Magisk General Support / Discussion

[jons99]

I have hidden Magisk V23 for 4 months and it still hides good root. Until the V24 appears and does not use hidden Root V23 anymore

read this

[Discussion] Magisk - The Age of Zygisk.

This is a discussion and help thread for the newer versions of Magisk. The main goal of this thread is to help users migrate to Magisk v24+ SafetyNet Basic integrity Pass CTS profile match Pass Play Protect certification Device is certified...

forum.xda-developers.com

 

[J.Michael]

I have hidden Magisk V23 for 4 months and it still hides good root. Until the V24 appears and does not use hidden Root V23 anymore

That is the point: I think you installed the new app without first uninstalling the old app.

There is no "hidden root". "Hide Magisk app" does not hide root. It hides the Magisk app.

 

[jons99]

Thanks, no I used fastboot command , this is the PC name folder where I moved the image patched.
This step is mandatory, because I moved with the PC the image patched
View attachment 5521607
In need helps for this step, I should rename the magisk patched image?
View attachment 5521609
Where I unchecked Recovery mode option?
Thanks

no need to rename. open your platform tools folder in that folder open powershell type fastboot boot and drag and drop the boot img file then press enter.
tho this will only boot that img if you want to flash it you need to write fastboot flash boot then drag and drop

 

[zxxz0x0]

That is the point: I think you installed the new app without first uninstalling the old app.

There is no "hidden root". "Hide Magisk app" does not hide root. It hides the Magisk app.

yes i cant creat hide magisk app , That makes me worry about some applications will see Magisk in my device

 

[vandyman]

I just wanted to throw this out there for people needing to troubleshoot.
Matlog is a handy tool to have.

 

[zxxz0x0]

That is the point: I think you installed the new app without first uninstalling the old app.

There is no "hidden root". "Hide Magisk app" does not hide root. It hides the Magisk app.

The bank application does not work again in V23 when it is impossible to create "Hide The Magisk App" whether Magisk Hide is hiding the banking application. Another error I met at V24 is not possible to denylist Google Play Service when installing Modul SafetyNet-Fix. That makes me unable to pass Safety Net and use the bank application.

 

[zgfg]

The bank application does not work again in V23 when it is impossible to create "Hide The Magisk App" whether Magisk Hide is hiding the banking application. Another error I met at V24 is not possible to denylist Google Play Service when installing Modul SafetyNet-Fix. That makes me unable to pass Safety Net and use the bank application.

If you don't need Magisk app on a daily basis, you can uninstall the app (not Magisk)

All modules, root grants, MagiskHide (since you are on v23) will continue to work

Only when you need, you install that same Magisk v23 app (keep the apk handy), you will install the app, grant a new root, manage modules, sonething and uninstall the app again

 

[zxxz0x0]

If you don't need Magisk app on a daily basis, you can uninstall the app (not Magisk)

All modules, root grants, MagiskHide (since you are on v23) will continue to work

Only when you need, you install that same Magisk v23 app (keep the apk handy), you will install the app, grant a new root, manage modules, sonething and uninstall the app again

I need root to work but also need to hide root bank and game app. I tried to remove and reinstall Magisk many times even reinstall ROMs but encountered errors in V23 as above. It was 3am but I still hope to try to overcome tomorrow not affecting the job

 

[zgfg]

I need root to work but also need to hide root bank and game app. I tried to remove and reinstall Magisk many times even reinstall ROMs but encountered errors in V23 as above. It was 3am but I still hope to try to overcome tomorrow not affecting the job

I'm not talking about uninstalling Magisk

When Magisk app is uninstalled, then it is better hidden then if you just hide it - isn't it?

I wrote about uninstalling Magisk app - read my previoud post carefully again, and again, and again if needed

If you don't distinguish Magisk from, then why Magisk app separately describes the version of MAGISK installed, and bellow the version of MAGISK APP installed

 

[zxxz0x0]

Sorry for my English is not good, can misunderstand what you say. I cannot removed and reset the application or Magisk because it takes a lot of time and those applications need to run parallel to each other

I'm not talking about uninstalling Magisk

When Magisk app is uninstalled, then it is better hidden then if you just hide it - isn't it?

I wrote about uninstalling Magisk app - read my previoud post carefully again, and again, and again if needed

If you don't distinguish Magisk from, then why Magisk app separately describes the version of MAGISK installed, and bellow the version of MAGISK APP installed

 

[zgfg]

Sorry for my English is not good, can misunderstand what you say. I cannot removed and reset the application or Magisk because it takes a lot of time and those applications need to run parallel to each other

Phone Settings, Apps, find Magisk app and Uninstall it there

Just that, DO NOT DO anything else

 

[zxxz0x0]

Phone Settings, Apps, find Magisk app and Uninstall it therey

I can distinguish Magisk and Magisk Manager. Uninstalling Magisk Manger can hide root?

 

[zxxz0x0]

Phone Settings, Apps, find Magisk app and Uninstall it there

Just that, DO NOT DO anything else

ah okay I understand what you say, delete Magisk Manager so that the application doesn't see but still turn on Magisk Hide

 

[zgfg]

I can distinguish Magisk and Magisk Manager. Uninstalling Magisk Manger can hide root?

You complained that for Magisk v23 you cannot do "Hide Magisk app", didn't you

I'm telling you that instead of "Hide Magisk app" you uninstall Magisk app

Magisk app = Magisk manager - it is not Magisk

Of course, before you uninstall Magisk app (call it Magisk Manager if you like), fully setup your Magisk v23 - all modules, root grants, MagiskHide

 

[zxxz0x0]

Phone Settings, Apps, find Magisk app and Uninstall it there

Just that, DO NOT DO anything else

I tried but the bank app still detected root, maybe V23 is faulty

 

[zxxz0x0]

You complained that for Magisk v23 you cannot do "Hide Magisk app", didn't you

I'm telling you that instead of "Hide Magisk app" you uninstall Magisk app

Magisk app = Magisk manager - it is not Magisk

Of course, before you uninstall Magisk app (call it Magisk Manager if you like), fully setup your Magisk v23 - all modules, root grants, MagiskHide

Safetynet pass , magisk hide on , magisk app delete , bank app still detected

 

[zgfg]

Safetynet pass , magisk hide on , magisk app delete , bank app still detected

Then it's something else, banking apps get smarter and smarter to detect or guess about rooting

But believe me, if it detects now, it would also detect if you kept Magisk app installefd but just did "Hide Magisk app".
Bcs, the app is NOW UNINSTALLED, not just HIDDEN (some banking apps detect even hudden Magisk app)

It's not about finding Magisk app

Go to Magisk Github, read Wiki, there is a section with tricks how banking apps may detect 'root' and hints how you try to beat them:

Hiding root from apps:Magisk and MagiskHide Installation and Troubleshooting guide

www.didgeridoohan.com

 

[zxxz0x0]

Then it's something else, banking apps get smarter and smarter to detect or guess about rooting

But believe me, if it detects now, it would also detect if you kept Magisk app installefd but just did "Hide Magisk app".
Bcs, the app is NOW UNINSTALLED, not just HIDDEN (some banking apps detect even hudden Magisk app)

It's not about finding Magisk app

Go to Magisk Github, read Wiki, there is a section with tricks how banking apps may detect 'root' and hints how you try to beat them:

Hiding root from apps:Magisk and MagiskHide Installation and Troubleshooting guide

www.didgeridoohan.com

I tried on the V24 with Zygisk Denylist + USNF as you guide another post or follow Youtube. Yasnac Pass SafetyNet But Other App (Safynet Test) Failed with Error (Cant Access Google Play Service). Banking still doesn't work. I do not use a lot of bank applications because I have many devices but I'm frequently used to check Magisk Hide operations. Before V24 officially released everything to operate normally. I am not specializing in phone so only focus on V23 version research . Thank you for guiding new users like me

 

[c3k]

Safetynet pass , magisk hide on , magisk app delete , bank app still detected

Have you cleared bank app data, right?

 

[zxxz0x0]

Have you cleared bank app data, right?

yes , alway force stop and clear data cache, restard device many time