Magisk General Support / Discussion

[zgfg]

What happens if you freeze magisk using Link2SD or another app? Will you have to reinstall it from TWRP?

Please distinguish Magisk app from Magisk itself (patched into the img, data saved under /data/adb)

You can even uninstall Magisk app, Magisk will continue to work but you will not be able to grant new root requests and manage other things like modules, etc - but what was configured will continue to work.
And you can later reinstall/unfreeze the app and continue to use it for managing

 

[SlimShady08]

Please distinguish Magisk app from Magisk itself (patched into the img, data saved under /data/adb)

You can even uninstall Magisk app, Magisk will continue to work but you will not be able to grant new root requests and manage other things like modules, etc - but what was configured will continue to work.
And you can later reinstall/unfreeze the app and continue to use it for managing

Oh! Thank you so much for educating me and clearing it up. Cheers.

 

[pndwal]

'Stable' Canary!

PW

 

[amk316]

connect your phone to a pc restart your phone then do adb logcat > logcat.txt in powershell let it log till your phone restart then share your log here you'll have a better chance of resolving your issue

her is a logcat during the reboot
thx

 

[yujincheng08]

her is a logcat during the reboot
thx

01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: [email protected]*** FATAL EXCEPTION IN SYSTEM PROCESS: Thread-42
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Unknown authority com.samsung.klmsagent.provider
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: at android.content.ContentResolver.call(ContentResolver.java:2454)
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: at android.content.ContentResolver.call(ContentResolver.java:2437)
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: at com.android.server.enterprise.license.EnterpriseLicenseService.lambda$activateKnoxLicense$2$EnterpriseLicenseService(EnterpriseLicenseService.java:1437)
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: at com.android.server.enterprise.license.EnterpriseLicenseService$$ExternalSyntheticLambda1.run(Unknown Source:4)
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: at java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:920)

 

[SOCOM-HERO]

.

 

[zxxz0x0]

I am using Magisk V23, since the V24 launches. I can't create "Hide the Magisk App" of V23 anymore, do anyone get a bug like me
I tried V23 to create "Hide the Magisk App" on many Android devices and have such an error

 

[zxxz0x0]

I am using Magisk V23, since the V24 launches. I can't create "Hide the Magisk App" of V23 anymore, do anyone get a bug like me
I tried V23 to create "Hide the Magisk App" on many Android devices and have such an error
Android 10 - Magisk 23000

 

[zgfg]

I am using Magisk V23, since the V24 launches. I can't create "Hide the Magisk App" of V23 anymore, do anyone get a bug like me
I tried V23 to create "Hide the Magisk App" on many Android devices and have such an error

You are still on v23 and Hide Magisk app fails - what is exactly the error?

I suppose that v23 stub somehow connects to the new v24 Magisk app, causing to fail

Frankly, it should not be the case, but bugs are always possible, and specially this story with hiding/unhiding/hidden while updating are known to be 'touchy'

 

[zxxz0x0]

You are still on v23 and Hide Magisk app fails - what is exactly the error?

I suppose that v23 stub somehow connects to the new v24 Magisk app, causing to fail

Frankly, it should not be the case, but bugs are always possible, and specially this story with hiding/unhiding/hidden while updating are known to be 'touchy'

When creating "Hide The Magisk App" it creates a icon according to the registration name. But that icon is unusable and the old Magisk App remains. Cannot use hidden root at V23 anymore. I have many jobs to do on the old device so I don't want to go to V24 now

 

[zgfg]

When creating "Hide The Magisk App" it creates a icon according to the registration name. But that icon is unusable and the old Magisk App remains. Cannot use hidden root at V23 anymore. I have many jobs to do on the old device so I don't want to go to V24 now

Sorry, bad luck (don't understand why do you need to hide the old v23 Magisk app today now right after the v24 was released, if you hid v23 over the last 9 or so months, there wouldn't be a problem)

You could try the following: find the exact URL for v23 stable json on Github and set it as Custum channel for the Updates channel - then perform Hide Magisk app

 

[meric57]

Good evening, how and why rooting jumps when there is an update. I had the magisk 32fc34f9 24101 update is boom magisk not installed, since yesterday rooting ok I had to redo the rooting.
Also why the internal memory ends up at 15 GB or 32 GB that I have 128 GB on my S10.

 

[jons99]

her is a logcat during the reboot
thx

well like the guy above said it's caused by:
--------- beginning of crash
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: [email protected]*** FATAL EXCEPTION IN SYSTEM PROCESS: Thread-42
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Unknown authority com.samsung.klmsagent.provider
not sure what it means maybe a smarter guy in this forum can tell you but what I did find is someone with the same issue as you and he says that if he restart with the wifi off he doesn't get a reboot

Bootschleife des Galaxy S20 5G, wenn WLAN aktiviert ist

Hi, seit dem Sicherheitspatch Januar 2022, hängt mein S20 in einer Bootschleife fest. Es erscheint nach dem Startvorgang die PIN-Eingabe und wenige Augenblicke danach startet das Telefon neu. Starte ich im abgesicherten Modus, läuft das Telefon normal. Starte ich es danach wieder normal, dann...

www.android-hilfe.de

 

[J.Michael]

When creating "Hide The Magisk App" it creates a icon according to the registration name. But that icon is unusable and the old Magisk App remains. Cannot use hidden root at V23 anymore. I have many jobs to do on the old device so I don't want to go to V24 now

Tell us: Have you ever hidden the Magisk app?

It sounds like you installed a new Magisk app without unhiding the old app first.

Look carefully at all apps. Start with those shortcuts on your home screen. Press and hold an icon. Select "App info". Look for where it identifies the app -- I think usually at the bottom of the info screen it shows a version number, and maybe from where app was downloaded. If it might be a version of the Magisk app, uninstall it. Do that for every possible Magisk app. (I would reboot at this point -- not Restart; Shutdown and then reboot.) Then install the one version of the Magisk app you want

 

[zxxz0x0]

Tell us: Have you ever hidden the Magisk app?

It sounds like you installed a new Magisk app without unhiding the old app first.

Look carefully at all apps. Start with those shortcuts on your home screen. Press and hold an icon. Select "App info". Look for where it identifies the app -- I think usually at the bottom of the info screen it shows a version number, and maybe from where app was downloaded. If it might be a version of the Magisk app, uninstall it. Do that for every possible Magisk app. (I would reboot at this point -- not Restart; Shutdown and then reboot.) Then install the one version of the Magisk app you want

I have hidden Magisk V23 for 4 months and it still hides good root. Until the V24 appears and does not use hidden Root V23 anymore

 

[J.Michael]

Good evening, how and why rooting jumps when there is an update. I had the magisk 32fc34f9 24101 update is boom magisk not installed, since yesterday rooting ok I had to redo the rooting.
Also why the internal memory ends up at 15 GB or 32 GB that I have 128 GB on my S10.

Re: smaller /data
Read John Wu's Installation Instructions.
He warns: if you do not give Odin all four kinds of files, Odim might shrink the data partition.

 

[amk316]

well like the guy above said it's caused by:
--------- beginning of crash
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: [email protected]*** FATAL EXCEPTION IN SYSTEM PROCESS: Thread-42
01-28 16:36:31.970 6804 9224 E AndroidRuntime: java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Unknown authority com.samsung.klmsagent.provider
not sure what it means maybe a smarter guy in this forum can tell you but what I did find is someone with the same issue as you and he says that if he restart with the wifi off he doesn't get a reboot

Bootschleife des Galaxy S20 5G, wenn WLAN aktiviert ist

Hi, seit dem Sicherheitspatch Januar 2022, hängt mein S20 in einer Bootschleife fest. Es erscheint nach dem Startvorgang die PIN-Eingabe und wenige Augenblicke danach startet das Telefon neu. Starte ich im abgesicherten Modus, läuft das Telefon normal. Starte ich es danach wieder normal, dann...

www.android-hilfe.de

well i turn off the wifi and rebooted but still reboots
i put airplane mode on and rebooted and it DID NOT reboot!!!

 

[An68]

I've never seen anyone use MiFlash to install Magisk! - Why are you doing that rather than following official instructions (install ADB drivers and flash with Fastboot command)?

Tip: on Xiaomi devices, generally Recovery mode option should be unchecked if it appears as Xiaomi bootloaders are compatible with ramdisk in boot partition and magisk will install one even when OEM hasn't. PW

Thanks, no I used fastboot command , this is the PC name folder where I moved the image patched.
This step is mandatory, because I moved with the PC the image patched

In need helps for this step, I should rename the magisk patched image?

Where I unchecked Recovery mode option?

Find thanks, I haven't the right recovery

Thanks

 

[jons99]

I have hidden Magisk V23 for 4 months and it still hides good root. Until the V24 appears and does not use hidden Root V23 anymore

read this

[Discussion] Magisk - The Age of Zygisk.

This is a discussion and help thread for the newer versions of Magisk. The main goal of this thread is to help users migrate to Magisk v24+ SafetyNet Basic integrity Pass CTS profile match Pass Play Protect certification Device is certified...

forum.xda-developers.com

 

[J.Michael]

I have hidden Magisk V23 for 4 months and it still hides good root. Until the V24 appears and does not use hidden Root V23 anymore

That is the point: I think you installed the new app without first uninstalling the old app.

There is no "hidden root". "Hide Magisk app" does not hide root. It hides the Magisk app.