Too Root Or Not Too Root?

N1NJATH3ORY

Senior Member
Aug 16, 2010
1,053
181
83
Hi all i own a Tab s 8.4 LTE for a good year or so i did not trip Knox due to warranty and stuff.. But a month or so ago i found out about Viper4Audio so me flashing Twrp to install viper4audio tripped knox, yeah i know i could have not tripped knox.. if i installed viper4audio apk but the dam thing wouldnt work until i flashed it. Anyway once i heard viper audio wow im blown away now when ever i listen to the S8+ the audio does not sound as good as the tab s. So im wondering is it worth rooting ? the ones who have rooted do you regret rooting ? or shall i wait will root ever come for the S8+ EXYNOS With out tripping knox or am i dreaming for that ?
 

the_scotsman

Assistant Forum Admin / Moderator Committee
Staff member
Jan 30, 2006
30,944
24,035
253
NSW, Australia
There will never be a way to root without tripping Knox I'm afraid.

You just have to decide if it's worth it for YOU.

You will lose warranty. You will lose things like Samsung Pay, Samsung Health, other banking apps, though sometimes this can be worked around.

I owned the S7E before owning the S8+, and it was the first time I have ever owned a phone that I didn't root it. It's a hard choice, but warranty is more important for me, along with Samsung Pay, Samsung health etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: N1NJATH3ORY

sireniankyle

Senior Member
Sep 21, 2012
427
79
58
I chose to not root my S7 edge, and the only thing that bothers me is video ads on youtube. otherwise I can live just fine without it. Custom roms tend to be too unstable for me, anyway. I won't root my S8+, assuming it ever comes out for the SD variant (bought it for dolphin, and I got it from Samsung for $524).
 

Amar.B

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2013
644
255
93
Khartoum-sarajevo
I don't recommend you to root your phone you will loose Samsung pay feature for good plus your warranty. I can tell you yes it's a bit boring without having the ability to modify your phone but you can live without it. I think the stock rom is quite good and satisfies my needs . So again don't do it

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
 
  • Like
Reactions: N1NJATH3ORY

Andrewtst

Senior Member
Aug 4, 2009
4,831
1,785
0
Johor
No root for me. Root is history for me since two years ago.

Don't see the needs of it already. Maybe they is still one or two nice apps that need root. For the sack of that one or two apps really not worth to root and trip Knox.
 

wrexed03

Member
Jul 2, 2012
20
4
0
Melbourne
Same rooted my s7 edge just to play and get more out of it. I will leave my new s8+ Alone. Battery is great would love the customizations with root but its good enough as it is. Only thing i really miss is viperaudio. Anyone know of a way this can be installed without tripping knox??
 
  • Like
Reactions: N1NJATH3ORY

e753

Senior Member
Mar 9, 2011
295
26
0
I have the same question...

I always rooted my phone since Froyo.

I basically need it to: browse on internet "safe" and to use titanium backup.

I guess I can use some adblocked browser (any suggestion?), but I do not how to backup and restore the apps.. Any idea how to resolve it?

THank you!
 

ggrant3876

Senior Member
Jun 17, 2009
2,010
594
193
Wichita Falls, Texas
I have the same question...

I always rooted my phone since Froyo.

I basically need it to: browse on internet "safe" and to use titanium backup.

I guess I can use some adblocked browser (any suggestion?), but I do not how to backup and restore the apps.. Any idea how to resolve it?

THank you!
First phone since the T-Mobile G1 I haven't rooted and I've had 12 smartphones since. There's nothing as good as Adblock but I'm not rooting the S8+ and am using Blokada from XDA.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/an...da-fire-forget-root-ad-blocker-t3503374/page2
 
  • Like
Reactions: roaduardo

roaduardo

Senior Member
Apr 27, 2016
1,357
574
0
I'm joining the growing choir of new S8 Plus users who have decided to leave rooting behind them. It was fun and extremely useful for me up until this S8 Plus. My Note 5 will be the last device I root. It's just not worth the hassle any longer. Lately rooting has become too much of a chore on this platform for me, personally. I've kept Samsung as my daily driver for years because one of the reasons was that traditionally it was much easier to root compared to other devices. This was especially true when I was with Sprint as they never locked down their phones like Verizon and AT&T did.

At this moment, as far as rooting is concerned, I have the same feeling I did when I finally said, "Enough!" when I was jailbreaking my iPhones. Eventually I grew tired of the cat and mouse game between devs and the OEM. This feels the same and I think it's time to say goodbye to rooting flagships for me.

Now I feel that the combined hardware and software development on this phone has matured enough that I'm okay rolling clean and stock from now on.
 
Last edited:

shiftr182

Senior Member
Oct 5, 2010
1,929
1,135
143
Boise
I have been rooting since the beginning of Android, every phone I've had. I stopped using Samsung in 2013 and went to LG, then to Google (Nexus 6P, then Pixel XL), and now back to Samsung. I was honestly a little disappointed with the Pixel and how difficult it was to flash because of the dual partitions. I am in the US, and the US S8 was a no go, as I don't appreciate a phone that I buy outright being locked down. I ended up getting the SM-G955F, and rooted it the first day I had it. It was so simple, and so worth it. I feel like its 2013 again with how easy this thing is to modify. I have Viper installed, and customized to my liking, and my ROM is bloat free.
 

jb_alphamale

Senior Member
Apr 11, 2011
725
145
0
I have a Canadian S8 Plus and I've rooted all my Androids since the first Motorola. Like others I don't think at this moment rooting would bring me anything really exciting. I've installed Adhell 2 and got rid of the ads and backed up everything with the pc smart switch. I'm missing the volume warning disable mod because I found it annoying but even that one is not that bad if I don't restart the phone. Starting with S6 the best ROMs were always stock based and that became more and more evident lately so until something really new is coming up I'm going to stay unrooted. I'm with Bell and there are only 2 apps which I would not want them so basically no bloat. My 2c.
 
Last edited:

EMJI79

Senior Member
Sep 7, 2014
1,940
209
83
Paris
I have the same question...

I always rooted my phone since Froyo.

I basically need it to: browse on internet "safe" and to use titanium backup.

I guess I can use some adblocked browser (any suggestion?), but I do not how to backup and restore the apps.. Any idea how to resolve it?

THank you!
You can get rid of ads with AdGuard.
I am hesitating to root also.
I used Titanium backup until now and if someone has an alternative I would be glad to hear it too.
 
Last edited:

jb_alphamale

Senior Member
Apr 11, 2011
725
145
0
Did you try Helium? The paid version has many features but it will only backup some apps vs Titanium. Because of missing root it will not be able to backup apps that have "backup disallowed" enabled.

You can get rid of ads with AdGuard.
I am hesitating to root also.
I used Titanium backup until now and if someone has an alternative I would be glad to hear it too.