which modules would you like to see for the lg g5

raynan

Senior Member
Jan 2, 2011
1,127
576
0
Maybe a co-processor module just because. Maybe a super low power one for while the device is in idle or later down the line, we could add the next SD?
I would also like to see them release the source code/kernel for the modules to use in custom ROMs; AOSP and those modules would be perfect.
 
S'all Good Man! But who needs 32 bit audio res? Very few are taking advantage of the old 24 bit audio from the days of DVD-A or similar. It's all compressed mp3 mostly, no? 24 has over 130 db dynamics, no? How many people has got 24/192Khz setup with high-end speakers, these days? I can't think of anyone, it's just compact or HTPC.

The camera module is pretty nice though. Maybe modules for gaming or turning the G5 into a full desktop/laptop computer? :D
 

volcolm

Senior Member
Jan 20, 2013
158
21
0
S'all Good Man! But who needs 32 bit audio res? Very few are taking advantage of the old 24 bit audio from the days of DVD-A or similar. It's all compressed mp3 mostly, no? 24 has over 130 db dynamics, no? How many people has got 24/192Khz setup with high-end speakers, these days? I can't think of anyone, it's just compact or HTPC.

The camera module is pretty nice though. Maybe modules for gaming or turning the G5 into a full desktop/laptop computer? :D
Some folks listen to FLAC but most people still wouldn't pass a blind test. FLAC and WAV carry the same data 1:1 in a checksum test, and a 1:1 studio recorded WAV sample is 32-bit, not 24. In this use case, the DAC is handling the entire audio stream instead of skipping every 8 bits. This is my theory anyhow, most other devices are 24-bit.

Not certain how a device can make 128K YouTube videos any better, however: I've tested some things with clipped MP3's that people said were impossible to do, since it's not a "raw sample" (remove clipping and extra noise), and that's is using free software. It might be possible for an IC to handle this on demand and upscale by resampling and dithering using mathematical formulas, but you'd still be changing the sound signature by doing so. What happens in this case is that 'lost' data is "made up" using signatures from preceding and following samples.
 
Last edited:

volcolm

Senior Member
Jan 20, 2013
158
21
0
Desperately hoping for some sort of gamepad design to surface but its surprisingly hard to find any module info outside of the ones announced by LG itself

Are people just waiting to see if the phone even takes off first?
I would certainly hope not, multiple articles have LG stating that it would open its design for interested parties wanting to develop accessories. And on top of that icing on hypothetical cake...

LG is teasing hard, aren't they? The last product flash in that video, hinting a printer attachment, but with every device doing BT or WiFi, I can totally see that working as well as a GameBoy Printer - just don't see the point (but still interesting).
 

technoturk

Member
Oct 5, 2010
8
1
0
-home/menu/back navigation hardbutton
- 360 cam
- gamepad for games
- extra ram
- laser rpm meter
- ssd
- 32 in 1 card reader
- sigaret lighter
- solar panel charger
- gas & smoke meter
- oxygen level meter
- HYGRO meter
- car/bike tire presure/barometer
- videocard
- usb host hub
- 1gbit lan
- rtl u2832 sdr radio
- mitutoyo micrometer
- (laser) temp C/F thermometer
- oscilloscope module
- multi meter module
- solder iron module
- laser pointer
- IR remote hardbutton module
- RF remote module
- hard button keyboard
- sub woofer
- dvb t/s/c/ tuner
- infrared cam
- optic zoom cam
- X-RAY camra
- ultrasone cam
- microscope 2000x
- weight scale
- 18+ toys
- pragnancy tester


To much ideas every thing with hard buttons and things outside the software
 
Last edited:
Some folks listen to FLAC but most people still wouldn't pass a blind test. FLAC and WAV carry the same data 1:1 in a checksum test, and a 1:1 studio recorded WAV sample is 32-bit, not 24. In this use case, the DAC is handling the entire audio stream instead of skipping every 8 bits. This is my theory anyhow, most other devices are 24-bit..
Yeah, I've been involved in studio recording since the early 1990s, so using 32-bit resolution makes sense, but there's a big difference between that an mobile audio or compact audio, as often is the case. For me, 24/96 (maybe 192) is more than enough, whatever I listen to. :) I still have a Tascam pro DAT-deck, with optional removable copy ID function. Since those days. :p
 

Harmtan2

Senior Member
Feb 26, 2013
271
75
0
Salt Lake City
Lg has already said they'll open it up to 3rd party's. :)

Sent from my LG-H811 using XDA Free mobile app

---------- Post added at 05:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:37 PM ----------

I would really like to see Hardware Buttons, clickable or even capacitive, make a comeback as a module - perhaps with an extended battery of its own. I would hate to waste the space at the bottom of the phone which could be used to enhance the user experience and free up screen space for a less restricted view of my apps. This is coming from somebody who has phone with on screen buttons - I REALLY DISLIKE THEM... Yes I know that there is something called immersive display mode or whatever it is called, but quite frankly i hate having to swipe up first and wait for the navbar to pop up and become fully usable so that i can go back to the home screen. I do quite a bit of cycling and because of it I need a phone (other than the Samsung lineup of crappy, bloat-filled, "smart" phones) that gives me instant access to navigational features.
That is something so simple, but I get it would sell really well.

Sent from my LG-H811 using XDA Free mobile app
 

Chocolina

Senior Member
Oct 16, 2012
201
22
0
The Hi-fi module peeks my interest the most, but honestly, the "module" thing is BS. In less than 365 days from this point, everyone is going to be talking about LG's flagship of 2017.

Assuming LG is going to keep the ball rolling on this "modular" design, the 1st thing LG is going to do for the G6, is improve on the criticism the current modular design for the G5. They're likely going to make it less clunky, more streamlined. If they change anything about what G5 modules need to work, then compatibility on future models is broken. So alot of what people may not like about the G5 will have to carry onto the G6 to keep compatibility with the modules; because if they don't, and they change dimensions, or functions then all G5 modules are instantly obsolete, locked to the G5's time-frame at the cost of improving their take on modular.

So why spend $70-$200 on a fancy module for the G5, if I'm just going to sell it with my G5 when I'm ready to upgrade. If the module
s can't transcend the G5's model, then it defeats the purpose of "module" that Project Ara started.

But personally, I think "module" wasn't the initial design going into the G5. They were trying to slim down the G5 and go metal, and the sliding battery was their solution. The bottom cap to the battery, which houses the speaker, mic, and possibly 3.5mm port would need the hardware components to work making the actual hardware of the phone two parts. Because the bottom part contained components and was needed to make the phone work, someone on the design team probably had the idea that if the bottom thats still a crucial component to the phone can be detacted, why not make accessories with different functions. I really think they were trying to figure out how to keep the removable battery, and "modules" were just a happy accident because a true modular phone would have several detachable pieces.
 
  • Like
Reactions: badger1000

orbital247

Senior Member
Feb 22, 2009
179
38
48
I would really like to see Hardware Buttons, clickable or even capacitive, make a comeback as a module - perhaps with an extended battery of its own. I would hate to waste the space at the bottom of the phone which could be used to enhance the user experience and free up screen space for a less restricted view of my apps. This is coming from somebody who has phone with on screen buttons - I REALLY DISLIKE THEM... Yes I know that there is something called immersive display mode or whatever it is called, but quite frankly i hate having to swipe up first and wait for the navbar to pop up and become fully usable so that i can go back to the home screen. I do quite a bit of cycling and because of it I need a phone (other than the Samsung lineup of crappy, bloat-filled, "smart" phones) that gives me instant access to navigational features.
Absolutely spot on underyourbed, i would pay for this in a heartbeat.