Finally working 10/6/13
You need to be on an LJ7 Rom.
Finally got my MSL. I was running MOAR v5.0.1 rooted with SuperSU and nothing would get the number. This included running getmymsl from the Play store, entering wrong code and checking alogcat and running adb shell/msl commands with root access and the getprop ril.MSL command.
As a last ditch effort I took prboy1969's suggestion and flashed the stock JB 4.1.1 L710VPBLJ7 via Odin v.307
I logged in and ran getmymsl from the play store and voila, finally got my 6 digit MSL
Wrote it all down, reflashed MOAR w/ root and tested my MSL code. All is working and I was finally able to write a new PRL to my phone. So far so good.
To everyone here, thanks for the help!