Stock GT-P1000 Headphones

[Ichijoe]

Hello I was given a used Galaxy Tab as a gift last year. It didn't come with any Headphones though.
I tried to use the Ones that came with my Galaxy S (GT-I9000), but it doesn't seem to work with it though.
I'm sure there are those here that have both the GT-P1000 (or its nearest relations), and the stock Headset.

If that's the case I'd like to ask you if it were possible to post a picture of the Headset, and the Mic / Answer Button and or Volume +/-.
So I might be better able to have an idea of which version I need to get.

Thanks.

 

[priyana]

Mine is stock. It only has an answer button. No volume up and down.

Sent from my GT-N7100 using XDA Free mobile app

 

[Ichijoe]

View attachment 2760585
Mine is stock. It only has an answer button. No volume up and down.

Sent from my GT-N7100 using XDA Free mobile app

Funny those look almost... (If I do not dare say) like the exact pair I got with my Galaxy S (GT-I9000). It also only has the Answer & Hold Button on it, yet I don't know why these just don't work on my Tab, or my Fathers Tab, (both GT-P1000 GSMs BTW) either.
So I think I can rule out a Hardware fault. Seems unlikely that two different units would develop the exact same fault. And I can reproduce this with his set of i9000 Headphones on his P1000 as well.

The sound is generally monotone I'd guess the Left channel if I had to, and the Button is ignored. as well as the Mic.

I don't think I ever left the Tab in a "Stock" state for more then an Hour over the course that I've had it. But I'd like to ask you anyway just to rule the possibility out. Are you able to still use that Headset after installing a Custom ROM? I can't see how it would affect it, but, lesser things get broken in such ROMs all the time.

To describe my problem as such when I insert those Headphones into my P1000. I get a strong Left Channel monotone output. That make everything sound very tinny. The Call / Hold Button doesn't seem to be working either. Using normal Phones I'm able to enjoy better (i.e. normal sound). But of course it harder to take or make calls from the Tab.

I'm just guessing that somehow that this Headset is somehow incompatible with the Tab (P1000), and I'm trying to track down a pair that are.

But again thanks

 

[priyana]

I haven't used my tab for phone calls for years.
But the stereo works for music.
I listen to podcast on beyond pod, and music on Neutron player. Both sides of the earphones are equally strong.

Sent from my GT-N7100 using XDA Free mobile app

 

[Ichijoe]

I haven't used my tab for phone calls for years.
But the stereo works for music.
I listen to podcast on beyond pod, and music on Neutron player. Both sides of the earphones are equally strong.

Sent from my GT-N7100 using XDA Free mobile app

Specifically those Phones (as pictured), or just a normal pair of Cans?
'Cause those (i.e. Cans), work just fine for me too. But, I'd like to be able to take a call with out having to take my Tab out, take the call, and have to press the Speakerphone Button TWICE so that I can hear who I am talking to, and to be heard myself. And yes my P1000 has pretty much kicked my Galaxy S to the Curb these days...

 

[priyana]

Specifically those in the picture.
It is the only pair I have on my bedside table
One of these days I should be trying out the phone/data function again. I have been using my tab purely as a wireless tablet so far.

 

[Ichijoe]

Specifically those in the picture.
It is the only pair I have on my bedside table
One of these days I should be trying out the phone/data function again. I have been using my tab purely as a wireless tablet so far.

Thank you very much for this info. Its been most helpful... I guess I really should just run an nandroid backup (to save myself from having to re-download everything again..., and restock this hunk'o junk back to factory gingerbread just to be sure. But as i've seen on another thread (I think it may have been the for OmniROM...), the Audio Out (on the Docking Station), also fails to work under it, and CM11 as well. Which I have also confirmed. It has since only lead me to question if these problems really are somehow related...

In any case I have ordered a pair of hard plastic White Phones that were also reportedly shipped with the P1000

I hope I have a bit more luck with these then I did with my stock Phones that came with my Galaxy S though....
They should be hopefully be here tomorrow, or Friday by the latest, given that Thursday is a National Holiday here in Germany.
So I'll report back with what findings as I can when they come in.


P.s. One last question are you on a Stock ROM or not?
In any case normal three pin Jacks work just fine on my P1000, its only the Headset that came with my Galaxy S (which has Four Pins (as pictured above), that doesn't. It has also been pointed out that you have to press a bit harder to get all Four Pins to connect. Which is kinda true if you weren't aware of the fact. Which I am, so I can't press the jack any deeper then it already is though.

 

[priyana]

I am on Omni. But prior to this I was on the last of Terenceng cm11. Before that I was on AOKP SGT and way before that I was in overcome.
The earphones has always been working in all those as far as music is concerned.

Regarding docking, I think it is an entirely different issue. The audio goes via the many pin connectors.


Sent from my GT-P1000 using XDA Free mobile app

 

[Ichijoe]

I am on Omni. But prior to this I was on the last of Terenceng cm11. Before that I was on AOKP SGT and way before that I was in overcome.
The earphones has always been working in all those as far as music is concerned.

Regarding docking, I think it is an entirely different issue. The audio goes via the many pin connectors.


Sent from my GT-P1000 using XDA Free mobile app

Again thank you very much for taking your time to respond. Its greatly appreciated!
In any case I decided to make a nandroid backup and restock.... Just to be sure.
And, I would like to state that I got this Tablet used as a birthday gift from my old man last October, it may have had stock Phones originally, but I never saw 'em. I've been trying to get it to work with my Galaxy S Phones, but these do not seem to work, even if I'm currently at the moment in a pure Samsung stock, and not rooted state.

I can only surmise that the Phones that came with the Galaxy S (GT-I9000), are somehow incompatible with the P1000. Which is on the whole odd given that they look just like the Ones in your Picture. I'm gonna guess its how the hold button part is wired up that makes it just different enough not to work. So I'll just have to wait and, see if those White Ones will somehow work better once the get here.

I also tried the Dock again as more of a goof then anything else, and Sound as well as HDMI-Out presumably works as well durr....
So thankfully I think I can rule out some kind of Software Bug as the cause of this. I just wish I knew the part number of your Headset so i could re-order it either from Samsung, or off Fleebay. As I much prefer those kind to the harder plastic White Ones. But, at this point I'd be happier if they just worked!

 

[Ichijoe]

Thank you very much for this info. Its been most helpful... I guess I really should just run an nandroid backup (to save myself from having to re-download everything again..., and restock this hunk'o junk back to factory gingerbread just to be sure. But as i've seen on another thread (I think it may have been the for OmniROM...), the Audio Out (on the Docking Station), also fails to work under it, and CM11 as well. Which I have also confirmed. It has since only lead me to question if these problems really are somehow related...

In any case I have ordered a pair of hard plastic White Phones that were also reportedly shipped with the P1000

I hope I have a bit more luck with these then I did with my stock Phones that came with my Galaxy S though....
They should be hopefully be here tomorrow, or Friday by the latest, given that Thursday is a National Holiday here in Germany.
So I'll report back with what findings as I can when they come in.


P.s. One last question are you on a Stock ROM or not?
In any case normal three pin Jacks work just fine on my P1000, its only the Headset that came with my Galaxy S (which has Four Pins (as pictured above), that doesn't. It has also been pointed out that you have to press a bit harder to get all Four Pins to connect. Which is kinda true if you weren't aware of the fact. Which I am, so I can't press the jack any deeper then it already is though.

As I had promised to do I shall write a quick review of the above Headset Model Number EHS61ASFWE(GH-59-11129H) F* (For the Galaxy Tab GT-P1000)... First off these unlike my Stock Phones that came with my Galaxy S (GT-I9000) DO INDEED WORK!! on my GT-P1000. alas their is always a "catch" though. This "Catch" it seems to only Work in Stock ROMs (As being currently tested on my GT-P1000 which has been re-stocked back to Gingerbread v2.3.3.

I have not tested CM10... (From 20130203), the only "Decent ROM" I know of against this "Headset" yet, but although Stereo out, and the Mic seem to be working in OmniROM the latest build (As of this Writing...), the Call & Hold Button is totally being ignored as if it weren't there. In a totally Stock Samsung ROM though they do work....

I'll try some other ROMs first with CM-11 SGT7 ROM (as I'm in love with KitKat at the Moment. If that fails... (As it likely will... I'll fall back on Jelly Bean and, hope that does the trick....)


*EDIT' I tried these on the most recent CM11 SGT7 -- [ROM]SGT7 CM11.0 UNOFFICIAL [4.4.2][P1/L/N][Kernel 3.0.x][2014-05-25] The Button works well here as a Play / Pause Button for Music. I can even Take incoming Calls by just pressing the Button. Though I can NOT seem to hang-up on calls though. Pressing the Button only seems to mute the Mic. on my end. I'm gonna post a bug report about this in the
[ROM][4.4.2] OmniROM Official Nightlies for p1ln, that the the Headset isn't working as expected under that ROM. Hopefully someone can fix it.


*FYI I was able to find these on Fleabay for 'round 5€'s if anyone else is in need of such a Headset. I'd have preferred the "Black In Ear" style myself. But I have no Model / Order Number upon which to work with. And these Headsets are NOT the same, as these, as wouldn't ya know it DO NOT work on the Galaxy S either.

 

[rpzk]

Those headphones works for the p1l?

 

[Ichijoe]

Those headphones works for the p1l?

Yes the Ones I Pictured and named... EHS61ASFWE(GH59-11129H) F** work on stock Samsung Firmware!!*
I've noticed that these, and other "P1" (Wired) Headphones have White Bands where as the Phones that came with my Galaxy S (GT-I9000) have Black Bands. What I don't know, or can be sure of is if this ... Color Code, means anything. But these Phones such as they are DO NOT work on my Galaxy S (GT-I9000), in the exact same way as the Phones from that Phone DO NOT work on my Tablet GT-P1000.

Problem is I've just made the jump to a Bluetooth Headphone, and now my biggest complaint is on how to route System Alerts, and Ringtones to the Bluetooth Phones, without being channeled though the internal Speaker(s). (Come on Google FIX THIS!)

* As it is these Phones work as expected on the Stock ROMs. Call & Hang up, Play & Pause.
They do NOT work at all on the OmniROM.... Bar the Stereo out, which continues to work. But the Button is totally ignored.

On [ROM]SGT7 CM11.0 UNOFFICIAL [4.4.2][P1/L/N][Kernel 3.0.x] The Button is working for Play / Pause, and though you can take calls with it, it seems that pressing the Button again only mutes the Mic., and does NOT actually hang up the Call.

Its worth noting that YMMV, depending on which flavor of the P1 you have, and which ROM you find yourself on. But, if they work on Stock... (Which these do!), then they should work for most ROMs as well.

** You can find these on Fleabay by searching for EHS61ASFWE they generally go for ~5€ new.

 

[rpzk]

Thx a lot! :thumbup:

Sent from my GT-P1000 using XDA Free mobile app