I will be interested in what you think as I ordered the same UAG and Samsung rugged cases as well as the ArmadilloTek.
Tried them all for about 3 hours each today and think I am going to go with the UAG (even though 3 times the price!). My subjective opinion of each:
UAG
Pros
- Good solid case with sufficient bumpers to protect the phone without feeling too bulky.
- Have used UAG on Note 5, 7, 8 and 9 with no issues. Never had a problem with the edges becoming loose over time
- Most importantly it feels good to hold. I like the feel of its texture and it has subtle, slightly soft ridges down the sides that prevent the prevent phone from slipping, but aren't hard on the hands.
Cons
Expensive!
No built in kick stand
Samsung
Really wanted to like this case, but the rubbery sides made my hands feel sweaty
Pros
- Looks like it is well made and fits well.
- Kick stand
Cons
- Unpleasant to hold
ArmadilloTek
Pros
- Case that looks like it would protect the phone the best out of the 3.
- Has ridges down sides to prevent phone from slipping - but they feel much more "hard plastic" than the equivalent UAT ones.
- Kick stand
Cons
- Largest of the 3 cases as it has the inner plastic liner that you have to put on top.
- Hated the buttons. They hardly stick out so I kept finding I had to look at the phone to locate the button. Also all 3 buttons are hard to push so adjusting the volume was a pain.
- Case felt very hard to the touch. I tired of holding it after a short period