On official Canary : Momo is working fine. No crash / No issues.on official Canary and latest Alpha, when Momo is in denylist, it crashes on startup.
I remember it does not happen to me only
On official Canary : Momo is working fine. No crash / No issues.on official Canary and latest Alpha, when Momo is in denylist, it crashes on startup.
I remember it does not happen to me only
Same in my RN8T. PWon official Canary and latest Alpha, when Momo is in denylist, it crashes on startup.
I remember it does not happen to me only
Moved to latest Canary, haven't had a minute today; may not test latest Alpha, sorry... May have misunderstood some of your points earlier... Haven't even played much with new Canary...Did you try:
- Does it show Update icon based on json
- Does LSposed v1.6.5(6315) (latest from TG, that worked fine with previous Alpha) work with Shamiko (or reports incompatibility), and with which version of Shamiko
- Does the accompanying latest Shamiko v0.3.0(73) (published together today on Alpha TG channel) show the status
Asking for the 'second opinion' - I had all those issues and I had to go back to Alpha 76ddfeb9 (23016) with the accompanying Shamiko v0.2.0(59)
with latest Alpha/Shamiko (yesterday's releases), update button is not thereMoved to latest Canary, haven't had a minute today; may not test latest Alpha, sorry... May have misunderstood some of your points earlier... Haven't even played much with new Canary...
Can say w/ 72 Shamiko Mono crashes if in denylist for me too ... I see update button but greyed out / does nothing... May manually update Shamiko later... LSPosed seems to be working fine w/ 72 anyway... PW
That was exactly one of my points about Alpha 23017with latest Alpha/Shamiko (yesterday's releases), update button is not there
are you on Android 11+? on LOS 18.1 I observe same behaviourCurious
I Installed
- Magisk 761a8dde-alpha
- SafetyNet 2.2.1
- Shamiko-v0.3.0-73
It hid the Magisk app. Could this be caused by the dentist being enabled?
When I checked settings hide Magisk app is not enabled.
It passed SafetyNet and the device is certified.
No: LOS 17-1, Android 10, Pixel XL
Maybe oculist, not dentist
Ophthalmologist or Optometrist
The way I see it, Google are our benefactors and Android custom modders are theirs... or vice versa... if you prefer...But what restrictions?...
John originally envisioned Zygisk as a framework for more powerful hiding in addition to enhanced module capability (some 2+ years ago now?) and he HAS DELIVERED! ...
Google has NOT stymied this, have publicly stated that they NEVER opposed root, only deliberate subversion of their security model (read SafetyNet API, incoming Play Integrity API etc) and have their own weapon that doesn't involve TJW to ensure this inevitably...
They've been strengthening Hardware Key Attestation for many years now - an early form of it predates Android 6 - and, as John has said, this will surely mean the end of hiding root as we know it; we will still have ability to hide root / magisk in userspace, but not unlocked bootloader / spoof Verified Boot Status which is the start of chain-of-trust for HKA.
Until Google swing their 'Big Hammer' (in deference to Devs who want assurance / to allow their code to run only in a TEE) however, we now have the structure to allow more powerful hiding as I said, and as John said 'Its time for others to start doing their job'...
He won't / can't do it, but neither he nor Google are preventing others; note that we already have Universal Safety net Fix, WIP Shamiko and LSPosed (with hiding solutions like Hide My Applist) powered by Zygisk now...
It must be said that John has done very little to strengthen MagiskHide aside from maintaining / adapting basic SafetyNet passing and Hide the Magisk app compatibility in new devices for several years now anyway, and even these have needed 3rd party fixes (MagiskHide Props Config fingerprint prop, force basic HKA fix and so on) for some time; much work was already being done by other Devs / researchers (hiding isolated process leaks, app intent queries, ID detections etc) long before John's Google tenure... And the SN hiding he did maintain is, as he puts it, 'trivial' for others to pick up...
Note also that Google is well aware of these efforts, and while they are bound to end them all w/ HKA at any tick of the clock, they are not meantime wasting time stopping modders beat Safety net etc. as they view these (especially Magisk users) as 'a healthy White Hat community' who's efforts actually benefit Google (help them identify / fix vulns) and not as people with 'nefarious goals' (summary of Reddit comments by Android Hardware-backed security team leader)...
We can thus have fun while the sun shines, and Google is actually facilitating this to the extent that they allow it / turn a blind eye (on purpose), ENCOURAGE modding efforts etc.
The refs for everything stated above are in XDA Magisk General Discussion Thread...
I hope this summary dispells some misinformation and also helps make clear how a symbiotic relationship with a healthy modding community makes Google's Android mobile platform and IOS two completely different animals...
I trust that both modders and corporate Big G value this difference... If either party dont, they're nuts in my book. PW
That's something for hiding like better than denylist because denylist doesn't hide as magiskhide did. From what I understand.
If you're into Manga she's The Demon Girl Next Door, a 15 year old high school student w/ horns and tail...
Ii'll check that folder (if I can install TWRP or something) in order to clean up, but my goal now is to reroot it.If you flashed a stock ROM, you effectively uninstalled Magisk, except for the /data/adb directory.
No, but, I did one factory reset from Android's configuration menu in order to clean up, set up the phone and debloat it (I bought it used). It worked afterwards but I screwed up when debloating so then I did the stock rom flash.Did the flashing of the stock ROM involve doing a "factory reset / wipe data"?
I'll keep that in mind when I try to reroot.If you have a problem after trying to reinstall Magisk, the things to check are:
- did you patch and flash the right file?
- did you change the version of Magisk?
- did you change the version of Android?
Keep in mind that official instructions still state:UPDATE: I got it to work by extracting and flashing the stock boot.img and recovery.img via odin. I guess that's a dirty fix and IDK why this worked and flashing the whole stock rom didn't
although I know many Sammy users have been able to recover from this mistake without wiping data... Seems you've put your finger on the working method for your device... Not sure if trick would work for any Samsung device however, but may be useful for others...Important Notes
- Never, ever try to restore either boot, init_boot, recovery, or vbmeta partitions back to stock! You can brick your device by doing so, and the only way to recover from this is to do a full Odin restore with data wipe.
- To upgrade your device with a new firmware, NEVER directly use the stock AP tar file with reasons mentioned above. Always patch AP in the Magisk app and use that instead.
If goal is to reroot, you can leave configuration as-is... Only modules that become incompatible with later Android versions may cause bootloop, but normally the previous Magisk configuration files are OK... If you want to force a configuration rebuild (restore clean Magisk, no modules, superuser list, DenyList etc) after installation, just delete everything in /data/adb after rooted with a root explorer and reboot; configuration files will then be rebuilt.Ii'll check that folder (if I can install TWRP or something) in order to clean up, but my goal now is to reroot it.
I think you are confused. (I know I am.)UPDATE: I got it to work by extracting and flashing the stock boot.img and recovery.img via odin. I guess that's a dirty fix and IDK why this worked and flashing the whole stock rom didn't
Ii'll check that folder (if I can install TWRP or something) in order to clean up, but my goal now is to reroot it.
No, but, I did one factory reset from Android's configuration menu in order to clean up, set up the phone and debloat it (I bought it used). It worked afterwards but I screwed up when debloating so then I did the stock rom flash.
I'll keep that in mind when I try to reroot.
Thanks for your response!
Known issue. A fix has been merged. You can use the Debug app, revert back to 27001 or wait until 27003 is released.I'm now having a problem hiding the TJW Magisk 27002 app ...
I finally was able to resurrect my old Pixel 5. It's running stock A11 and was running TJW Magisk 26004 with no problem.
The Magisk manager was showing that the upgrade to 27002 was ready for installation, and so I did the following:
(1) Unhide Magisk
(2) Update Magisk (27002 was listed)
(3) After Magisk manager restarted, I did Direct Update to 27002, including reboot
(4) Magisk 27002 indeed came up properly after reboot.
(5) Tried to perform Hide The Magisk App.
I entered the arbitrary name for hiding, and I clicked "OK". But the hiding never took place.
I rebooted again, to see if perhaps that's necessary, and I repeated the hiding attempt by adding the same arbitrary name, and I again clicked "OK". But the hiding still didn't take place.
I searched my device, and there is no app nor shortcut with that arbitrary name. I also tried other, different arbitrary names, but after clicking "OK", the hiding still didn't take place for any name I chose.
What am I missing?
Only v27000 is Stable. (and Beta). v27001 and v27002 are Canary or DebugIs the Magisk 27001 APK/zip still available anywhere? I'd like to downgrade, but I can only find 27000 on Github and 27002 via update. I don't want to go to Canary in case the mounting changes break anything, or Debug as I hear the extra logging etc. causes performance issues (correct me if I'm wrong).
Yep, I told you several times that you need Recovery mode (selected) for your Ramdisk=No device; instructions for this are also clear in official Installation Instruction page too, but apparently you have not been trying to follow official instructions, so it's no real surprise you've messed up firmware too... Please take *extra* care when modding as there are simply so many variables and pitfalls!Direct Install with recovery mode checked worked for me. You were right.
After I flashed wrong CSC firmware my baseband and EMEIs disappeared. Now I have updated bootloader and I cant to flash original CSC firmware anymore. Any ideas how to restore baseband, EMEIs or it is too late?
Known problem with 27002, the debug version doesn't have the problem with hiding, read back to see the discussion about itI'm now having a problem hiding the TJW Magisk 27002 app ...
I finally was able to resurrect my old Pixel 5. It's running stock A11 and was running TJW Magisk 26004 with no problem.
The Magisk manager was showing that the upgrade to 27002 was ready for installation, and so I did the following:
(1) Unhide Magisk
(2) Update Magisk (27002 was listed)
(3) After Magisk manager restarted, I did Direct Update to 27002, including reboot
(4) Magisk 27002 indeed came up properly after reboot.
(5) Tried to perform Hide The Magisk App.
I entered the arbitrary name for hiding, and I clicked "OK". But the hiding never took place.
I rebooted again, to see if perhaps that's necessary, and I repeated the hiding attempt by adding the same arbitrary name, and I again clicked "OK". But the hiding still didn't take place.
I searched my device, and there is no app nor shortcut with that arbitrary name. I also tried other, different arbitrary names, but after clicking "OK", the hiding still didn't take place for any name I chose.
What am I missing?
Since Xiaomi eu is a custom ROM, their devs made the injector, 'module' that tricks DroidGuard and injects the spoofs with no need for Magisk/root and ZygiskThanks for your reply.
So I stay for the moment at Magisk 26.4 für my Xiaomi 14 Ultra. Because there is xiaomi.eu ROM for my phone available since 2 hours, I will flash this tomorrow und with the Module from Xiaomi.eu Team I do not need Playintegrity anymore.
So do I understand correct, to hide root I should use Shamiko? Latest Shamiko can be found here https://github.com/LSPosed/LSPosed.github.io/releases correct?