Donating N5 to my Dad. Keep on stock Marshmallow or upgrade to Oreo?

redsmith

Senior Member
Apr 11, 2011
676
359
63
As said in the title, I'm giving my N5 to my father. Is it best to flash stock Marshmallow or try something a little speedier and secure but not as stable? What are your thoughts?

Thank you for all your recommendations.
 

stuffed_tiger

Member
Apr 19, 2013
48
2
0
34
if you want to do a little work before you give it to him, this is my suggestion. this is what i did for a long time, before i started really messing with my N5. (instructions for clarification, you probably already know how this stuff works.)

TL;DR: flash stock M -> root -> remove junk [-> unroot]

ive never actually unrooted so i dont know the process, but if you feel its a good idea...

INSTRUCTIONS:
- download and flash stock Android M from the google stock ROM collection. (hammerhead).
- wait until it reaches Startup Wizard and then reboot into bootloader.
- flash TWRP recovery.
- reboot into bootloader again.
- from recovery, flash SuperSU to gain root.
- reboot into system.
- after setting up the phone, disable first and then remove (titanium backup is my choice) any unnecessary app.
note: make sure the app is disabled. sometimes after you hit the disable button it just uninstalls updates without actually disabling it. the app will say Disabled in the app list.
note: you can filter installed apps in titanium backup by Frozen status so the disabled ones are easier to find.
- reboot.
- if youd like, here you could unroot.
- reboot and enjoy.

REMINDER:
removing certain apps can prevent basic functionality from working properly. trial by fire, i know for a fact that the system cannot run without the Google app installed. Google Play Services is another necessary one.

i feel marshmallow was a fantastic generation of android. i was always learning new things i could do. also, as a human with a father i feel he would benefit more from stability than from extra performance or features.

have fun, and be safe.
 
Last edited:

redsmith

Senior Member
Apr 11, 2011
676
359
63
Stick with marshmallow or, if you want to get rid of Google spying, go to lineageos 14.1.

What are you getting for yourself?
Two years ago I bought a OnePlus 3T, and I have been using a Pixel 2 for a year now. I wish Google released an improved Nexus 5. There are no good small phones anymore.
 
  • Like
Reactions: maybeme2

maybeme2

Senior Member
Aug 28, 2015
1,996
495
103
Two years ago I bought a OnePlus 3T, and I have been using a Pixel 2 for a year now. I wish Google released an improved Nexus 5. There are no good small phones anymore.
I guess the OnePlus 3T didn't do it for you...
How does the Pixel 2 compare with the nexus 5?

I'm using lineageos 14.1 with MicroG, Xprivacylua, and AFWall on my N5 (no Google apps) and would probably do the same with a new phone.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: forb'S and redsmith

xenyz

Senior Member
Oct 30, 2010
1,368
1,445
0
Is he going to be using it as his main cell phone? If you need stability the best bet is likely LineageOS 14.1

Personally, I'm on darkrom 7.1.2 (& elementalx 8.14 kernel) for more than a year now as I need a stable phone but LOS is more up-to-date.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: redsmith

redsmith

Senior Member
Apr 11, 2011
676
359
63
I guess the OnePlus 3T didn't do it for you...
How does the Pixel 2 compare with the nexus 5?

I'm using lineageos 14.1 with MicroG, Xprivacylua, and AFWall on my N5 (no Google apps) and would probably do the same with a new phone.
Actually the OP3T is wonderful. The only reason I got a Pixel is because my wife's N5 died, so I gave her the OP3T and then I bought myself a Pixel 2. Like most of us, I'm the unofficial smartphone dealer in the family...

The Pixel 2 is great. The camera is unrivaled and stock Android is lightning fast as always. That said, I wish it was the same size as the N5. No current smartphone can match the ergonomics of the late N5. If I were Google, I'd release the N5 with the same exact dimensions, OLED screen, current camera tech, bigger battery, and stereo speakers. I'd buy the **** out of that phone.