Review: Rhinoshield Case/Bumper and Screen Protector

Rennat

Senior Member
Oct 18, 2008
123
9
0
For the past 2 years, the screen protector I have had on my previous phone (OnePlus One) was made by a successful Kickstarter company by the name of Evolutive Labs. The screen protector's main focus is protection and in my experience it has lived up to all the claims they make about it. I originally bought it for my OnePlus One because the phone was about as large of a phone as I would own, and as a result I didn't want to add any more size/bulk to it without leaving it unprotected. Below I have included a link to the videos of them pounding it with a hammer, my first impression review when I originally got it, and pictures of how my phone now. I have dropped my phone several times within the past two years and the phone's edges have racked up a beating; however the screen has never cracked and I have grown accustom to it being safe from drops.

(1) Evolutive Labs videos on the Rhinoshield Screen Protector: http://www.evolutivelabs.com/pages/rhinoshield
(2) My previous first impressions when I got the screen protector 2 years ago: https://forums.oneplus.net/threads/rhino-shield-first-impressions-install.75686/
(3) Wear and Tear to the phone over 2 years without a case, but the screen protector did it's job in protecting the screen from all the drops it sustained. This will give you an idea of the real world protection it provides.
IMG_0128.jpg
IMG_0129.jpg IMG_0130.jpg IMG_0131.jpg IMG_0132.jpg IMG_0133.jpg

Over the past two years, it has done its job very well at protecting my phone from all types of drops and such. It is made of a hard plastic so it does end up scratching over time. After about the first year, it had several scratches on it. These where from normal wear and tear, several drops, and me dragging it across a dirty bus floor (face down) with my foot after I dropped it under the seat. Fortunately, they do have a lifetime replacement program for the screen protectors and I was able to get it replaced for shipping cost in my situation a year ago. I asked Evolutive Labs about the scratching and they replied:
Most of our competitors' use tempered glass while we use plastic tpu. Plastic will not be able to reach 9h hardness; polymer is weaker against scratches but much stronger against impacts. The device itself receives much more protection from our screen protector (even if the screen protector itself scratches more easily) because plastic will never break. For tempered glass, once it's broken, the screen is no longer protected. For our screen protector, it is a simple ding.

We are working on improving this issue but it is quite challenging, however we are proud to say our screen protector is currently one of the most scratch resistant polymer protectors on the market.
I recently got a new phone, a Nexus 5X, and wanted to get a screen protector for it. I have been satisfied with the protection the RhinoShield offered so I got one. I also saw that Evolutive Labs have came out with a low profile bumper that can protect your phone from 11 ft drops. The Nexus 5X is a bit smaller and I was intrigued by it so I got that as well.

For basic information about how the Rhinoshield screen protector feels that isn't device specific, see my first review linked above (#2). All the information I said in that review is still correct about the quality of the product. The tl;dr version of that review is that it feels harder than most plastic protectors, has a great visibility/clearness, touch responsiveness doesn't suffer, it doesn't peal up if installed somewhat decently, and the cutouts/fit for the OnePlus One are great. Here are pictures of how it fits and looks on the Nexus 5X:
IMG_0069.jpg IMG_0070.jpg IMG_0071.jpg IMG_0072.jpg IMG_0073.jpg IMG_0074.jpg IMG_0075.jpg IMG_0076.jpg

The Rhinoshield Crash Guard Case/Bumper: http://www.evolutivelabs.com/pages/crashguard

The bumper does not add very much bulk to the Nexus 5X, especially when you compare it to the protection it provides. It has a sizable lip on the front and back that will elivate the phone from the surface. They even made sure to make the lip a bit bigger on the top back to protect the camera lens. The cut outs for the USB C, audio jack, and mic are nice and sizable. They shouldn't be an issue for most people (pictures of them below). The bumper doesn't have a nice curvature like the normal back of the Nexus 5X has. Due to this, it may feel a bit more substantial in the hand, but retains the smaller profile of the Nexus 5X when in your pocket. This is a positive thing for me because it makes it a bit easier to handle. Pulling it out of a pocket can be easier by grabbing the edge of the phone. The bumper makes it a bit easier to grip the phone when using the finger print sensor as well. The power/volume buttons are a bit mushy. They are a little harder to push and don't provide a nice click. They by no means make it 'hard' to push the buttons. I do have to use a notable more effort to click them though. This normally would have been a bigger issue, however the finger print sensor is how I turn my phone on 99% of the time. I just take the phone out of my pocket and rest my finger on the sensor on the back and it turns on. I really only use the power button when turning off the Nexus 5X.
Pictures of the case/bumper:
IMG_0084.jpg IMG_0087.jpg IMG_0092.jpg IMG_0094.jpg IMG_0135.jpg IMG_0103.jpg


UPDATE:
I got a reply from Evolutive Labs about the buttons being a bit hard to press. I have included that below. After I got the reply from them, I took off the case and pushed in the buttons a whole bunch with the purpose of stretching/wearing in the rubber. I can feel a little bit of a click and it is much easier to use the buttons now.
We are going to be honest here. Some of our customer's feel that we made the buttons too stiff and have voiced their concern about having to use more force. Nexus 6p and 5x were designed with much more sensitive buttons and sometimes feels a bit loose, so we had designed our bumper with this in mind. If your issue is afraid that you want a clear and defined buttons, then our cases is a good solution.
If you are however afraid that a light tap will not register the buttons then we are unfortunately have yet to solve this issue, but judging from my own personal experience, a week of usage with the bumper, you will find the buttons to be less stiff :)
 
Last edited:

brycekerr

Senior Member
Aug 12, 2010
511
145
0
Dayton
Just got mine in the mail today. Initial impression: love it. I own about a dozen various others including the official Google ones. This feels like it could take quite a beating and keep on ticking. It looks great with my dbrand skin as well.
Cons: 2/3 of my headphones don't fit the jack. Easy fix with a drill bit though. It also makes the phone feel substantially wider which surprisingly doesn't bother me that much. The buttons are tough to press and don't "click" as mentioned above but I'm sure it will break in.
I highly recommend.
Great review Rennat!
 

Rennat

Senior Member
Oct 18, 2008
123
9
0
Just got mine in the mail today. Initial impression: love it. I own about a dozen various others including the official Google ones. This feels like it could take quite a beating and keep on ticking. It looks great with my dbrand skin as well.
Cons: 2/3 of my headphones don't fit the jack. Easy fix with a drill bit though. It also makes the phone feel substantially wider which surprisingly doesn't bother me that much. The buttons are tough to press and don't "click" as mentioned above but I'm sure it will break in.
I highly recommend.
Great review Rennat!
I actually got a reply from Evolutive Labs about the buttons and I've included that in the OP now.

When I first got the case, the buttons where a bit hard to push. After I got the reply from them, I took off the case and pushed in the button parts of the case a whole bunch to stretch out the rubber a bit. Now I can feel a noticeable click from the power button. They definitely ware in.

I can agree with you that it does make it seem a bit wider. It doesn't bother be at all either. I believe this is because it doesn't actually add any bulk to the back so it is still very thin in my hand and pocket.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brycekerr

danielzyy

Senior Member
May 21, 2011
149
16
0
Don't.
I got mine few days ago, and I got so disappointed I just shipped it back and asked for refund.
This bumper is total crap.

My Nexus 4 was guarded by Google's original bumper for 3 years! and I LOVED it. It was perfect!
Then I bought Galaxy S6 which was guarded by Spigen Neo Hybrid EX - and it was PERFECT. True bumper!
Then I traded my S6 for Nexus 5X cause I just love AOSP and ofc the very first thing I did is to order a bumper.
Sadly there arent many options out there. So I ordered this one.

It is only 1 layer - not 2 like the Neo Hybrid EX or the Google's one - it just a piece of cheap plastic that makes your side buttons IMPOSSIBLE to press - and they charge 25$ for it. Just sad.
 

brycekerr

Senior Member
Aug 12, 2010
511
145
0
Dayton
A: Read the description and look at the pictures. Nowhere does it say it is dual layer.
B: If you give it time and work the buttons like Rennat said the buttons
click fine (i agree this is an oversight on their part)
C: I am still envious of the official bumper from the Nexus 4... It was an awesome product. But i still maintain this is the best bumper for the 5x for the time being
 

danielzyy

Senior Member
May 21, 2011
149
16
0
A: Read the description and look at the pictures. Nowhere does it say it is dual layer.
B: If you give it time and work the buttons like Rennat said the buttons
click fine (i agree this is an oversight on their part)
C: I am still envious of the official bumper from the Nexus 4... It was an awesome product. But i still maintain this is the best bumper for the 5x for the time being
I didnt say he said it's a dual layer. I wanted to emphasize that.
And I dont agree with the "should give it some time" - a product should work fine right away, and not after "some time". Especially with this tag price.
 

BigHulkDiesel

Senior Member
Dec 3, 2009
110
22
0
I initially felt the same way about the buttons, they are VERY hard to push. This makes taking a screen shot very difficult. However, it is beautiful on the phone. It shows the full back, and if you use a tempered glass screen protector, it is the perfect combination. the buttons (rubber) loosen up over time. You will appreciate it.