• We are moving to xdaforums.com!

    Posts made between now and when the migration is complete will not be carried over.
    You will be automatically redirected once the migration is complete.

Question Does your S23 have camera issues? Blurred image? Bananagate? Other problems?

Do you suffer from blurry or out of focus images on stock camera?


  • Total voters
    46
Search This thread
I'm opening this topic to get this information to all S23/S23+ users.

We have a serious problem with the camera and Samsung has come to say that it is a feature and so far Samsung has been washing its hands and not pronouncing itself, not even issuing a statement about this problem.

Is your S23 good? Vote!

Almost 6 years separate the OnePlus 5T from the S23+ and still, the 5T gets better definition and focus, despite the fact that the 5T already has enough problems with the Camera.

But Samsung continues to say that it is a function and characteristic of the lens of the S23+ what is clearly seen in the "banana" effect is a circle of blur, perhaps not because of the sensor but because of the poor construction of the lens. I, like many others, feel cheated for having bought the S23.

Look at the photos and draw conclusions.


01 - OnePlus 5t (Large).jpg

OnePlus 5T


02 - S23+ (Large).jpg

Samsung S23+

03 - 5T vs S23+ (Medium).png

5T vs S23+
 
Last edited:

The_SloPro

Senior Member
Jan 15, 2022
60
12
Xiaomi Poco F1
Samsung Galaxy A50
Yes. Very bad photos if you dont hold the phone completeley still. Also in apps like snapchat, it takes 2 seconds to capture the photo, which is often completely blurred (not out of focus, but a preview of two secs before tapping the shutter button)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Racpu_

Jason379

Member
Apr 2, 2018
38
14
S23 (non +) user here. My phone's been suffering from the very same issue and in 90%+ of all the photos I have taken with it so far you can clearly spot the 'banana-spahed' blur at first sight without having to pixel-peep.
The phone itself is amazing.. yet the cameras turned out to be a huuuge letdown. Never seen such inconsistent, over-sharpened and over-processed images before. And then there's the blur which ruins pretty much every image taken (even more). My 2016 LG G5 takes better and sharper images than my S23..
 

jvidia

Senior Member
Jun 1, 2011
916
107
Lisbon
My S23 256mb arrived yesterday and today I returned it!

It had horrible focus and the bananagate effect too!

My old Honor 8 from 2016 focus better on close subjects than S23.

I refuse to believe this is normal on a 2023 flagship!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: duttyend and Racpu_
My S23 256mb arrived yesterday and today I returned it!

It had horrible focus and the bananagate effect too!

My old Honor 8 from 2016 focus better on close subjects than S23.

I refuse to believe this is normal on a 2023 flagship!
It's sad to say, but from 2020 smartphones have gotten worse and worse, the S23 is not worthy of a flagship, the camera has issues and Samsung just won't admit it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jvidia

jvidia

Senior Member
Jun 1, 2011
916
107
Lisbon
Yep that's what I've experienced too!

I tested the S23 against my Tablet S8+ / Pixel 6a / Honor 8 and all of them took clean focused pictures of documents. This situation is important to me because I digitalize a lot of documents like this.

The Samsung official position about this is that it is a normal effect and for this kind of utilization we must take the photo using the 2x or 3x option with the phone far from the paper. I refuse to believe this.

But even assuming that the 2x or 3x method solves it, this problem does not end here (on close up shots) because there are reports of image blur in the same sensor place (left side when in landscape) when shooting normal daily photos.

Another report I did read but did not test, is that if we put that same A4 paper on a wall (instead of a table) and take the photo with the phone vertically, the banana effect does not occur! Can anyone test this scenario? If this is true it blows out of the water the theory of 2x/3x and takes it to a mechanical problem due to gravity orientation of the sensor or other camera component.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Racpu_

jvidia

Senior Member
Jun 1, 2011
916
107
Lisbon
The country where your device was made is printed on the box, on the sticker where you can also see the IMEI.
 

Top Liked Posts

  • There are no posts matching your filters.
  • 1
    If you want to try an alternate camera:

    1. Get AGC8.8.224_V7.0_samsung.apk from here

    2. Get the corresponding configs here

    3. Open GCam app on your phone, accept permissions. This should automatically create the folder /sdcard/Download/AGC.8.8/

    4. Copy the configs downloaded above into /sdcard/Download/AGC.8.8/configs/ Note that on the S23/S23+ you don't need the configs with names that contain "_s23u_". Only copy the configs with "_s23_"

    5. In the Gcam app click the drop-down arrow on the upper-left and select Load Configs. You can also go into Settings -> Custom file -> Load custom XML
  • 3
    I'm opening this topic to get this information to all S23/S23+ users.

    We have a serious problem with the camera and Samsung has come to say that it is a feature and so far Samsung has been washing its hands and not pronouncing itself, not even issuing a statement about this problem.

    Is your S23 good? Vote!

    Almost 6 years separate the OnePlus 5T from the S23+ and still, the 5T gets better definition and focus, despite the fact that the 5T already has enough problems with the Camera.

    But Samsung continues to say that it is a function and characteristic of the lens of the S23+ what is clearly seen in the "banana" effect is a circle of blur, perhaps not because of the sensor but because of the poor construction of the lens. I, like many others, feel cheated for having bought the S23.

    Look at the photos and draw conclusions.


    01 - OnePlus 5t (Large).jpg

    OnePlus 5T


    02 - S23+ (Large).jpg

    Samsung S23+

    03 - 5T vs S23+ (Medium).png

    5T vs S23+
    2
    Just after reading this thread, I can confirm the issue of unsharp areas in the image taken at 1.0 magnification rate at short distance is clearly there! But if zoomed in on 3x magnification, image is as sharp as it can get, corner to corner. Images taken at normal (meaning medium to far) distances don't exhibit any out of focus areas in my quick snapshots, but CLEARLY short/close up distances at 1.0 magnification show "the banana effect". Does it bother me? Absolutely!!! Can i live with it? It is just me I guess, but I can, using 3x zoom for occasional pictures of documents is fine with me. My model is EUX from Germany, if that's valid information to anyone.

    I'm not selling the phone because of this camera issue, because I like everything else I tested it for so far. But Samsung should man up and admit they're at fault here, whether it is a software or hardware issue (or combination of both, no idea). For such an expensive device one would expect ANYTHING captured during daytime/with plenty of light available (including) close up pictures to be as sharp as a razor, bloody hell!
    2
    My S23 256mb arrived yesterday and today I returned it!

    It had horrible focus and the bananagate effect too!

    My old Honor 8 from 2016 focus better on close subjects than S23.

    I refuse to believe this is normal on a 2023 flagship!
    2
    It seems it also has got the same problem. I've read reports about it by S23 Ultra owners.
    I haven't seen any valid claims regarding the S23U having the same issues so far. It's a completely different array. Also, the larger sensor inside the S23U gives the user way more depth of field, which can easily be mistaken for an optical error by some users.

    The S23 and S23+ models however clearly do suffer from a faulty lens design /misalignment of one of the lens elements. I just can't oversee and ignore it - no matter how good the 50mp sensor is actually performing.
    2
    Did anyone try Gcam to see if this issue is present?
    Yes. I fully switched to using Gcam exclusively a while ago and it didn't do anything to 'fix' the issue. It's clearly hardware-based and can't be fixed with a firmware update. I guess it has something to do with a slight misalignment of one of the lens elements inside the camera module. My other guess would be a faulty lens element as in the element itself having imperfections on its surface - even the slightest bump on an otherwise flat surface can cause such optical issues.