens to you with different SN checkers (YASNAC now works perfectly for me), the pipe is broken in your ROM or on your line

Eg, ask in the group where you took the ROM from, how they test and pass SN

 

[rodken]

{Mod edit: Quoted post has been deleted}
You need to be more specific:

-- What device are you utilizing
-- Which version of Android
-- Custom ROM or Stock
-- What steps did you take [if any] to mitigate the issue

 

[GreekPilot]

Good morning everybody. With new Shamiko v0.5.1 (117), no zygisk detected.

 

[huskydg]

Good morning everybody. With new Shamiko v0.5.1 (117), no zygisk detected.

Seem meanless because it can't hide zygisk for some banking apps such as livin by madiri, instapay egypt, itsme,...

 

[zgfg]

Good morning everybody. With new Shamiko v0.5.1 (117), no zygisk detected.

For me (Xiaomi 11 Lite 5g NE, A11) did not help, Momo stil detecting Magisk, Zygisk and su - same as reported previously:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/magisk-general-support-discussion.3432382/post-87084745

 

[huskydg]

For me (Xiaomi 11 Lite 5g NE, A11) did not help, Momo stil detecting Magisk, Zygisk and su - same as reported previously:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/magisk-general-support-discussion.3432382/post-87084745

Did you checkbox all for momo processes in denylist?

 

[zgfg]

Did you checkbox all for momo processes in denylist?

Thanks, enabling all Momo proccesses for DenyList eliminated Momo detections of su and Zygisk

 

[aximili]

I can't get HMA to work. I have enabled it in LSPosed but I don't have the module in Magisk.
(I have tried installing it from the APK and from the Play Store)
Help please?

 

[m0han]

Did you checkbox all for momo processes in denylist?

This is how I have Momo configured in DenyList at the moment. The middle item was disabled after reading somewhere that it is advisable. (I don't recall where I read it.) Would my Momo situation change for the better if I enable that also?

 

[dohanin]

This is how I have Momo configured in DenyList at the moment. The middle item was disabled after reading somewhere that it is advisable. (I don't recall where I read it.) Would my Momo situation change for the better if I enable that also?

Probably the same.

If you like to hide Init.rc, you can install another magisk module InitRcHider. Or use Shamiko which has included initrc hider since 0.4.3. Although it doesn't make much difference I guess as not many apps would try to look for it.

 

[m0han]

Probably the same.

If you like to hide Init.rc, you can install another magisk module InitRcHider. Or use Shamiko which has included initrc hider since 0.4.3...

I have used 'InitRcHider'. I'm using the latest Shamiko. https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/magisk-general-support-discussion.3432382/post-87084405

 

[dohanin]

I have used 'InitRcHider'. I'm using the latest Shamiko. https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/magisk-general-support-discussion.3432382/post-87084405

Oh sorry, didn't read your earlier post. So you're using Delta. I have no idea then.