I'm in a weird predicament.. been running A11 rooted for ages, decided to upgrade to A12. Followed all the original steps that people have success with..
1. D/L the full october A12 from Google website.
2. Extracted boot.img, patched it with magisk 23. Disabled my magisk modules.
3. Installed the A12 firmware. Let it boot once with regular boot.img
4. Reboot to bootloader and flashed my patched boot.img.
But now when I run Manager, it is showing as "Installed: N/A" for the boot image and I lost root! I even tried the posted October A12 boot.img in the thread and it is same behavior.
I even tried uninstall magisk manager before flashing boot.img as post above had some problems with that but still no luck.
I see OP says full flash with wipe is necessarry for permanent root, but I'm not even getting temporary.
Edit: Oh well will try full wipe flash and see how it goes.. man why did I think today would be a good day fiddle with my phone