Galaxy S9/trade-in horror story

Jkcash

New member
Apr 13, 2015
3
2
0
I bought an S9 in early April from Samsung's website, and they were running a deal for $150 off with trade-in of my phone (the 1G Pixel 5"), along with a 99$ bundle that included the Gear VR, IconX, and wireless charger. That plus 720 for a brand new phone with rave reviews (basically the great S8 + a better camera, processor, etc) sounded like a good deal, and my Pixel's bluetooth issues were nagging as I had more accessories using it than before. Things were going well enough after this, but I had mixed feelings about the phone - the camera quality is incredibly inconsistent, really worse than the Pixel, battery life seemed worse than my 1.5 year old phone, and I wondered about future updates (or lack thereof), but I was happy enough with it.

Just over two weeks after buying it, just outside of my return period, Samsung informed me that my Pixel was not up to their terms for trade-in and they would be charging me $125 of the 150 trade-in value. $25 for my perfectly functional phone that I'm now honestly convinced was better in the first place, all things considered. They sent me two photos which show light paint specks missing, which on a metal phone is par for the course under "normal wear and tear" - which they said it was beyond. Absolutely ridiculous. Try sticking your phone in a bag with anything else and that not happening. The phone was in great shape when I sent it, well packaged, also in its nice fabric case, which I thought was a fun idea at the time. I have been back and forth with them on the BBB after waiting over two weeks for response from their support channel (I doubt they would ever have come up with an answer for me otherwise), and they are standing fast on not honoring their agreement while referring to me annoyingly as "valued Samsung customer" (whatever). I've seen this isn't a unique case and wonder if some sort of class action lawsuit is brewing (sign me up!).

The absolute lack of scruples they've shown in jipping me on this has turned this into a nice lifelong boycott for me, and I just wanted to warn anyone else against sending in their old baby (RIP Pixel ), if not buying their products entirely. I've since sold that S9 and bought a Pixel 2, which is such a better experience across the board (camera, battery, software, speed, not touching the screen because of tiny bezels, security updates, et. al) it's not even funny - despite running older hardware. Good learning experience for me, and I'll know never to expect anything from the brand again. I hope Samsung enjoys the $125 - I have a number of friends/family who take advice from me on phones, and I'll gladly inform them on my Valued Samsung Customer experience.

Just wanted to get my story out, so I'm sending it around. People should really know what this company is up to... Either way, thanks for reading!

 
  • Like
Reactions: siggey

preambean

Member
Feb 1, 2018
17
10
0
Adelaide
Tbh, judging by the pictures, i'd say Samsung are right. Seems like more than "normal wear and tear" to me. Never happened to any metal phones iv'e ever used or any phone iv'e seen being used carefully (BTW try using a case). In any case, I think it is up to Samsung on what they deem to be "normal wear and tear" unless it is completely unreasonable (which I don't think is your case).

-- not defending Samsung --

What does seem kind of ridiculous is that it took them over two weeks to make the decision that it was not "normal wear and tear", especially when that's after the return period.

As for a class action lawsuit, there are really are no grounds to accuse Samsung of anything. They haven't done anything wrong, just been annoying to deal with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kekistaneerefugee

Tel864

Senior Member
Nov 22, 2011
3,011
1,093
253
Greenville
Dont believe anything a phone manufacturer tells you and you'll never be disappointed. I've been lied to and seen broken promises from LG, Motorola/Lenovo, Samsung and Huawei so I try to make decisions on what I see in front of me and not what they promise. Well, maybe the Samsung promise of monthly updates got me. :laugh:
 
  • Like
Reactions: nexy33

nexy33

Senior Member
Jan 3, 2011
412
93
48
Dont believe anything a phone manufacturer tells you and you'll never be disappointed. I've been lied to and seen broken promises from LG, Motorola/Lenovo, Samsung and Huawei so I try to make decisions on what I see in front of me and not what they promise. Well, maybe the Samsung promise of monthly updates got me. :laugh:
ain't that the truth swift updates is the mobile market equivalent of don't worry I'll pull out in time
 

elliwigy

Forum Moderator / Recognized Developer
Staff member
Mar 16, 2011
12,925
8,800
253
Phoenix
www.sampwnd.com
cool story bro lol

fact is, you shouldve kept it and sold it yourself as you woukdve got more money in return..

i agree with sammy on this one, you knew there was some chips or w.e ur calling it when u sent it in and they were taking ur word for it that it was in good condition and turns out it wasnt..

now what i woukdve done was tell them to either honor it or send the phone back to me so i can resell it and get my moneys worth..

also, i own a p2xl as well, its a great phone dont get me wro g but the s9+ is too, if it wasnt locked bl id like it more than the p2xl in fact..

and those complaining about updates, im on 2ARF5 with June security patch.. last i checked pixels are still on June sec patch also, so its on par with updates, just sayin
 

Tel864

Senior Member
Nov 22, 2011
3,011
1,093
253
Greenville
cool story bro lol

fact is, you shouldve kept it and sold it yourself as you woukdve got more money in return..

i agree with sammy on this one, you knew there was some chips or w.e ur calling it when u sent it in and they were taking ur word for it that it was in good condition and turns out it wasnt..

now what i woukdve done was tell them to either honor it or send the phone back to me so i can resell it and get my moneys worth..

also, i own a p2xl as well, its a great phone dont get me wro g but the s9+ is too, if it wasnt locked bl id like it more than the p2xl in fact..

and those complaining about updates, im on 2ARF5 with June security patch.. last i checked pixels are still on June sec patch also, so its on par with updates, just sayin
Just sayjng, US unlocked phones are sitting on Feb security patches, not June and it was Samsung who committed to monthly updates a year ago.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sd_N

undertaker2k14

Senior Member
Nov 26, 2014
217
54
0
San Francisco, CA
Pulled the same thing with my wife's iphone, but I opened a dispute since I had pictures showing the phone working right before I sent it (they claimed it would not turn on) and promptly canceled the credit card they had on file so they cannot process this charge. Screw Samsung , first no updates for the S9 for 4 months !! Stuck on Feb patch and now they want to rob me of $175, not if I an help it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tel864