[review] Whitestone Dome Glass

kellybrf

Senior Member
Nov 16, 2007
1,380
339
103
After lots of hype and anticipation the Dome Glass finally went up for preorder on Amazon today (https://www.amazon.com/dp/B078JR1HTN/_encoding=UTF8?coliid=I1TW2EEPYOB6KA&colid=348Y83I4OO9QD&psc=0). They've sent me a review unit, which just arrived on my doorstep. I have to admit I'm a bit nervous as I've never done an install like this before. I'm also a bit curious since the glass itself appears to be flat. Here are a few pics of the package contents and protector, I'll get it installed shortly and post more.




 

kellybrf

Senior Member
Nov 16, 2007
1,380
339
103
not going to lie, installation wasnt the smoothest thing in the world but its on. it did take two tries, though that is partially my fault. in the installation video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PMr68wi0Rw0) at 1:30 when they pull the pin to drop the protector on the bubble nicely hits the glass and starts to spread right before they pull it. it was not quite as nice of a spread my first try, and i waited until the adhesive had gotten a bit too far down which caused some bubbles. thankfully they provide good cleaning instructions and a second bottle of adhesive. their video is way better than i could have done, but two differences are that you need to place stickers over the speaker grills and pads on the sides. the pads are really tight on the left side with the buttons, so its best to put the pad in place before the phone goes in the tray.

as for the protector itself, i think it is the best we have available for sure. it is full adhesive, and the feel is fantastic, like using the phone naked. at least initially the oleophobic coating is great and fingerprints are non-existent. of course, well have to see how that holds up over time. i dont have any touch sensitivity issues like i experienced with the various dot matrix protectors. despite being flat it does cover the entire view able display, albeit just barely. i was a bit surprised/disappointed to find that the edges werent curved and if i try i can notice the edge of the protector when swiping from the sides. that said, it doesnt effect performance at all and it probably helps the protector be more case friendly than it would be otherwise. as you can see from the pictures there are no issues with my ghostek cloak, and i think case compatibility is an issue with the gs8. i think there is the faintest hint of halo though, so time will tell if that is an issue or my eyes just looking for something wrong. there is some adhesive residue along the edges that you can see in the pictures. i cleaned it up a bit and have no worries that it will come off over time. it also looks worse in the pictures than it is in reality.

all that said, at least right now this is the best option out there. it may not be the unicorn perfect protector, but i think it checks off all the appropriate boxes and is in a completely different class than anything else on the market.




 
Last edited:

elimli

Member
Dec 6, 2017
7
2
0
I don't understand how the glass could be flat. The protector either doesn't cover the screen or has "liftings" on the borders.
 
Last edited:

uicnren

Senior Member
Jun 19, 2007
1,239
440
113
easy enough to figure out, simply lay the protector on the screen to see how it fits prior to actually installing it.
 

Pkt_Lnt

Recognized Contributor
Dec 26, 2011
7,895
5,802
253
SLO
despite being flat it does cover the entire view able display, albeit just barely. i was a bit surprised/disappointed to find that the edges werent curved and if i try i can notice the edge of the protector when swiping from the sides. that said, it doesnt effect performance at all and it probably helps the protector be more case friendly than it would be otherwise. as you can see from the pictures there are no issues with my ghostek cloak, and i think case compatibility is an issue with the gs8.
A *flat* dome?!? wtf...... :rolleyes:

Now I'm not disappointed that it sold out. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: ehaze

GridironTrenches

Senior Member
Dec 6, 2012
169
26
58
the curved edges are cool for scrolling up and down. avoids selecting the wrong things but perhaps companies want to increase the probability of screen repairs or replacements
 

Pkt_Lnt

Recognized Contributor
Dec 26, 2011
7,895
5,802
253
SLO
shows "Full coverage" with rounded coverage... yet is flat. And theyre asking for 50 for this? I'll stick with my wet apply that has actual full coverage and unlimited free replacements.
Which screen protector is that "wet apply that has actual full coverage and unlimited free replacements"?
 

cdig

Senior Member
Aug 11, 2016
164
26
0
How do you get free replacements from iqshield?
write a 3* review on amazon.



hmmmm are there any other 'flat' options out there thats not $50?

I swear i had similar style flat protectors for my iphone 6 back in the day that just covered the flat part of the screen, that wasn't weird dot matrix stuff.
 

AndrasLOHF

Senior Member
Jan 7, 2013
2,875
2,065
0
Ugh....the wait continues. For 50 bucks I expect the thing to curve perfectly over the edges with full adhesive. Not be a flat protector that really doesn't need the added headache at installation and cost. Hard pass.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Pkt_Lnt