Xperia Z vs HTC One Complete Video Comparison (Full HD)

Status
Not open for further replies.

wyterabitt

Senior Member
May 1, 2011
70
16
0
I mean seriously? You have got to be kidding right? Have you watched that vid? the part where all 3 phones are at the youtube part and the display is suppose to be black but its greyish on the Z? Subjective my a%&.
Except I can't replicate that, on full brightness, no auto, I just loaded up youtube and got a black screen on a video and it looks nothing like in this video. It also doesn't look like that in the service test. Or am I only supposed to believe what you say and any videos that you happen to want people to look at and nothing else?

You cannot call it washed out against a different type of screen that technologically is guaranteed to be able to do blacks better - that is just silly so immediately we are down to between two screens. Add in the reflection in the Z not in the Nexus in the video (which is a problem that can be debated, I have a problem with that) along with the fact I can't actually replicate this effect on an Xperia Z in my hand in front of me and yes it is subjective and not a proven fact at all - and I'm not trying to say it is a proven fact the other way in case that is what you think as it's not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dpk1

nazrin313

Senior Member
Mar 6, 2010
595
91
0
I had a play with the htc one in the shops yesterday and compared the screen with my XZ. Note that only on the homenscreens thou, with both devices set on adaptive lighting they are 100% similar but with both devices at 100% brightness with adaptive settings off the htc wins hands down.

But the htc ones im the shops had build issues thou, minor gaps between the speaker and the body, jagged usb ports and even on of them ( i actually took out 3 units) the power button was flush on the left side and protruded on the right.. Baad baad htc

But should i find a perfect one I would definitely consider getting one.. I kinda like it, already have the S4 for the wife, so im guessing owning the top 3 phones in the world is a definite win hahah
 
Last edited:

pandaball

Inactive Recognized Developer
Oct 18, 2011
2,391
1,738
113
I mean seriously? You have got to be kidding right? Have you watched that vid? the part where all 3 phones are at the youtube part and the display is suppose to be black but its greyish on the Z? Subjective my a%&.
I used the service menu test for display, I can't replicate the grey-ish "black" in the video at all. It looks perfectly black to me.
 

zodiac100

Senior Member
Aug 19, 2010
795
216
0
I laughed so hard ( im not kidding nor trolling). Haven't you noticed that since the HTC One and S4 have been released, the Xperia Z became an after thought?

And why are you comparing it with the One? Im a samsung guy i could care less you bashing HTC. But in all honesty, the HTC One is an all around better device than the Xperia Z. I have some time to kill so here we go:

The HTC One is/has:

- A better display ( even the One X has a better display than the Xperia Z)
- Faster, better SoC
- Arguably a better design ( never have i seen a phone getting so much praise for its design and build, to the point that it becomes annoying)
- Faster UI
- Better sound quality ( amazing speakers vs you know)
- Better low light performance in camera

You bark about millions of folks falling in love with the display? Dont make a fool out of yourself, every review that i saw/read say that the display on this thing is a let down because of the washed out screen, sharpness is good. Im sure if you could trade for the HTC One display you would do it in a heartbeat. Get out of here, you're grounded. Call me when the XZ sells more than the Galaxy S 4.

---------- Post added at 09:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:57 PM ----------



The HTC One has received praises all over the tech world. And you comparing it with the Xperia play? ...... Now you sound desperate.
Who gives a **** what a small minority of tech geeks say and do on the web. The people who matter are the consumers and they have embraced the Z in large numbers while the HTC One has been overlooked.
If you're too stupid to understand the crux of my argument then that's your problem.
I wasn't comparing the One to the play technically, I said both devices were misguided in their conception.
The simple truth is techstreet might prefer the HTC One but mainstreet has voted overwhelmingly for the Z. If I were a manufacturer, I know who's vote I'd much rather have and it ain't that of the geeks.
I return back to my starting point, the Z is a smash hit. Talk as much crap as you will about it. It's immaterial, you can't touch it. It's much much bigger than you.

Sent from my C6603 using xda app-developers app

---------- Post added at 08:44 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:41 AM ----------

The Haze thing is that white shade, kinda like white smoke thats on the screen. I may sound like a Xperia Z hater but im not. I love the design and the UI of the phone and probably would have bought but i cannot stand this screen.
All this talk is getting boring. Who gives a damn what you can't stand, if you don't like it, don't buy it. I didn't see Sony holding a gun to anyone's head.

Sent from my C6603 using xda app-developers app
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dpk1

barondebxl

Senior Member
Jul 8, 2011
7,857
2,028
0
San Diego, CA
Who gives a **** what a small minority of tech geeks say and do on the web. The people who matter are the consumers and they have embraced the Z in large numbers while the HTC One has been overlooked.
If you're too stupid to understand the crux of my argument then that's your problem.
I wasn't comparing the One to the play technically, I said both devices were misguided in their conception.
The simple truth is techstreet might prefer the HTC One but mainstreet has voted overwhelmingly for the Z. If I were a manufacturer, I know who's vote I'd much rather have and it ain't that of the geeks.
I return back to my starting point, the Z is a smash hit. Talk as much crap as you will about it. It's immaterial, you can't touch it. It's much much bigger than you.

Sent from my C6603 using xda app-developers app

---------- Post added at 08:44 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:41 AM ----------



All this talk is getting boring. Who gives a damn what you can't stand, if you don't like it, don't buy it. I didn't see Sony holding a gun to anyone's head.


Sent from my C6603 using xda app-developers app
The One has been overlooked uh? Right. The Z became an after thought since the One and S4 came out. If you enjoy the inferior phone, good for you :)

Ill keep giving my opinon, if you don't like it you can blow it out your a$$. " mainstreet has overwhelmingly voted for the Z...." where? You have a poll?
 
Last edited:

doministry

Senior Member
Sep 25, 2008
4,242
431
0
Bytom, Poland
doministry.blogspot.com
The One has been overlooked uh? Right. The Z became an after thought since the One and S4 came out. If you enjoy the inferior phone, good for you :)

Ill keep giving my opinon, if you don't like it you can blow it out your a$$. " mainstreet has overwhelmingly voted for the Z...." where? You have a poll?
I think your comments continue to be just silly and thoughtless.

BTW yes, techsites are often awfully biased these days. They don't even try to give equal credit to all the top devices on the market.

Yes, Z made a great vibe across the average users and HTC just didn't. Neither SGSIV which is disappointing compared to what SGSIII was.
 

zodiac100

Senior Member
Aug 19, 2010
795
216
0
The One has been overlooked uh? Right. The Z became an after thought since the One and S4 came out. If you enjoy the inferior phone, good for you :)

Ill keep giving my opinon, if you don't like it you can blow it out your a$$. " mainstreet has overwhelmingly voted for the Z...." where? You have a poll?
I think we're looking at things from different angles. I'm talking about consumers and you're talking about tech sites.
Well the day tech sites start buying phones in their millions, then and only then will your argument begin to make sense.
But until then, you're talking pure nonsense!
You represent a small minority which very much typifies HTCs problem, they just don't appeal to a wide enough audience to stay viable as a company.
It's not a pageant show for tech sites and their followers to judge which is the greatest phone.
It's a very competitive market place and manufacturers need to produce devices that have some form of common denominator to appeal to a wide base. The htc one just doesn't have that factor. It's a techies phone, and not because it's the best but simply because it contains the latest raw specs. Never mind that the implementation of these specs are lacking in inspiration, the fact that they're present are enough for the look my phone's got bigger numbers than yours crowd a.k.a geeks!.
I come back to what I've been saying, the Zs surpassed all expectations. It's a success story and if Sony carry forward that same momentum into the second half of this year, and with the upcoming Honami, we can see them even surpassing the Zs performance, they'll certainly finish 2013 very happy bunnies indeed.
Shows really how much influence these tech sites have doesn't it.
Just a small meaningless minority who shout loudest. Well it's time for the majority to speak now and they have. The verdict? Z yes, HTC One No!

Sent from my C6603 using xda app-developers app

---------- Post added at 05:17 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:44 PM ----------

Wow! this started with me saying the Xperia Z's screen & speakers weren't good... Is the HTC One having quality issues, yup... (if I were a fanboy I wouldnt be saying this) but my own device has been sent back...

Ill give you the following...

- Yup HTC seems to have QC issues (I wasnt aware at the time of making the video since nothing major was reported but when returning my own I started noticing some ppl have reported issues) - Sony doesnt
- HTC and only HTC is responsible for the One's delays - Sony has stock and better supply
- The camera on the XZ is better, lets have it... I said I prefer the One's camera and that doesnt mean I said its better and Ive said multiple times from the 1st page that the XZ performs better in lights... I have no idea why u keep going back to the cam

What I disagree on is...

- HTC One or no HTC One, for the price I (and you all) paid we deserve a screen with better viewing angles (irrespective of whether u use it straight at most times or not) How do u expect me to do a comparison where I dont point that out?
- Same thing with speakers... I did mention it was because of water proofing... I believe the ear piece is more important to a phone than waterproofing...
if you arent going to buy into the the whole a lower resolution camera for better low light performance argument then how come you are buying into lower ear piece output for waterproofing? if you are going to scream Switch on the Damn Light you fools, why cant a HTC One user scream back Keep your damn phone out of water you Fool? am not trying to insult, I really am not... I just dont get it... Both phones have a tradeoff "a feature not all will use" for "something all will use"... you get so annoyed at one while you support the other... how is that not biased?
Stop using words like deserve a display with better viewing angles. For most, viewing angles are,a minor detail which brings us back nicely to my point about geeks and their insane fixations.
There are many other phones on the market with great viewing angles, you have many to choose from. No one's forcing anyone to buy the Z are they?
Also your point about the waterproof feature of the Z shows your lack of understanding.
It's not about going swimming or taking a shower with your phone.
It gives an added layer of security, an insurance policy of sorts.
These high end devices are very expensive and if you can't see why people would find a phone which can survive water comfortably appealing, then to be honest there's not much else I can say to that but 'you really don't understand marketing'. You've got to have something to market in the first place. The reason why you see so many Z ads about is because it's got a feature that people actually want to talk about. Retailers know this and exploit it. The marketing isn't all Sony's doing directly, others are promoting the phone on their own because they know it's an easy sell. I don't think Sony's paying all these retailers to push the Z so hard. The simple truth is, the retailers themselves know they're on to a winner and push it of their own volition. There's much commission to be made and they're making it happily.
Anyway, all these conversations about the Zs display, speakers blah blah blah have already been discussed at length in countless posts before. There's really no need to start it up again. To what end? The phone's doing very nicely in the hands of millions. Sour grapes I guess from the HTC crowd.

Sent from my C6603 using xda app-developers app
 
Last edited:

Dpk1

Senior Member
May 24, 2012
806
244
0
The One has been overlooked uh? Right. The Z became an after thought since the One and S4 came out. If you enjoy the inferior phone, good for you :)

Ill keep giving my opinon, if you don't like it you can blow it out your a$$. " mainstreet has overwhelmingly voted for the Z...." where? You have a poll?
Dude.. giving your opinion on anything is fine, but forcing it on.. that's not cool! Now, having read this entire thread, all I get is your whining about XZ screen which is quite lame imo as you don't even own one! On the other hand the screen seems totally fine to the actual owners of XZ. I mean, you are welcome to post your opinion & I do get that you don't like the XZ screen, but you should understand that it gets boring (even annoying) to read the same complaint over n over & that too from a non-owner.

I have the XZ and I chose it over the GS4 for various reasons & my preference of the XZ screen over the S4's being one of them. I am not saying that XZ screen is better than S4 (I like S4's better blacks & wider viewing angles), only that I find it (XZ) more useful for my use (as in daylight viewing, crisper/sharper text while browsing, better white balance). As for the HTC one, I have my reasons for not considering it & screen is not one of them. Having said that, I agree that sony could improve its screen in certain aspects (esp. black levels & wider viewing angles), not that they matter a lot to me but because they might to others.
 
Last edited:

ethan3686

Senior Member
Aug 19, 2009
1,161
135
0
India
Just a calm comment from me

The One has been overlooked uh? Right. The Z became an after thought since the One and S4 came out. If you enjoy the inferior phone, good for you

Ill keep giving my opinon, if you don't like it you can blow it out your a$$. " mainstreet has overwhelmingly voted for the Z...." where? You have a poll?
You are wrong..Galaxy S4 i agree has taken over [not as big as S3 in terms of praise] but definately sales..And i see what you did there..You are trying to make it as BOTH htc one and S4 have achieved that..No my man..Thats just the S4 and the power of Samsung marketing!

As far as HTC ONE goes, i went to a local seller and asked him about the release date of ONE..and he told me its already released long back and he ACTUALLY showed me the HTC ONE X :p

I would never hope bad for HTC but they have axed their own foot..confusing names, ads, marketing..They were the first android phone..I hope they dot crumble..So much nostalgia..

HTC One sales are nowhere near the Xperia Z..And i am not talking about total sales as that would be unfair as htc has released later..But the sales in same amount of time..In fact Note 2 still sells more!
 

barondebxl

Senior Member
Jul 8, 2011
7,857
2,028
0
San Diego, CA
Dude.. giving your opinion on anything is fine, but forcing it on.. that's not cool! Now, having read this entire thread, all I get is your whining about XZ screen which is quite lame imo as you don't even own one! On the other hand the screen seems totally fine to the actual owners of XZ. I mean, you are welcome to post your opinion & I do get that you don't like the XZ screen, but you should understand that it gets boring (even annoying) to read the same complaint over n over & that too from a non-owner.

I have the XZ and I chose it over the GS4 for various reasons & my preference of the XZ screen over the S4's being one of them. I am not saying that XZ screen is better than S4 (I like S4's better blacks & wider viewing angles), only that I find it (XZ) more useful for my use (as in daylight viewing, crisper/sharper text while browsing, better white balance). As for the HTC one, I have my reasons for not considering it & screen is not one of them. Having said that, I agree that sony could improve its screen in certain aspects (esp. black levels & wider viewing angles), not that they matter a lot to me but because they might to others.
i don't own one but i have held it. To each his own. The XZ isn't a bad phone by any means, but i don't wanna repeat myself. Actually i just said earlier that the screen was crap and someone overreacted and defended sony as if thy get paid by them. If i feel like the XZ has a subpar screen, why hate? Its my opinion but if someone gets mad at it i could care less. I do respect your opinion though not like the other fanboys.
 

randomuseresato

Senior Member
Jan 30, 2013
156
77
0
^

ALL your 1000 posts in this Z forum have been the same - XZ has such a bad screen blah blah blah. Don't you get bored posting that same thing ?

And since you're buying the S4 why the **** do you care about Z screen so much ? Did your gf leave you because of Z's bad screen or something ?

Please, just stop this crap. Your opinion isn't worth more than mine or anybody else's. In fact in this forum your opinion is worth LESS than REAL owners.

So just stop with the drama
 

Zigurat

Member
May 14, 2009
30
5
0
I hate the way how this debate is going... to each his own. I like how the author wanted a critical feedback, shows maturity on his part, yet so much hatered... :( I own a XZ and love it. My previous phone was the Gnex. As for the screen debate - MY honest opinion is that the screen is great with nice colours, yet hate the washed out effect when i glance at the screen from the side during lectures or sth. I agree that a as a flagship, Sony could have done better, but still during normal use its not much of a bother.
As for the camera, its great. Best Ive had so far. I cant compare it to the HTC and wont because the targets are in MY opinion different. HTC is on the bottom and had to find a gimmick to help it get back on top. If it had a 13 MP camer, it would be one of the many, compared to S4, XZ, LGG etc. and they probably couldnt really measure up based on their past cameras. Yet by inventing a cool new name (remember FaceTime anyone :D) and studying the market, they decided that a 4 MP camera would suit most people needs. I mean how many people print phone pictures or view them pixel by pixel. The majority of people want to have the new and the best yet they dont utilise their phones to a great extent beyond, email, internet, fb, album, youtube, mp3 and some other basic stuff. And for those people, 4 MP should be enough, based on HTC's opinion. (Though I agree that lack of onscreen zoom on full hd screens is a bit of a downer). And so far its working great for them. A nice stylish body, with great screen and a fancy named camera to differentiate them from others... I hope they can rise up again and we can see a top of the line competition from them!
Software-wise - blinkfeed is in MY opinion a gimmick, yet thats only my opinion, but I believe they did some sort of a market research before doing sth so radical. But the option to turn off should have been present imo. Sony's software on the other hand is clean and efficiont, the way I! like it.

Just my cup of tea on some of the points :D Ty for your review and for trying to be constructive and cool headed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ashwin123
Status
Not open for further replies.
Our Apps
Get our official app!
The best way to access XDA on your phone
Nav Gestures
Add swipe gestures to any Android
One Handed Mode
Eases uses one hand with your phone