LG G5 vs. LG V10

[invertedskull]

Hey.

So I'm in the market for a new phone, just coming from the LG G3. I was meant to be getting the G4, but now I have the option for ANYTHING. And I'm leaning toward the G5 or the V10 right now.

I'd love some opinions on why the G5 is the way to go over the V10, or vice versa. But I should explain something first... I have a sort of criteria in mind for my next phone.

• Screen size: I would love to keep the size under 5.5". So the G5 is more favourable there.
• Removable battery: Both the G5 and V10 have this, so woohoo!
• Headphone jack: IMO it belongs on the base of the device. It's far more convenient for me this way. V10 wins here. HOWEVER, I know about the Hi-Fi Plus module, so this could be something I change on the G5.
• mSD Card slot: Both have it, woohoo again.

I've heard a lot of negatives for the G5 too. A lot of videos have surfaced of people complaining about the seam between the body and the chin / module. The body and chin not matching up nicely... Dust gathering inside this gap... But I haven't heard the same about this WITH the Hi-Fi Plus module in use. So if I were to get the G5, I would definitely get the Hi-Fi Plus module too so I have the headphone jack at the base... I would use it all the time. But then I wonder if I will ever find a case that will fit the phone with this module in use. I think I've seen one, but I cannot recall where now. I always have bought cases for my phones.

The V10 looks and sounds pretty great too. I'm not a big fan of the "grip" back panel, and of course the screen and body size is a bit big for my liking, but I could suck it up for the sake of the other criteria I have. However, it is a bit older than the G5 and I would like to buy a more recent device if possible.

Ugh, I really can't decide! I need some opinions from some owners!

 

[PHYCLOPSH]

The V10 will have a slightly larger screen and better audio capabilities out of the box, but the G5 will be better in the long run as it has a newer SOC that is at least 30% more powerful. The G5 is also now steeply discounted in many places making it a great value overall. If you must have a V series device, I would suggest waiting another month so you can get the V20 which will include the same powerful SOC as the G5 as well as the other perks of the V series.

 

[tejasm1]

Hey.

So I'm in the market for a new phone, just coming from the LG G3. I was meant to be getting the G4, but now I have the option for ANYTHING. And I'm leaning toward the G5 or the V10 right now.

I'd love some opinions on why the G5 is the way to go over the V10, or vice versa. But I should explain something first... I have a sort of criteria in mind for my next phone.

• Screen size: I would love to keep the size under 5.5". So the G5 is more favourable there.
• Removable battery: Both the G5 and V10 have this, so woohoo!
• Headphone jack: IMO it belongs on the base of the device. It's far more convenient for me this way. V10 wins here. HOWEVER, I know about the Hi-Fi Plus module, so this could be something I change on the G5.
• mSD Card slot: Both have it, woohoo again.

I've heard a lot of negatives for the G5 too. A lot of videos have surfaced of people complaining about the seam between the body and the chin / module. The body and chin not matching up nicely... Dust gathering inside this gap... But I haven't heard the same about this WITH the Hi-Fi Plus module in use. So if I were to get the G5, I would definitely get the Hi-Fi Plus module too so I have the headphone jack at the base... I would use it all the time. But then I wonder if I will ever find a case that will fit the phone with this module in use. I think I've seen one, but I cannot recall where now. I always have bought cases for my phones.

The V10 looks and sounds pretty great too. I'm not a big fan of the "grip" back panel, and of course the screen and body size is a bit big for my liking, but I could suck it up for the sake of the other criteria I have. However, it is a bit older than the G5 and I would like to buy a more recent device if possible.

Ugh, I really can't decide! I need some opinions from some owners!

Wait till Sept. 6th when the V20 will get announced. Probably will have bigger display but the bezels seem pretty small. You'll hopefully have a v10 with better specs and I don't think it will have the rubberish back. I wish I had waited.
Pictures:

 

[invertedskull]

Thanks guys. TBH, I'm not sold on the V10 or V20 due to the screen size being much larger than I want. I really want keep it under 5.5". I'm not sure what to make of the secondary screen either. I'm REALLY torn what to do...

I've also been without the use of a proper phone for about a month now and I am itching to get something. It's all due to the place where I bought the LG G3 screwing me over big time. I was told I was getting the G4 as a replacement, and they were just stringing me along. I'm also frustrated at the lack of really great flagship devices that have a removable battery. Very disheartened to the direction the smartphone industry is moving toward.

 

[Lukijs]

G5, just go for it.

 

[kms108]

G5 with B&O modular is similar size to the V10, like wise if the V20 is the same size to the V10, wait for the V20, overall without seeing the V20, V10 is a better choice as the phone has a much solid built.

BTW the G5 has 4 cases available at present to support the B&O modular and 1 case for the cam plus modular.

 

[lolmensch]

I ve never seen a v10 but I don't understand where all the hate is coming from. My previous phone was a note 2 and I'm just happy with the G5. It is superior in every aspect. The only small disadvantage is the battery life compared to the note series.

Absolutely love the performance and the camera. Especially the wide angle lense is able to to make some nice photos.

 

[ngerlach15]

I personally like the G5. I believe it only gets so much hate because LG tried to be innovative with the modularity aspect and didn't do that great of a job. As a standalone phone it's specs are good IMO and it performs well. I haven't had any issues. My biggest complaint is that when not in a case it is a little bit slippery but that's pretty nit picky.

Sent from my LG-H820 using Tapatalk

 

[invertedskull]

Thanks everyone. I'm leaning more toward the G5 again... But man, I am having such a hard time deciding. I think It's a combination of being spoiled for choice and me being too damn fussy. My dream phone with that criteria will never get made, I need to accept it. The G5 is REALLY close.

I'm such a damn nerd I made up an Excel spreadsheet and punched in several phones with all their specs that come close to fitting my criteria. If you are interested, here's what I was looking at:

• LG G4
• LG G5
• LG V10
• Asus ZenFone 2 Laser
• Asus ZenFone 2 Deluxe
• HTC One M9
• HTC One M9+
  
• Xiaomi Redmi Note 2
• Samsung Galaxy S7

The bold ones made my shortlist.

Then I got a notepad and ruler and actually drew exact measured sizes of those four phones to compare the sizes. I don't have quick and easy access to a store where all of those are easily comparable. So I think I am going to regret the V10 (or V20) due to the size. It is a monster. The S7 is still a couple hundred $ more than the others, and the One M9+ is getting old now... So I keep coming back to the G5.

But I'm really concerned about the seam between the body and chin. Can any G5 owners tell me if the body / chin seam is a bit funny or does line up perfectly? Is is something I could possibly (and unintentionally of course) fiddle with too much and cause it to shift and not line up as nicely over time?

 

[kms108]

Thanks everyone. I'm leaning more toward the G5 again... But man, I am having such a hard time deciding. I think It's a combination of being spoiled for choice and me being too damn fussy. My dream phone with that criteria will never get made, I need to accept it. The G5 is REALLY close.

I'm such a damn nerd I made up an Excel spreadsheet and punched in several phones with all their specs that come close to fitting my criteria. If you are interested, here's what I was looking at:

• LG G4
• LG G5
• LG V10
• Asus ZenFone 2 Laser
• Asus ZenFone 2 Deluxe
• HTC One M9
• HTC One M9+
  
• Xiaomi Redmi Note 2
• Samsung Galaxy S7

The bold ones made my shortlist.

Then I got a notepad and ruler and actually drew exact measured sizes of those four phones to compare the sizes. I don't have quick and easy access to a store where all of those are easily comparable. So I think I am going to regret the V10 (or V20) due to the size. It is a monster. The S7 is still a couple hundred $ more than the others, and the One M9+ is getting old now... So I keep coming back to the G5.

But I'm really concerned about the seam between the body and chin. Can any G5 owners tell me if the body / chin seam is a bit funny or does line up perfectly? Is is something I could possibly (and unintentionally of course) fiddle with too much and cause it to shift and not line up as nicely over time?

its a hit or miss situation.

 

[invertedskull]

I've gone with the G5. Ordered the G5 H860 along with the Hi-Fi Plus module and battery charging kit.

 

[PlagasX]

Wish I could get the B/O module with my T Mobile G5...

 

[PHYCLOPSH]

I've gone with the G5. Ordered the G5 H860 along with the Hi-Fi Plus module and battery charging kit.

Good choice. I hope you enjoy it as much as we do.

 

[invertedskull]

Wish I could get the B/O module with my T Mobile G5...

Can't you get around that by rooting it? I plan to root my G5 in the first week I get it.

 

[Lukijs]

I've gone with the G5. Ordered the G5 H860 along with the Hi-Fi Plus module and battery charging kit.

Is the module really worth it? I've heard for several sources that youreally can't feel difference(eith hi-fi headsets of course)

 

[PlagasX]

Can't you get around that by rooting it? I plan to root my G5 in the first week I get it.

Is this true?

 

[invertedskull]

Is this true?

I haven't looked into it enough, but I think it will only be a matter of gaining root access and / or flashing a different region firmware... Someone correct me if I'm wrong?

 

[invertedskull]

Is the module really worth it? I've heard for several sources that youreally can't feel difference(eith hi-fi headsets of course)

I'm kind of buying the Hi-Fi Plus module cos I want the headphone jack on the bottom of the phone. Once I get it I'll let you know if I hear a big difference or not.

I have a DAC I used to use with my old Cowon S9 MP3 player, and the audio difference was a little, but not worth using all the time due to the extra cable and the DAC requiring to be charged in addition to the MP3 player. But the Hi-Fi Plus will be connected to the G5, eliminating both of those factors.