(Full Body Shield) vs (Screen Protector + Case)

[topdnbass]

I'm anticipating my next phone, the incredible, and I want to make sure I get my protective gear first.
So i don't end up with another broken phone (bye G1)

I am considering getting the Zagg full-body shield because I have a 50% off code.
Although I don't see a thin strip of plastic being very impact-resistant.
Pros: no added bulk, phone will look good, and no worries about the antenna strength being interfered with.
Also will fit nicer in the hand..
Cons: Might not work with an extended battery door. Could potentially feel worse in hand

Next option is to get a zagg/steinheil screen protector (or whatever is the best, since it's very difficult to decide)
Along with a case such as the Body Glove, or maybe a silicon case.
Pros: pretty much impact proof, maybe you prefer the bulk because it makes the phone fit in your hand better, also maybe the case just looks good
Cons: other than the obvious, it also may not fit into docks without removing the case first. Also, when I get an extended battery the case may no longer fit..

Possible cases below..

Body Glove (belt clip is removable and smooth cutout can be put to make the back smooth)
Also it gets rid of the unique back, if its not your style.

Amzer® Limited Edition Elite Leather Snap On Hard Case

Amzer® High Gloss TPU Skin Case

Amzer® Silicone Skin Jelly Case

Amzer® Rubberized Black Snap on Crystal Hard Case

There are plenty of other nice ones, I also liked this.
http://shop.htcpedia.com/index.php?dispatch=products.view&product_id=840

Please recommend a route, i'm all ears to any ideas.

 

[x.v_]

As you said, do you want impact resistance? You laid everything out nicely for yourself, now decide what is right for you.

 

[mrchambo]

Right now, I'm using the VZW high gloss silicone case and a Steinheil Crystal Clear screen protector. Very happy with both. Have had the case since day 1 and tried several other SPs before I settled on the Steinheil.

Am considering the Seidio Combo case, but will probably stick with the Steinheil for now (I have one left!)

Good luck!

JC

 

[t41n7ed]

I'm using a full body shield from BSE AND the black high gloss silicone case from VZW.

I like the BSE / ZAGG type screen protectors because they tend to self repair themselves if you scratch them. BSE all the way tho, I refuse to spend 20+ dollars on a skin.

http://www.bestskinsever.com/htc-droid-incredible-skin

plus

http://www.verizonwireless.com/b2c/store/accessory?action=accessoryDetails&archetypeId=12058