[GSI][ROM][ CURTANA | JOYEUSE | EXCALIBUR][10.0][AOSP+GAPPS][04/08/20]

[foneiamone]

Patch stock boot image with magisk then flash it via fastboot

Sent from my Redmi Note 9 Pro using Tapatalk

I did this and still bootlooping ?

 

[sooti]

rooting via magisk causing bootloop! what am I doing wrong?

Patch stock boot image with magisk then flash it via fastboot

I did this and still bootlooping ?

Guys I've repeated myself too much, magisk is broken on all GSIs, talk to the magisk dev if you want him to fix it, this is not the place

 

[dmenezes]

Guys I've repeated myself too much, magisk is broken on all GSIs, talk to the magisk dev if you want him to fix it, this is not the place

@sooti, sorry to bother you but just to clarify: you mean only the newest (v21+) Magisk, right? I have v20.4 here working perfectly with this exact ROM.

So, unless I'm missing something, a good solution for @foneiamone ppl running this and other Android10 GSIs would be to use v20.4 Magisk instead of the latest versions, until at least its developer fixes it.

 

[dmenezes]

(duplicated post, deleted)

 

[sooti]

@sooti, sorry to bother you but just to clarify: you mean only the newest (v21+) Magisk, right? I have v20.4 here working perfectly with this exact ROM.

So, unless I'm missing something, a good solution for @foneiamone ppl running this and other Android10 GSIs would be to use v20.4 Magisk instead of the latest versions, until at least its developer fixes it.

Sorry I meant 20.4 works fine on Q no magisk works on R

 

[dmenezes]

Hi so I know you don't need to flash TWRP but is TWRP bad/unstable for this device in general? Would it cause any conflicts if flashed?

I've learned that TWRP doesn't work with GSI ROMs in general; to flash GSI you gotta use recovery. (Someone please correct me if I'm wrong).

 

[foneiamone]

I've learned that TWRP doesn't work with GSI ROMs in general; to flash GSI you gotta use recovery. (Someone please correct me if I'm wrong).

I don't know about twrp but I've installed android 10 gsi with lineage recovery. I think twrp doesn't work because of it not having fastbootd. Lineage recovery has fastbootd !!

---------- Post added at 06:19 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:16 PM ----------

Guys I've repeated myself too much, magisk is broken on all GSIs, talk to the magisk dev if you want him to fix it, this is not the place

ok! that's fine just mention this to your post. many people don't read these comments. like me?

---------- Post added at 06:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:19 PM ----------

@sooti, sorry to bother you but just to clarify: you mean only the newest (v21+) Magisk, right? I have v20.4 here working perfectly with this exact ROM.

So, unless I'm missing something, a good solution for @foneiamone ppl running this and other Android10 GSIs would be to use v20.4 Magisk instead of the latest versions, until at least its developer fixes it.

Let's see

 

[raenye]

@sooti Since GSI 11 has no magisk (and won't have it anytime soon), could you please build GSI 10 with up-to-date security patches?
I'm not saying monthly builds, but perhaps every 2-3 months? Just until GSI 11 is ready for prime time?

Thanks in advance.

 

[sooti]

@sooti Since GSI 11 has no magisk (and won't have it anytime soon), could you please build GSI 10 with up-to-date security patches?
I'm not saying monthly builds, but perhaps every 2-3 months? Just until GSI 11 is ready for prime time?

Thanks in advance.

No, sorry

 

[dmenezes]

@sooti Since GSI 11 has no magisk (and won't have it anytime soon), could you please build GSI 10 with up-to-date security patches?
I'm not saying monthly builds, but perhaps every 2-3 months? Just until GSI 11 is ready for prime time?
Thanks in advance.

I would like to add myself to @raenye's request; being too much "out of date" in relation to security patches makes me really nervous, and without Magisk we can't have root and SafetyNet at the same time (which makes 11 unusable to me).
@sooti, I know this is a lot to ask -- perhaps if I and the other users pool together to make a donation in order to finance this extra work, it would become feasible?

Thanks in advance for your consideration,
-- Durval.

 

[samcess]

Is this safe to install? I have have unlocked bootloader.its my firsr time to flash without using recovery. Will this cause my device to brick?

 

[dmenezes]

Hello @samcess,

​

Is this safe to install? I have have unlocked bootloader.its my firsr time to flash without using recovery. Will this cause my device to brick?

Only if you f*ck it up Seriously, I and many others have installed it by carefully following @sooti's instructions on the first post, and we did not brick any phones. YMMV of course, depending on how attentive to the instructions you are. If you're in doubt about your own capacity in doing that, I suggest that you do not install.

 

[sooti]

I would like to add myself to @raenye's request; being too much "out of date" in relation to security patches makes me really nervous, and without Magisk we can't have root and SafetyNet at the same time (which makes 11 unusable to me).

@sooti, I know this is a lot to ask -- perhaps if I and the other users pool together to make a donation in order to finance this extra work, it would become feasible?

Thanks in advance for your consideration,
-- Durval.

No, sorry,. But the script is in my repo, under local_manifest, just follow instructions and build it yourself. Good luck

 

[samcess]

Hello @samcess,

​

Only if you f*ck it up Seriously, I and many others have installed it by carefully following @sooti's instructions on the first post, and we did not brick any phones. YMMV of course, depending on how attentive to the instructions you are. If you're in doubt about your own capacity in doing that, I suggest that you do not install.

I usually triple check every step before proceeding. I'm just afraid like other rom still causing brick after following exact instructions. Afraid to brick this device since i dont have xiaomi service center here in my place. If this brick my device it'll end up in trash can.

---------- Post added at 07:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:34 PM ----------

Does this rom support adoptable storage(Format sd card as internal)? That's actually my main goal why i plan to use custom rom.

---------- Post added at 07:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:01 PM ----------

Does this rom support Adoptable storage (format sd card as internal) without bugs?

 

[dmenezes]

Wrong Thread, reposted.

 

[sooti]

@sooti, I understand. And no need to apologize, on the contrary, we all have to thank you for the great work you did, and continue to do, with your ROMs.


I may well try... not much experience with Android development, but I've been a C/Java programmer for a few decades(!), and I don't imagine that simply building it would be much too difficult.
But what about integrating Google's security patches monthly? Can you point me towards a "tutorial" or some introductory text dealing with that?

Thanks again,
-- Durval.

Just run the script once a month when the patch comes out

 

[dmenezes]

Wrong thread, deleted/reposted.

 

[CosmicDan]

I've learned that TWRP doesn't work with GSI ROMs in general; to flash GSI you gotta use recovery. (Someone please correct me if I'm wrong).

It always worked fine in my experience, at least on the Mi A1 and Poco F1. You just have to flash the raw IMG and make sure you have TWRP set to keep system read-only.

If it isn't working then it may be a problem with TWRP.

Sent from my POCOPHONE F1 using Tapatalk

 

[HELLBOY017]

Is there face unlock in it?

 

[sooti]

It always worked fine in my experience, at least on the Mi A1 and Poco F1. You just have to flash the raw IMG and make sure you have TWRP set to keep system read-only.

If it isn't working then it may be a problem with TWRP.

No, twrp fadtbootd on curtana is broken, you need to use lineage recovery or stock to flash