Suggestion about "thank you" posts

Chef_Tony

Retired Forum Moderator
Sep 8, 2008
1,839
506
0
i don't know if this is worth the work that might be necessary to be put in or if it is even possible, but hear me out:

i am active on a lot of forums and i have seen that lately, many forums switch their policy on "thank you" posts, forbidding users from creating new posts, just to say thank you. instead, most implemented a feature, that gives you a button at the end of every post, next to quote and quick reply... that is meant for thanking the original poster.

the idea behind it is to keep threads clean, so that even in a section with many visitors, it is easy to find relevant information.
some rom threads here have so many posts (most of which just "thank you"s), that the chefs have a hard time finding actual bug reports or constructive criticism. often, in tutorial threads, all the thank you posts make it hard to find actual questions of people in need.
i am mostly supporting newbie users here and writing tutorials and i like it, when people actually appreciate my work, but by doing it with a button instead of a text, everything would stay a lot cleaner.

somehow i feel, that in my new section (blackstone), "thanks" is the new spam clogging the forum.
especially threads like the blackstone nrg rom thread (http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=562952) with 17,945 Replies and 2,834,609 Views are a good example to profit from my suggestion but also every other rom thread, tutorial thread or FAQ thread would be better off
 

pulser_g2

Admin Emeritus / Senior Recognized Developer
Nov 27, 2009
19,538
11,594
113
You can rate threads using the star buttons up at the top of the page already, but not a post in particular.
 

svetius

User Experience Admin
Dec 23, 2009
4,521
7,964
263
You know, we actually built this feature a few months back. At the last minute, we killed it for some reason. If there is a lot of support for this idea, we can re-investigate, but for now you can show your love for a thread by rating it.

Sent from my Nexus One using XDA App
 

Agent Zach

Senior Member
Feb 10, 2009
539
17
48
31
Prophetstown, IL
I'd support the idea of a Thank You button here on xda, but with the number of users on daily... even hourly, that's THOUSANDS of Thank Yous'... which will increase the database size ginormously... and possibly jack up the Post Bit Legacy format... Just my two cents, though I haven't Administered a vBulletin board & database since 3.7.2. I'm not sure about the new features implemented in the 3.8.x series.
 
Our Apps
Get our official app!
The best way to access XDA on your phone
Nav Gestures
Add swipe gestures to any Android
One Handed Mode
Eases uses one hand with your phone