Got my second case in the mail, have been using it for a few weeks and thought I'd report back.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/160683756830
Got the white for something different, and was surprised to actually like the color.
More importantly, I like this cover more than I liked the previous black one. This one covers more of the top and bottom than the black one did, even covering the one ding I have on the top.
It fits snugly and the plastic is slick enough to go in and out of my pocket easily. Not sure how evident it is from the eBay pic, but there is a knobbed "grip" section on either side that I really REALLY appreciate! I might not even have a ding to cover up if I had had this sort of grip on the naked phone! I was worried about that crazy line across the back, but it doesn't really bug me, and you can find this style of case in just about any color you want.
The other interesting thing is that the power, camera and volume buttons are covered by this case, but the case actually has raised "buttons" of its own where those buttons are. As such, they are actually both EASIER to find now that the case is on than they were on the naked phone! Big plus for me.
Oh, and both of these cases were dirt cheap.