Magisk install on Pie

[anykiel91]

I have installed the latest pie stable on my op 3t. However it would never boot when installing with Magisk.

So for now I have installed it without Magisk and got it to work ok. However now I'm having same problem installing Magisk.

I can install and uninstall it from twrp latest, however when it's installed, it is just stuck on the initial screen with oneplus logo. And never makes it to the circle/dots screen.
I tried using 19. 2, 19.0 Magisk and 18.1.

Is there any logs I can pull or did anyone else have this issue?

Are there any other safe root solutions to try instead?

Any help would be appreciated

 

[ast00]

I have installed the latest pie stable on my op 3t. However it would never boot when installing with Magisk.

So for now I have installed it without Magisk and got it to work ok. However now I'm having same problem installing Magisk.

I can install and uninstall it from twrp latest, however when it's installed, it is just stuck on the initial screen with oneplus logo. And never makes it to the circle/dots screen.
I tried using 19. 2, 19.0 Magisk and 18.1.

Is there any logs I can pull or did anyone else have this issue?

Are there any other safe root solutions to try instead?

Any help would be appreciated

I always flash Magisk BEFORE the first boot. Also no custom kernels, especially not AFTER Magisk flash.
Is this what you did as well?

 

[anykiel91]

I couldn't get it to boot up before firstboot. So I went with normal nonroot flash so I could use the phone.

I figured it would not matter if I installed Magisk later.

I might try to reflash everything over again

 

[Immortalis]

I always flash Magisk BEFORE the first boot. Also no custom kernels, especially not AFTER Magisk flash.
Is this what you did as well?

topjohnwu says that you flash custom kernel after flashing Magisk

 

[ast00]

topjohnwu says that you flash custom kernel after flashing Magisk

Never had this problem until today. So I did some testing.
Magisk 19.1 causes it to get stuck at the OP logo.
I flashed uninstaller, reflashed the ROM, flashed Magisk 19.2 and it worked.
Are you using the 19.2 zip?

 

[Immortalis]

Never had this problem until today. So I did some testing.
Magisk 19.1 causes it to get stuck at the OP logo.
I flashed uninstaller, reflashed the ROM, flashed Magisk 19.2 and it worked.
Are you using the 19.2 zip?

Yes, I had problems with 19.1 too, that the phone sometimes (if not always) would boot itself into fastboot mode instead of system, so at that time I moved temporarily to canary builds

 

[anykiel91]

I used this zip instead and it worked. Not sure what's different but I'm good now
https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-3t/development/rom-theone3tos-v1-0-t3730932