[Q] ProClip Mount vs OEM Samsung Mount

[cam815]

I'm debating on which car mount to get for my Fascinate. I have a Zagg Invisibleshield on the back and the SGP Ultra Crystal protector on the front, so allowing for a case is not a problem.

Option #1) Samsung Galaxy S i500 Vehicle Navigation Mount
http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/cell-phones-accessories/ECS-M985BEGSTA

It seems to fit perfectly and there are some great pics here. It looks like there is a micro USB plug that activates the Car Cradle app but that's 100% useless to me since it launches all the Microsoft/Verizon crap. I'll be using Google Maps/Navigation anyway. I'm also not quite clear as to how the cradle itself gets power. The cradle also seems to cover the 3.5mm headphone jack, ruining any chance of me using the phone as audio input in my car (I don't have a Bluetooth stereo). The biggest plus? I can get it for $30-$40, depending on how lucky I get online.

Option #2) The ProClip Car Mount
http://www.proclipusa.com/brodit-de...cord-for-fixed-installation-513192-18363.aspx

Customized to the Fascinate, dedicated charging adapter that, with a little wiring, won't use up your DC port. It leaves the 3.5mm jack open for use. The drawback? The $80 pricetag, PLUS the $30 mounting plate you need for it. That's pretty pricey but almost looks worth it...

Option #3) Some other generic swiveling mounting clip

Any worthwhile experiences anyone wants to share?

 

[nunyazz]

Proclip 10000%
I've had 3 different proclips for different phones. Best mount on the planet. VERY well made and the vehicle mounts are made specifically for your car.

Not cheap, but very well worth it. I probably went through 6 or 8 mounts before finding Proclips.

Here are some pics of my iPhone cradle in my Acura TSX.
http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b296/nunyazz/DSC00978.jpg
http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b296/nunyazz/DSC00979.jpg
http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b296/nunyazz/DSC00980.jpg

I just got my new Acura TL, so I need to get the vehicle mount for it, but I have the Fascinate holder and it fits great. Very sturdy, doesn't move around at all and just snaps into place.

 

[The_Tech_Ninja]

Only thing is it does not have case/extended battery support.

I used this: http://www.amazon.com/Arkon-SM415-W...SE/ref=sr_1_18?ie=UTF8&qid=1295493610&sr=8-18

 

[nunyazz]

They do make an adjustable mount for phones with cases.
http://www.proclipusa.com/brodit-de...ces-with-or-without-a-skin-875214A-13978.aspx

But, the naked versions are much nicer as far as sliding the phone in and out.
Slide it in, it automatically plugs the charger in... Slide it out when you leave the car. No buttons to push. Everything can be done with one hand.

I have searched for years to get a reliable, easy to use and functional mount for my cars. This is by far the best one on the market. I've spent a hundred dollars on all the other mounts and threw them all in the garbage after getting the ProClip.

 

[danwanna]

I have both of the Samsung mounts and the ProClip and I say ProClip all the way. I liked the look of the Samsung with the charger built in, but it is really difficult to get the phone out. I dropped my phone more than once trying to get it out one handed. Also, the suction cup mount on the Samsung mounts are the least flexible/customizable of any I've used in the past.

The ProClip holds the phone securely while still allowing for quick and easy docking and removal. You also can't beat the mounting locations and options they provide.

If you can afford it, go with the ProClip.

Oh and a side bonus is that you can access the headphone jack on the ProClip so you don't have to wait for Froyo...